Social Profile: 
✔️Breakfast ✔️Brunch ✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Many ask “WHAT IS TOMATO PIE?” Tomato Pie Café’s Signature Dish is a Fisher Family Original. Deliciously seasoned red tomatoes are baked in a flaky pie crust, covered with a rich cheesy topping. Guaranteed to be like nothing you have ever experience before! Stop by, have a taste and experience a flavor so good we just had to name our Café after it. Deeply ingrained in our Café culture is the belief that food tastes better when you are with friends. Our customers are our friends, our honored guests! We can’t wait for you to dine in with us.
Breakfast & lunch, including the namesake pie, are served with gourmet coffee at this quaint cafe.
Address and Contact Information
Address: 23 N Broad St, Lititz, PA 17543
Phone: (717) 627-1762
Website: http://www.tomatopiecafe.net/?y_source=1_MTk1Mzc0OTctNzE1LWxvY2F0aW9uLndlYnNpdGU%3D
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Tomato Pie Cafe
-The Fisher Family. A little food. A little coffee. A lot of charm! 23 N Broad St, Lititz, PA 17543. Made with Squarespace. 735e7f941a4b9e-NV116492739.jpg.
Tomato Pie Cafe Lititz – Facebook
Details. . 94% recommend (1,940 Reviews). . $. . Opening Soon. . 23 North Broad Street, Lititz, PA, United States, 17543 ; Links. . tomatopiecafe.net/? …
The Tomato Pie Cafe (@tomatopiecafe) · Lititz, PA – Instagram
“A little food, a little coffee, a lot of charm.” Click the link to see our Spring Menu. Spring is HERE at the cafe Our Spring Menu has officially …
Reviews
English Bully
We were here on a weekday for lunch and somehow lucked into one of the best tables in the place- front left high top- with a beautiful view of the park and old Wilbur chocolate factory. I ordered the hot roast beef and hubby ordered the tomato pie. I loved my dish, but after tasting the tomato pie, I will never order anything else but that. It was melt in your mouth delicious! Do not miss it!! The greens that come with your meal are so tasty with the lemon white balsamic from Olio down the street. We also ordered a pumpkin macchiato, so good. Can’t wait to check out their other seasonal drinks throughout the year, I’m sure they’re all as unique and tasty.
… moreAnn Acquaviva
A nice surprise mid-afternoon.
First time visiting Lititz PA and first time here. Great small town country vibe with everything you’d expect from any big city eatery.
Cold brew was excellent as was the pumpkin latte (not too sweet like many from the brand name coffee houses we know). Menu was extensive with many options from salad to bowls to paninis and everything in between.
We had a delicious and very very fresh spinach artichoke with creamy ricotta over spaghetti squash. Very different. We loved it.
The help was attentive and the place was clean. They have a cute porch where you can sit and eat or sip your coffee. It was decorated in a festive fall vibe which was perfect fur this time of year.
While we didn’t try their famous tomato pie we were very happy with our choices.
… moreFirst time visiting Lititz PA and first time here. Great small town country vibe with everything you’d expect from any big city eatery.
Cold brew was excellent as was the pumpkin latte (not too sweet like many from the brand name coffee houses we know). Menu was extensive with many options from salad to bowls to paninis and everything in between.
We had a delicious and very very fresh spinach artichoke with creamy ricotta over spaghetti squash. Very different. We loved it.
The help was attentive and the place was clean. They have a cute porch where you can sit and eat or sip your coffee. It was decorated in a festive fall vibe which was perfect fur this time of year.
While we didn’t try their famous tomato pie we were very happy with our choices.
Christopher Jones
Great location right in the middle of town, nice little breakfast and lunch menu with seasonal options. We had the Summer Berry Salad, the Cilantro Lime Bowl w/ Chicken, and side of the Rosemary Potatoes. Everything was very flavorful but ended up having to go out to eat after. We were going to order a tomato pie (which you do not see that on very many menus), but everyone was trying to finish up for the day. The fogged tea was perfect! Thanks for having us..
… moreKimberly Tuano
whoa! thats one reaaally good tomato pie! ive never tried one before so this was a great treat! crust was so good and the tomatoes were fresh and bursting with flavor. So glad we tried their signature dish!
Their cookie butter was good but a bit too sweet for me. Like sugary sweet. Ham, mushroom and cheese omelette was okay. However service was great! all the staff we encountered were nice and pleasant.
Parking is kinda hard but luckily we came on an early saturday morning so the bank across was closed and the hostess mentioned we can just park there on their lot which we did lol. Inside was cozy, like going into a historic house (which it probably was idk lol). The restroom was pretty small and tight fyi.
… moreTheir cookie butter was good but a bit too sweet for me. Like sugary sweet. Ham, mushroom and cheese omelette was okay. However service was great! all the staff we encountered were nice and pleasant.
Parking is kinda hard but luckily we came on an early saturday morning so the bank across was closed and the hostess mentioned we can just park there on their lot which we did lol. Inside was cozy, like going into a historic house (which it probably was idk lol). The restroom was pretty small and tight fyi.
Victor “Bud” Nye
One of my wife and my favorite breakfast spots when we vacation in Lititz. The vibe is super cool and laid back, it’s really nice inside and the staff are always great here.
On our stay this last week I’ve had the pancakes which were great, the sausage egg wrap which was nice, and the classic breakfast which was great as well. The bacon is also done perfectly the two times I ordered it.
My wife generally gets the classic breakfast as well, and for the first time tried the squash side and absolutely loved it, it’s baked, then tossed on the griddle with a little bit of sugar. She also loves the tea here over anywhere else in town.
… moreOn our stay this last week I’ve had the pancakes which were great, the sausage egg wrap which was nice, and the classic breakfast which was great as well. The bacon is also done perfectly the two times I ordered it.
My wife generally gets the classic breakfast as well, and for the first time tried the squash side and absolutely loved it, it’s baked, then tossed on the griddle with a little bit of sugar. She also loves the tea here over anywhere else in town.
emi zakharov
if i could give 10 stars i would. i had been waiting to try this place for almost a decade but was never in the area before they closed. it was worth the wait! highly recommend the pumpkin chai, tastes like real pumpkin not artificial syrup. also recommend the chipotle chicken and the spinach artichoke spaghetti squash. the antique and old world vibe inside is timeless. the server was very attentive and personable. can’t wait to come back!
… moreVirginia Jennings
Stopped in today for lunch with my daughter on a quick trip through Lititz and was wonderfully surprised by the tomato pie. Coming from Philly I was expecting a cold sauce and dough situation. No shade on the traditional tomato pie, but was not expecting this delectable little quiche like treat. plus I got the gluten-free and didn’t feel like I was missing anything with the lack of gluten. My latte was also perfectly flavored and not too sweet. It’s such a cute shop and the service was lovely. I will happily drive the hour and a half to eat there again. Any excuse
… moreRaymond D
First, the tomato pie:
Light flaky crust holding in generous amounts of cheese on top of nicely seasoned diced tomatoes. Like the perfect quiche sitting on top of warm Bruschetta. I’ve really had nothing like it and was not what I expected even after reading all reviews. This is by no means anything resembling a pizza and noone should ever refer to any other pizza as a ‘pie’ ever again. I got the double and brought one home.
The carrot fries had sea salt and you are given a small amount of ranch with them. They were good on their own with sea salt, but to make them great, you needed the ranch.
The rest of the table got handhelds. They were slightly small for the price and came with chips or plain greens. They were ok, but nothing special. If we go back, we could get an entree or one of the specials. We were trying to stay on the cheaper side. Looking at other tables, they looked very good.
They had a nice selection of homemade deserts. We liked the s’mores cookie and the chocolate peanut butter pie.
Overall, we spent a little over $20 a person.
The atmosphere is cozy with a classic cafe feel. It had a wrap around porch with outdoor seating. If it’s crowded, it will get loud since there is nothing to dampen the sound. It’s surrounded by the classic main street USA like town of Lititz. There is a large park across the street that often hosts festivals in the warmer months.
… moreLight flaky crust holding in generous amounts of cheese on top of nicely seasoned diced tomatoes. Like the perfect quiche sitting on top of warm Bruschetta. I’ve really had nothing like it and was not what I expected even after reading all reviews. This is by no means anything resembling a pizza and noone should ever refer to any other pizza as a ‘pie’ ever again. I got the double and brought one home.
The carrot fries had sea salt and you are given a small amount of ranch with them. They were good on their own with sea salt, but to make them great, you needed the ranch.
The rest of the table got handhelds. They were slightly small for the price and came with chips or plain greens. They were ok, but nothing special. If we go back, we could get an entree or one of the specials. We were trying to stay on the cheaper side. Looking at other tables, they looked very good.
They had a nice selection of homemade deserts. We liked the s’mores cookie and the chocolate peanut butter pie.
Overall, we spent a little over $20 a person.
The atmosphere is cozy with a classic cafe feel. It had a wrap around porch with outdoor seating. If it’s crowded, it will get loud since there is nothing to dampen the sound. It’s surrounded by the classic main street USA like town of Lititz. There is a large park across the street that often hosts festivals in the warmer months.
Jessica McCardell
Tomato Pie Cafe is a great place to eat! The food is always delicious – their chia seed puddings are to die for! Hot beverages are excellent. The atmosphere is homey and charming. It’s a popular place, so there is sometimes a wait, but it is always worth it! Highly recommended.
… morePriya
We drove to Lititz to try the famous tomato pie! The cozy ambiance added to the experience. We tried their tomato pie meal with carrot fries and herbed scones along with mango smoothie. The food was delicious and had good portions with reasonable pricing, bonus it’s vegetarian-friendly too! A perfect spot to grab a satisfying meal in a warm and welcoming setting.
… more