Social Profile: 
✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Old-school pizzeria featuring specialty pies, calzones, pasta dishes & salads in a homey atmosphere.
Address and Contact Information
Address: N 63 W23951, Main St, Sussex, WI 53089
Phone: (262) 820-8669
Website: https://tonymaronni.com/
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Tony Maronni’s – Sussex, WI
California grown Roma tomatoes, locally made Mozzarella & hand crafted Artisan dough. Complemented by only the best & freshest locally sourced meat’s & …
Tony Maronni’s Pizza | Sussex WI – Facebook
Hello everyone. Thinking about pizza? Then think about Tony Maronni’s, Sounds good for dinner tonight, See you soon. Call NOW 262-820-8669 or order online …
Tony Maronni’s Pizza, N63W23951 Main St, Sussex, WI 53089, US
Tony Maronni’s Pizza, located in Sussex, WI, pays homage to the rich heritage of Italian cuisine by prioritizing the integrity of its ingredients.
Reviews
Lupe Macias
We went there last night for the 1st time. My wife & I are Vegan & we were able to have a very delicious Vegan dinner! We shared the house salad, the dressing was awesome (just had them remove the meat & cheese), the fried eggplant without the cheese also & a veggie pizza, again no cheese extra sauce. The crust was perfect as well as all the toppings! We also had a very sweet, funny & energetic server, named McKenna. We will definitely be back & we highly recommend Tony Maronni’s!!!
… moreLisa Komppa
Ordered online 1 hour before pick up time of 5:15. I was tracking the order & tracking indicated it was ready a 6 minutes after scheduled pick up time. I went to the counter & at first, the person said they couldn’t find my order then he said oh it’s right here. I will go back and check. He went in back and started talking to somebody else and, from the back, he told me my order will be ready in a few minutes. It was at that time that they actually started preparing my order. As I had plenty of time to sit and wait for my pizza, I started noticing how dirty the waiting area is floor and counter are filthy. There are several workers but they all seem somewhat clueless. Finally ended up getting my pizza 25 minutes after my expected, pick up time 5:15. Nothing makes me more angry than wasting my time
… moreArturo Jimenez
Well after coming out of Holy Hill Mass at 11:00 am I originally was about to go to Fox and Hound restaurant. I had discovered this hole in the wall Italian restaurant that’s not too bogie and was in my budget and was craving for Italian despite being in Wisconsin. They are known for their pizza but I wasn’t craving for pizza since I had pizza yesterday. It was good. Service was a bit slow but friendly. The sandwich was delicious with the meatballs I didn’t know it was a meatball sandwich and their lasagna is very fresh and homemade the calamari was delicious too and it was not too battered very light with the marinara sauce. It’s interesting that the owner Tony himself is married to a Filipino but he was very nice and kind. As well as generous giving some biscuits. Four out of five stars because of the fact that I wish he had more entrees besides pizza but they’re very quaint and kind of hole in the wall but those are usually the good places to go to near holy Hill church. 3 out of 4 stars because I was hoping they would have other traditional Italian dishes like Alfredo Linguine or Fettuccine or Spaghetti but maybe it is a lot of work. Anyways that is my review.
… moreEmily Every
A Happy Accident we found this place, we will be coming back. We had very good service and as promised the pizza was great. We had the the New Yorker with black olives on thin crust, a must try.
… moreTanya Bohacheff
We’ve had take out, dine in and delivery. We really enjoy Tony’s pizza— it’s our go to pizza place in Sussex. Love the cheese garlic bread too!
… moreShelly Walker
McKenna was absolutely amazing. Give her a raise. Our food took a little bit longer than normal because they had a large order ahead of us; we did not complain nor draw any attention to the wait, but they chose to give us all larger size pizzas as an “apology” for the slight delay. Friendly service (shoutout McKenna again, we love you) and great food.
… moreBrendon Crippen
Great pizza and very friendly staff! Best pizza in the area in my opinion! We’ve tried Sal’s and Pepinos and a few others but we keep coming back to Tony’s! They never skimp out on the toppings either, a little on the pricey side but sooo worth it! The pizza pictured was a XL pepperoni and smoked bacon pizza for about $30
… moreDevin Herritz
I’ve been here before and the pizza was decent. I got a coupon in the mail so my wife and I ordered a pizza today. It was so hard I couldn’t even chew the crust. Seems like they must have burnt it. Any other day I would’ve taken it right back, but we were so hungry we decided we’d try to deal with it. We literally had 1 piece and had to give up. Super disappointed because I could’ve probably gotten 2 pizzas from dominos or something for the same price.
… moreLana Bahr
We moved to the area 7 years ago and started going to Toni’s for our pizza and we love it! There’s a young man named Owen who is very pleasant and does a great job with customers… We’re happy to have good pizza so close to home…
… moreDee Hulte
Had a pizza delivered, wasn’t hot and I had requested a very light crust, which was dark brown, black around the edges. I couldn’t use my butter knife to separate the pieces. Was told one charge on the phone but $1.14 more appeared on my card. I called to inform of the bad pizza and was told “they couldn’t do anything about it”. Businesses nowadays seem to be so busy they don’t have to care whether a customer is happy or not.
… more