Joseph Iacono
Had an amazing meal at Tommy’s! The French onion soup was fabulous, and the Cali burger and chicken sandwich were both 10/10. A huge thank you to our waitress, Stephanie, for being so attentive and making the night great. We’ll definitely be back!
… moreLayla Depalo
We love tommy’s tavern however the last couple of times we ordered food to go the burgers were undercooked. The first time I asked for mine to be well done and was extremely undercooked. This time my husband asked for medium well and it was like half the burger was cooked and the rest was kind of raw. Also we got kids meatball and penne and the meatball had something inside of it, seems like maybe a piece of bamboo or plastic. I’m not sure we’ll be ordering again from here. Used to be our favorite place
… moreVon Chamberlain
I met my girlfriend here recently on a Wednesday after work, and it was perfect because it wasn’t too crowded. We kicked off the evening with a couple of beers at the bar. They have a great selection, including a lot of craft beers. Since IPA is my go-to, I tried a few different ones, and they were all really good. After a few drinks, we decided to order dinner, and there were so many options on the menu. We ended up sharing a pizza and a burger. The burger was amazing—I went for the bacon barbecue, and it was full of flavor and super juicy. The fries that came with it were crispy and delicious. The pizza was just as good, and the meat lover’s option was definitely the right choice. The bartenders were awesome, too. They were always checking in to make sure we had everything we needed. All in all, this place is a great spot to relax and hang out.
… moreMia Sofia
Food was good. We love Alexa she’s a girls girl. Awesome waitress, great personality, and also attentive- we didn’t feel rushed but also not forgotten. Had a great time, thanks Alexa!!!
… moreVirginia Tong
Great place at the Staten Island mall. We had two kids with us and they were very accommodating- besides the traditional crayons and placemat- the kids go some dough to make their own pizza. All our entrees were great- including poke, short ribs and sandwiches. Great food and service at a reasonable price. Will definitely return.
… moreElena Choi
foods have been so amazing!
me and my boyfriend always visit here for the flatbread and vibes
became the regular here
… moreMario DiBartolomeo
Kaitlyn was absolutely wonderful. From the moment we sat down, she was warm, attentive, and genuinely kind. She checked in at all the right moments without ever being intrusive, made great recommendations, and handled everything with ease and professionalism. You can tell she truly cares about giving guests a great experience. Her positive energy and attention to detail made our visit even better than expected. Ask for Kaitlyn if you can—she’s a standout and a real asset to the team.
… moreMargaret McCue
Big place with lots of TVs. I had a veggie burger with fries and a jalapeño pineapple margarita. The fries were excellent. The margarita yummy. The veggie burger was fine just not to my liking. They offered 1/2 price wine happy hour. The service was excellent.
… moreSmall Town Scout
Tommy’s Tavern in Staten Island is great! This place deserves every bit of a five-star rating. Their burgers are hands-down the greatest—juicy, flavorful, and cooked to perfection. I’m obsessed with their avocado burger; the creamy avocado paired with their perfectly seasoned patty is a match made in heaven. The Wisconsin cheese curds are another highlight—crispy, cheesy, and downright delicious, they’re a must-try appetizer. The staff is consistently friendly and welcoming, creating a warm atmosphere every time I visit. On top of that, the service is impressively quick—I’ve never had to wait long for a table or my food. If you’re in Staten Island looking for a spot with incredible food and great vibes, Tommy’s Tavern is the place to go to!
… moreShi
Its pretty typical mall food, but the outdoor seating option is nice! The menu is very expansive and allergy/dietary restriction friendly as a result, but perhaps because its so big the food is just okay as a result. The restaurant wasn’t crowded when we went but service was on the slower side, likely they were understaffed
… more