Social Profile: 
✔️Brunch ✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out
… View more
Trendy haunt featuring high-end, eclectic American fare & sushi, plus a happening bar scene.
Address and Contact Information
Address: 9300 Amherst Ave, Margate City, NJ 08402
Phone: (609) 822-7535
Website: https://www.tomatoesmargate.com/
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Reservations: resy.com
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Downbeach Restaurants , Tomatoe’s – Margate NJ: Upscale …
Experience upscale dining and craft cocktails at Tomatoes Restaurant in Margate, NJ. Indulge in a unique dining experience with a touch of elegance and …
Tomatoes | Margate City NJ – Facebook
Tomatoes, Margate City. 10610 likes · 92 talking about this · 39783 were here. Californian Restaurant + Sushi Bar.
Tomatoes (@tomatoesmargate) · Margate City, NJ – Instagram
What a nightmare Walk-ins always welcome. Doors open at 5pm. 9300 Amherst Avenue, Margate, NJ. Photo by Tomatoes in Tomatoes.
Reviews
Mark S Smith
Tried a new place at the shore. Tomatoes. Looked pretty encouraging on Resy. Overall it was good, maybe very good?! Service was excellent.
Our waitress Chris was top notch.
Ambiance was not great for us. We didn’t realize this was more bar than restaurant (with live music, a huge bar, and very kid friendly). For us this ended up being a loud environment where we had to yell over the out of control kids that were moved next to us. The food was pretty good, maybe slightly unrefined but tasty. My grilled octopus was mostly very good with just one piece being a little “mushy”. My baked duckling came with excellent grilled asparagus and garlic mashed potatoes.
The duckling itself was more like roasted chicken to me than true duck breast but I still ate all of it. The blueberry pie was very good (not Steve & Cookies great though
168). Generally the food portions were too big (I know, complaining about too much food!). I am not sure we would rush back since they have fine dining prices in a local bar setting, but we were glad we tried them!
… moreOur waitress Chris was top notch.
Ambiance was not great for us. We didn’t realize this was more bar than restaurant (with live music, a huge bar, and very kid friendly). For us this ended up being a loud environment where we had to yell over the out of control kids that were moved next to us. The food was pretty good, maybe slightly unrefined but tasty. My grilled octopus was mostly very good with just one piece being a little “mushy”. My baked duckling came with excellent grilled asparagus and garlic mashed potatoes.
The duckling itself was more like roasted chicken to me than true duck breast but I still ate all of it. The blueberry pie was very good (not Steve & Cookies great though
168). Generally the food portions were too big (I know, complaining about too much food!). I am not sure we would rush back since they have fine dining prices in a local bar setting, but we were glad we tried them!
Jerry
The surf and turf roll was amazing! The chicken parm portion was huge, enough for 2 full meals. Salt and pepper calamari was cooked to perfection and the service was great. Hard to get in this place in summer but off season, while it was still busy, we were able to sit right away. Great well rounded restaurant, big sushi menu in addition to steaks, seafood, chicken dishes…. highly recommend a visit if you haven’t been here. Fyi, we came by boat as they just opened a sister restaurant across the street with transient slips available.
… moreLarry Francisco
Margate offers many great places to eat, but this is by far one of my favorites. The staff are great and very attentive. If you are a fan of sushi you have your pick of an extensive menu. But if you’re just looking for some great Italian food, you will not be disappointed. I had an amazing pork tenderloin that was amazingly tender and flavorful. So much to explore and enjoy from this menu.
… moreTrevor Allen
The sushi boat and specialty rolls were delicious with fresh, high-quality fish and great flavors. The crème brûlée was outstanding, and my wife really enjoyed her martini. We’ve never had a bad meal here. We usually sit at the bar, but this time we had a table during the dinner rush. They were very busy, and I wish there had been a bit more attention to drinks. I would have had another. Still, the food and atmosphere were excellent as always. Can’t wait for our next meal!!
… moreMarc Abrams
A Margate fixture, Tomatoes ha served consistently delicious dishes for a demanding clientele over several decades. The waitstaff is professional and attentive. The sushi is fresh and well portioned. Entrees of note include crispy duck, sea bass, and pork chops. The assorted appetizers are fantastic. Recommend the short rib and octopus offerings.
… moreChristopher Ferry
I had an absolutely delightful experience at Tomatoes restaurant in Margate City, New Jersey. From the moment I walked in, the ambiance was warm and inviting. The highlight of my visit was undoubtedly the exceptional service provided by our waitress, Ashley. She went above and beyond to ensure our dining experience was nothing short of perfect. Her attentiveness, knowledge of the menu, and friendly demeanor truly elevated our evening. The culinary creations were equally outstanding – each dish bursting with flavor and expertly prepared. Whether you’re a local or just passing through, Tomatoes is a must-visit destination for a memorable dining experience. Five stars all the way!
… moreCrystal
Parking is horrible during weekend/summer. Plan accordingly .
Bit surprised how “blah” Customer service was… Expected it to be pretty good considering the cost and location. 1st time there and had no idea where to go. Hostess is all the way to the back and no one to greet/ guide you. Waitress wasn’t all that friendly, seem to be bothered when asked for recommendations – but the BUS GIRL, yea she WAS BOMB!!
Overall Food was pretty good. Ceviche, good. Sushi is a must, delicious! Cocktail drinks are a bit pricey- stick to beer.
Walk across to the pier to watch the sunset! Or dessert across the street.
… moreBit surprised how “blah” Customer service was… Expected it to be pretty good considering the cost and location. 1st time there and had no idea where to go. Hostess is all the way to the back and no one to greet/ guide you. Waitress wasn’t all that friendly, seem to be bothered when asked for recommendations – but the BUS GIRL, yea she WAS BOMB!!
Overall Food was pretty good. Ceviche, good. Sushi is a must, delicious! Cocktail drinks are a bit pricey- stick to beer.
Walk across to the pier to watch the sunset! Or dessert across the street.
L D
Loved EVERYTHING about this place! Service excellent. Drinks were yummy. The food was fabulous!! First time eating a Poke Bowl, and it was so good. I will definitely come back.
… moreDavid Lazar
Don’t get me wrong, the food at this place is really good. They have a huge menu and seem able to pull off sushi and traditional coastal cuisine really well.
My problem is, this place seems to be overhyped. It is virtually impossible to get a reservation here (we ate at 8PM on a Sunday). It just doesn’t seem to be worth the effort. There could definitely be more upscale places to eat in this part of the Shore but I will not go out of my way to grab a reservation here again.
With that said, we did have a good meal. The menu is so diverse that it was a struggle to try everything that we wanted and we probably over-ordered. We started with the Parmesan Crusted Asparagus, which was probably my favorite thing we tried. It was kind of a unique spin on a staple and very tasty. It came with a great pesto aioli. We also got the Mozzarella en Croute, which was nothing special, but tasted good on some table bread.
Our second course was sushi. We got a Philadelphia roll and a “Karen” roll. Both were prepared at the sushi counter and really good. It was cool to have such good sushi at the Shore.
For the main course, we split the Cuban Pork Chop with a side of Truffle Mac n’ Cheese. Both were also really good. The pork chop was seasoned really well and was bone-in. The Truffle Mac n Cheese was good but a whopping $11.50 for a small side portion.
All-in-all, this place has some good food and enough options that everyone will be happy. However, the high prices and insane difficulty I had getting a reservation means I will probably pass in the future. If you can grab a spot, it’s probably worth a visit.
PRO TIP: There is a cool little seating area outside that has food trucks. I couldn’t tell whether this was associated with the restaurant or not but it is definitely something to check out!
… moreMy problem is, this place seems to be overhyped. It is virtually impossible to get a reservation here (we ate at 8PM on a Sunday). It just doesn’t seem to be worth the effort. There could definitely be more upscale places to eat in this part of the Shore but I will not go out of my way to grab a reservation here again.
With that said, we did have a good meal. The menu is so diverse that it was a struggle to try everything that we wanted and we probably over-ordered. We started with the Parmesan Crusted Asparagus, which was probably my favorite thing we tried. It was kind of a unique spin on a staple and very tasty. It came with a great pesto aioli. We also got the Mozzarella en Croute, which was nothing special, but tasted good on some table bread.
Our second course was sushi. We got a Philadelphia roll and a “Karen” roll. Both were prepared at the sushi counter and really good. It was cool to have such good sushi at the Shore.
For the main course, we split the Cuban Pork Chop with a side of Truffle Mac n’ Cheese. Both were also really good. The pork chop was seasoned really well and was bone-in. The Truffle Mac n Cheese was good but a whopping $11.50 for a small side portion.
All-in-all, this place has some good food and enough options that everyone will be happy. However, the high prices and insane difficulty I had getting a reservation means I will probably pass in the future. If you can grab a spot, it’s probably worth a visit.
PRO TIP: There is a cool little seating area outside that has food trucks. I couldn’t tell whether this was associated with the restaurant or not but it is definitely something to check out!
Steffie Pinay
First time with this place. Great restaurant if you are craving of everything for dinner. If you like seafood,they have an amazing choices, meat lovers, vegan , sushi, etc. You may love their specials entrees too, so good. I recommend Keylime pie for dessert. Never regret stopping by in this restaurant. Also make a reservation if you come later than 6pm, they got busy. All in all very delicious food and great service. Thank you and stay safe.
… more