Social Profile: 
![]()
✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Address and Contact Information
Address: 1259 N Hamilton Rd, Gahanna, OH 43230
Phone: (614) 532-0061
Website: https://tonyandenzos.com/
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Related Web Results
Tony & Enzo’s Pizzeria – Best Pizza in Gahanna, OH
Carryout Pizzeria located in Gahanna, OH offering NY Style Pizza and Detroit Style Pizza for Delivery or Pick-up. Menu offerings also include toasted subs, …
Tony & Enzo’s Pizzeria | Gahanna OH – Facebook
1259 Hamilton Rd, Gahanna, OH (614) 532-0061 Hours: Sunday: 12PM – 8PM Mon–Thurs: 3PM – 9PM Friday: 11AM – 10PM Saturday: 11AM – 10PM Order tonight and …
Tony and Enzo’s Pizzeria (@tony_and_enzo_official) – Instagram
Whether you’re craving a classic slice, loaded specialty pizza, wings, or subs, we’ve got your next meal covered. 1259 Hamilton Rd, Gahanna, OH (614) 532- …
Reviews
Konstantinas Grajauskas
I’ve ordered from this place quite a few times now, and they’ve quickly become one of my favorites. Their New York–style thin crust is spot-on — it actually reminds me of home. That’s hard to find in Ohio, where most places go for a cracker-thin crust instead, so it’s a real treat.
Their plain cheese pizza is perfect, but their specialty pizzas are where they really shine. The chicken bacon ranch and the Tuscan chicken are some of my go-tos, and there are several others I’ve loved (I’m blanking on the names, but they’ve all been great).
If you’re looking for real NY-style thin crust or just want consistently good pizza, this place is absolutely worth a try.
… moreTheir plain cheese pizza is perfect, but their specialty pizzas are where they really shine. The chicken bacon ranch and the Tuscan chicken are some of my go-tos, and there are several others I’ve loved (I’m blanking on the names, but they’ve all been great).
If you’re looking for real NY-style thin crust or just want consistently good pizza, this place is absolutely worth a try.
Kyle Burton
Edit: Updated with photos. The merchant lied and changed the description instead of admiting the likely unintended misrepresentation as an ohio style pizza. I should of added my recipt as I added cheese and sauce to the pizza and ordered directly through them adding to the cost.
Note the receipt says Ohio Style XL
Then the topping underneath. the menu photo they missed deleting that has no mention of new York style (delted all the photos that said “ohio style”).
I’d suggest labeling as ezzo pepperoni pizza or cupped pepperoni as I think ohio style is still misleading.
That being said im willing to come at a later date and give it a second try as I hope it was just a bad experience. I dont like giving bad reviews and I understand bad days happen.
Original:
FLOP! NOT OHIO STYLE OR COLUMBUS STYLE
I was pretty excited about this pizza good reviews, ezzo pepperonis and ohio style but the pizza was a total flop and got worse the more I ate.
I got an XL ohio style pizza. NOT OHIO STYLE (ohio valley style) OR COLUMBUS STYLE (thin crispy and square cut)
3/10- ill start with the good.
Crust- would have been pretty good if it was just a but more done nice edges and bite yet super floppy overall
Cheese- Generic, looked really good but wasn’t anything special. too solid and instead of stretching comes right off the pizza.
Sauce- smelled and tasted like an open can of tomatos. The sauce was raw and so acidic it felt like I ate a battery. The sauce had no seasoning. (A little salt or basil would have went a long way) it tasted like a low quality newyork style neapolitan hybrid.
Pepperoni- this was the only thing that tricked my first bite into being a 6/10. Ezzo cupped Pepperonis are top tier and carried this whole pizza and there was very few pepperonis.
Overall I would not go back almost $30 for a low quality pizza even thought the staffs was very friendly.
… moreNote the receipt says Ohio Style XL
Then the topping underneath. the menu photo they missed deleting that has no mention of new York style (delted all the photos that said “ohio style”).
I’d suggest labeling as ezzo pepperoni pizza or cupped pepperoni as I think ohio style is still misleading.
That being said im willing to come at a later date and give it a second try as I hope it was just a bad experience. I dont like giving bad reviews and I understand bad days happen.
Original:
FLOP! NOT OHIO STYLE OR COLUMBUS STYLE
I was pretty excited about this pizza good reviews, ezzo pepperonis and ohio style but the pizza was a total flop and got worse the more I ate.
I got an XL ohio style pizza. NOT OHIO STYLE (ohio valley style) OR COLUMBUS STYLE (thin crispy and square cut)
3/10- ill start with the good.
Crust- would have been pretty good if it was just a but more done nice edges and bite yet super floppy overall
Cheese- Generic, looked really good but wasn’t anything special. too solid and instead of stretching comes right off the pizza.
Sauce- smelled and tasted like an open can of tomatos. The sauce was raw and so acidic it felt like I ate a battery. The sauce had no seasoning. (A little salt or basil would have went a long way) it tasted like a low quality newyork style neapolitan hybrid.
Pepperoni- this was the only thing that tricked my first bite into being a 6/10. Ezzo cupped Pepperonis are top tier and carried this whole pizza and there was very few pepperonis.
Overall I would not go back almost $30 for a low quality pizza even thought the staffs was very friendly.
renae resendez
We got a Togo order and upon opening the boxes at home, we were pretty excited. The deep dish dough just wasn’t it though. It was doughy with no flavor. now in my head I do compare this to Jets deep dish, which is top 2 for me,so take that into consideration for your own personal preference. The Tuscan specialty on the deep dish also didn’t help. The ingredients were good but it did not come together well. I would be curious to try it on their regular crust as we also got a cheese in that style and that pizza was superior by far. The red sauce was pretty good balance of sweet and savory which a lot of places find hard to do so I appreciate that. The price point is fairly on par with what the quality of the ingredients are but seems high when you compare price point with other places with similar style pizzas.
Will try again because the service was great, the online order was easy to use and the time estimate was very accurate.
… moreWill try again because the service was great, the online order was easy to use and the time estimate was very accurate.
Tatyana Gutierrez
I rarely do reviews but when I say this food was great. Even with the delivery taking over an hour, which I AM NOT MAD ABOUT! Just surprised the food was still good It was a Saturday so pretty good timing in my opinion. The pizza was 10/10 and made exactly how my family liked it. Even the wings were good and no lie, I get a little nervous about wings from a pizza place ♀️ but Next time I’ll ask for them to be a little more well done. I’m an extra crispy type of wing gal anyway delicious and I’ll be back to try it in person
… moreSumer C
5 stars ALL the way around! 10/10 food, service, everything! The cheesy bread was SO cheesy and had the best flavor! The barbecue chicken is to dieeeeeee for. Omg. The crispy fried onions on top was such a game changer! Also tried the chicken bacon ranch & the Tuscan chicken! Both amazing as well. All of their signature pizzas look soooo good!!! Super friendly staff! Nick was amazing and very helpful! I will definitely be back to try those cannolis and cheesecake also. My new favorite take out spot in all of CBUS!!!! YUM!!!
… moreReynaldo Cordova
Superb pie! Stopped in and got an XL pepp and half mush, along with 8 of their signature wings. Wings were a mix of bbq and some heat but a good size. Pizza was excellent. Great crust, a little flop and a great undercarriage
… moreReb S
This place was recommended to me by my son. It was very good. We got the all meat pizza. I’m new to the area and don’t like big commercial pizza chains and was very happy I tried this and really liked it. We’ll definitely be back for more. ♥️
… moreKari Drouhard
We loved our pizza. We shared a classic cheese and Tony two Times! Both excellent! We would order again! Good addition to Gahanna.
… moreJason
$41 for 2 pizzas . One regular crust medium cheese for $12.99 and a deep Dish Tuscan for $27.99 . The cheese pizza is good but not great, not as good as Frankie’s , Sextons, or even Marco’s. The deep dish Tuscan was a disappointment. Toppings were good, but you’re paying a premium for what is essentially bread . The Tuscan may be better on the regular crust, and for the price point, Jets is a better deep dish option. Service was decent, and the time quoted was accurate. Pizza is cooked in a conveyer, not a convection oven .
… moreJamie Frost
Pizza was great, I would love to have had a more traditional type of pepperoni, other than the Ohio style. Garlic bread with cheese was amazing, so much cheese! YUM
… more