Tomasino’s Pizza

by

  4.5 – 767 reviews   • Italian restaurant

Social Profile:

Tomasino’s Pizza is a family-owned and operated Italian restaurant in Lake Mary, FL. We have been serving delicious pizza and other Italian dishes. Our pizzas are made with fresh, high-quality ingredients and our service is second to none. We also offer catering services for parties and events of all sizes. Come experience the Tomasino’s difference today!

Family photos line the walls of this casual eatery specializing in New York-style pizza.

✔️Brunch ✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery Tomasino's Pizza 32746

Menu Photos

tomasinospizza.com

Photo Gallery

Related Web Results

Welcome to Tomasinos Pizza – Lake Mary

Tomasinos New York Pizzeria in Orlando, Winter Springs, Lake Nona and Lake Mary, Florida. Order Online.

Tomasinos Pizza

Tomasinos New York Pizzeria in Orlando, Winter Springs, Lake Nona and Lake Mary, Florida. Order Online.

Menu expand_more – Tomasinos Pizza – Lake Mary

Tomasinos New York Pizzeria in Orlando, Winter Springs, Lake Nona and Lake Mary, Florida. Order Online.

Reviews

Sri K
First time ordering food here. It left me regretting all the times I’d ordered pizza/pasta from other vendors- so very, very fresh & tasty The quality of the pie & whatever cheese they used was so very delicious It’s several rungs above that of what other vendors use. We ordered veggie cheesebread, veggie pizzas, & an Alfredo pasta. Perfectly roasted & cheesy. Thoroughly loved it. Though our order was takeout, I was waiting a little bit in the restaurant for my order to be ready. During that time, I felt the ambience for a dine-in was very good too, & the staff were very cheerful & friendly. I’m sure we’ll be ordering from here again
… more
Komal
Delicious!!! The appetizer chicken bites are so delicious. The sauce is unique and tasty.
The pizza is phenomenal! Wow. A 14′ regular crust is big enough to feed about 2-3 people.
Quality ingredients.
You have to make an account with them online to place a delivery/takeout order.

Love the margarita pizza! Comes with warm marinara sauce! Marinara sauce seems to be freshly made. Wow!

Tried the pesto pizza. Its great but more oily than the margarita pizza.

The tiramisu dessert is authentic. Light & bitter as it should be.
… more
Veronica Red
We discovered this place because of their food challenge, and after seeing so many great reviews, we decided to drive all the way from South Georgia to Orlando just to try their pizza. Let me tell you… it’s one of the best pizzas I’ve ever had! Definitely worth the drive. Highly recommend
… more
Amanda O’Connell
Food was disgusting. Unfortunately the only good thing was the service, the waiter was so sweet. They keep deleting my review but I’ll attach the pizza below
… more
Antonio Rodriguez
So, it was pizza night, and we stopped by Tomasino’s Pizza in Heathrow, which always leaves a good impression. The classic New York-style pizza vibe was just what we were looking for. You can tell they care about getting the flavor just right as the ingredients appear freshly prepared every time. The atmosphere was quiet, casual, and very welcoming. The staff was friendly, and the service was quick without feeling rushed.

Whether you’re into classic cheese or loaded toppings, Tomasino’s is the best pizza in Heathrow, so much that it has you craving pizza again the next day.
… more
Geri Egan
Amazing food and service! This was our 1st time n definitely not our last. Been craving NY style slices n was in the area, so did a quick Google search n found this place! So glad we did. Absolutely loved the lady at the front counter/waitress (forgot her name) she explained everything, didn’t rush us etc. Definitely will be back. Absolutely delicious
… more
WMB 4Him
This is our first time at Tomasino’s in Lake Mary. The food was excellent. The service was great. Nik did an awesome job of taking care of us. The marinara sauce was great. We also enjoyed it with the pizza crust. The meatballs were great. The Cheesesteak bun was toasted perfectly and held up to the generous of the mixture of cheese and steak. The restaurant also offers lunch specials 11:00 to 3:00 everyday. Definitely will visit again
… more
Charlotte Sporkia
Aryanna took such great care of us. We stopped in on a dreary Sunday and she totally brightened our day. We love the slices and my father in law who is legit Italian thought the spaghetti and meatballs were good. Not sure why there was no whipped cream with the Juniors cheesecake but we are happy nonetheless. Thanks for being so wonderful.
… more
Richard Carignan
I want to be clear, food is good, tastes like home cooking and the vibe is nice. What is making this a one is service, I went with a date, on Valentines, who loves their food and they refused allow her 1 glass of wine. Now I talked to the server about something personal, but it was not affecting her, and she only stumbled due to her wearing heels that she was not used to. When asked, the server made a statement that upset her and me. When arguing the point, we proceeded to the manager and were treated the same. This is not the first time I have had issues with this location as well. Last Valentines we arrived while the store was still open, but they no longer were serving at the location, so I had to order out and drive back home just to make do with the night we had. This place service has changed from 5 years ago and not for the better.
… more
Robert.
We order 14 ” pie not bad but was very costly 2 toppings were $12 more
Then we made a big mistake and ordered the banked Zite it was so bad,it was 2 ” of cheese on top no other cheese with tje zite .The sauce was not cooked down at all. Meatballs they eggplant parm they buy the sauce was alot watered down big time i have been buying a few pies ea week pizza not bad . The food don’t waste your money and the heart burn
… more
… View more

Leave a Comment

© 2026 Marketer • Built with GeneratePress

Privacy Policy

Terms

Contact