Ana T.
I would prefer not to leave this review, but after many disappointing experiences, I feel it’s only fair given how much I’ve spent here.
I order pickup from here 2-4 times a month because this has definitely been my favorite pizza place for the last 4-5 years.
First issue, I ordered a salad and the vinaigrette wasn’t included. Frustrating, but it was an honest mistake.
Next time I ordered, same exact thing… Maybe it’s not included? Next order I placed, I paid for a side of vinaigrette and found at least 5 included with the order.
After that, I added a note asking to “please include vinaigrette with the salad.” Problem solved.
But then, the pizza was incorrect and very undercooked. The pizzas here have specific toppings, and if one is left off, what’s the point? I would get a different pizza. In this case, the missing topping was roasted garlic, which I consider the star of the pizza.
I ordered again, no roasted garlic… and again, no roasted garlic. This has been over several months, so it’s not just a one-time mistake, this is clearly a pattern.
Tonight, I was confident my order would be perfect. I left simple requests like “Cook well done and please include all toppings” and “please include vinaigrette.” When I took a bite of the pizza, I bit into the most disgusting, soggy pile of arugula imaginable. Just gross. I will never be able to look at arugula the same again.
A photo is included of the heap of arugula I removed from one slice of pizza.
I’m done, Tony C’s. You have officially lost a very loyal customer.
… moreMandy
The staff is super kind and thoughtful. Their lunch special offers 2 gigantic slices and the specialty pizzas are also not to be missed! The interior is incredibly spacious and has a nice vibe.
… moreCharles Springer Jr
Just wanted a small pizza with two toppings and Jess at the bar suggested are two slice special that comes with a drink. Gigantic slices, excellent food, premium service, comfortable atmosphere! I really appreciate the customer service I got from Jess at Tony C’s on Anderson Lane in Austin Texas! Loveit! It’s a true pizzeria.
… moreAdelle
Alexa at Tony C’s is absolutely amazing! Her customer service went above and beyond anything we expected. She was incredibly kind, attentive, and thoughtful with our family, and it truly made a lasting impression on all of us. It’s rare to see someone take so much care in making customers feel welcome and taken care of. Our whole family walked away talking about how wonderful she was. Tony’s is lucky to have someone like Alexa on their team!
… morerussell cavin
Great pizza and specials, love the Chicken Parm Pizza but the thing that keeps us coming back to this location is the bubbly and always happy employee, Alexa! My 3 year old was having a tough day when we came in but Alexa had her giggling and happy in no time. Love this place!
… moreAbigail614
Had the pleasure of getting Alexa today to help us find something on the menu as it is typically hard to find a pizza that I really like without tomato sauce, she suggested a pizza and it was my favorite! The interaction with her alone made me and my partner feel welcomed and we will definitely be back!! Thank you Alexa you’re great and the friendliest person we’ve encountered recently in our times of eating out!
… moreAndi May
Tony C’s is hands-down one of our favorite spots!! The coal-fired, made-to-order pizza is absolutely incredible—honestly, every pizza we’ve tried has been fantastic. You can truly taste the quality and care in every bite. The appetizers and salads are just as impressive, and the gelato is the perfect way to end the meal.
The entire staff is always warm, friendly, and attentive, which makes the experience even better every time we visit. Shout out to Jess who always takes amazing care of us and makes our visits even better with her friendliness and great energy!!
We love that they offer both indoor and outdoor seating and all of the indoors TV’s make it a perfect place to catch a game. Consistently amazing food, great service, and an overall awesome vibe. We’ll be loyal Tony C’s fans for a very long time!! 🙂
… moreRenee Riffee
Perfect for a quick, casual bite. Flavors have been great on everything I’ve tried, my friend’s wings were fried great with tons of parmesan and I got the special with drink, salad and slice of pizza for $10.99. Great deal, the slices are huge. The Caesar was dressed well and the little garlic knot that came with it was tasty. The ambiance inside is what it is, a bunch of open tables with just a few booths on one side and then the bar on the other, so laid-back and casual. They also have several TVs on for sports. Big request would be for better napkins though. A lot of what you serve has grease (which tastes amazing) but the ones on the table are so small and thin, you end up going through so many it feels wasteful.
… moreMatthew Karabi
I was there for the first time. There was a problem with timing of my food. But management and the crew took care of it as soon as possible. Pizza was good. Tasty I had the egg plant crust. I recommend it. Will be going there next time for pizza. 5 stars
… moreMaya Martinez
Had an excellent lunch experience! Friendly staff and quick service. Try the Caesar!! Perfectly dressed and so fresh. The Bianco pizza was lovely. Will absolutely come back!
… more