Social Profile: 
✔️Breakfast ✔️Brunch ✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Address and Contact Information
Address: 90 Park Ave, Madison, NJ 07940
Phone: (973) 434-9304
Website: http://tonyboys.com/
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Tony Boys NJ: Home
Welcome to Tony Boy’s Sandwich House, offering gourmet sandwiches crafted with premium ingredients across multiple New Jersey locations.
Menu | Tony Boy’s Sandwich House in Madison, NJ
Explore our menu at Tony Boy’s Sandwich House: Subs, hot sandwiches, cheesesteaks, and more. Fresh flavors in Madison, NJ. Make sure to stop by today!
Tony Boy’s Sandwich House – Madison 90 Park Ave. – Order Online
Tony Boy’s Sandwich House – Madison 90 Park Ave. · Humpty. Peppers, Eggs. $11.99 · Dumpty. Pepperoni,Eggs. $11.99 · Dip. Roast Beef , Melted Mozz Au Jus Sauce.
Reviews
Kaleena Koon
Food was great … i coulda used a lil more meat but it could be the fat girl in me. A bit pricey but for a once in a while treat could be worth it. I gave 4 instead of 5 stars cause I needed my milkshake a lil thicker but the machine only does one consistency . Good eats tho..
… moreAmy Ercole
Wanted to try Tony Boys out as a resident of Madison. Sloppy Joe sandwich is over $20 – there was basically nothing on the sandwich, minimal ingredients piled in the middle with most of the bread empty. Bread was completely stale and fell apart . Terrible – will not come back.
… moreArtemis Yun Ko
It’s a great place for when you want something nice but don’t want to go to a sit-down restaurant. The sandwiches are creative and delicious, the shakes are great, and the staff are friendly. And you may usually not think of sandwich shops when talking about good coffee, but the Columbian coffee they serve here (which includes frozen coffee cubes if you like) is incredibly smooth and delicious. I’m here at least once a week!
… moreBean Slider
Truly mid. Probably could make just as good at home to be honest. The portions on the chicken sandwich are laughable. Especially given it was the driest chicken I’ve had in a while. Cut your mouth dry. Idk why my friend even talks about this place; it’s not good. Go to an actual deli. Waste of money and time
… moreDes KF
I love good sandwiches and couldn’t wait to give this spot a try. When I arrived I parked in their lot. I walked into the shop and was greeted. I ordered with the nice man the Angry Bird and the turkey and Provolone sandwiches. I also got the oreo shake and the lemonade. It came out after about a few minutes. I really enjoyed the oreo shakes and the turkey. The lemonade was ok and the Angry bbird wasn’t too bad, a little messy but not too bad. All in all I had a good experience!
… moreJason Coley
Fantastic subs!! Great friendly service as well!! Time to open in Florida!! Thanks!
… moreDeni Dumandan
Boardwalk Hand Cut Fries
it’s 2025 and we’re still making cheeseteaks like this? Just layered like a sandwich. I guess I’m just used to everything being chopped and blended together. I mean the steak slices were still whole. Like, think school cafeteria cheesesteak. The fries were fine but the portion was a joke especially at the price there charging. one and done.
… moreit’s 2025 and we’re still making cheeseteaks like this? Just layered like a sandwich. I guess I’m just used to everything being chopped and blended together. I mean the steak slices were still whole. Like, think school cafeteria cheesesteak. The fries were fine but the portion was a joke especially at the price there charging. one and done.
Nicaluz Raagas
First time ordering from here and it wasn’t a bad deal. On uber they had a buy one get one special— so I opted in for a very basic turkey and cheese. The packaging was sustainable, and the meats and condiments are fresh. The bread, on the other hand I just didn’t like.. it’s the hard bread; which is subjective but just isn’t for me.
… moreBumpskeytv
I work in Madison and have been looking for some good places for food. I tried Tony Boy’s and the sandwich was just average and expensive like everyone else these days. I figured maybe it was a fluke because of all the positive reviews. I tried them again. I got their chicken cutlet with mozzarella, roasted peppers and balsamic vinegar. I think they call it a 10 or something. I was so disappointed. First the chicken is pounded super thin. Then the chicken is overcooked until it dry. The worst part was there was so much vinegar the bread was falling apart from it and I was choking every bite. All I could taste was vinegar. So if you are looking for a $15 vinegar sandwich this is your place. If you are looking for a great sandwich at a reasonable price this is not your stop. Very disappointing. I don’t think I will be giving them another try.
… moreStanley Moy
Awesome quick spot for lunch. Price point and value are great. You get a lot for what you’re paying for. Got the angry bird which featured vodka sauce and honey on a chicken cutlet sandwich. It was amazing and unique combo. Will definitely be back to try more of the menu since it’s so close to the office. Staff was great too.
… more