Social Profile: 
✔️Brunch ✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out
… View more
Toll Station Pizza is McCall’s go-to spot for handcrafted pizzas, pastas, and sandwiches, alongside a classic bar and grill selection. Located in the heart of downtown, we have been serving locals and visitors for over 40 years with a menu that combines classic flavors and creative twists complemented by a family friendly atmosphere. Whether you’re craving a hearty pizza, a cold beer or a crisp cocktail after a day on the lake or getting off the skii hill, we’ve got you covered. We offer dine in, online ordering, and take out by phone or walk in. Come on down to Toll Station and experience a taste of our sweet, small town. #TollStationPizza #McCall,ID #BestPizza #PayetteLake #ValleyCounty #TS #PizzaPizzaPizza #Patio #DoGoodBeKindEatPizza
Hours
| Monday | 11:30 AM–8 PM |
| Tuesday | Closed |
| Wednesday | Closed |
| Thursday | 11:30 AM–8 PM |
| Friday | 11:30 AM–8 PM |
| Saturday | 11:30 AM–8 PM |
| Sunday | 11:30 AM–8 PM |
Address and Contact Information
Address: 410 Railroad Ave, McCall, ID 83638
Phone: (208) 634-7818
Website: http://tollstationpizza.com/
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Toll Station Pizza: Home
Since 1981. Toll Station Pizza is McCall’s go-to spot for handcrafted pizzas, pastas, and sandwiches, alongside a classic bar and grill selection.
Toll Station Pizza and Pasta | McCall ID – Facebook
Toll Station Pizza and Pasta, McCall. 1344 likes · 4117 were here. Go-to spot for handcrafted pizzas, pastas, and sandwiches, alongside a classic bar…
Toll Station Pizza – Order Online
Sign in for a faster ordering experience. Toll Station Pizza. 410 Railroad Ave, McCall, ID.
Reviews
April Perus
I am gluten free. The gluten free spinach dip with gluten free bread was wonderful. The gluten free pizza was alright, similar to other gluten free pizza places. The most important thing for me is I didn’t get glutened and sick. Very happy with that. My husband ordered lasagna which he said was good. Our server was awesome. He made me some butter with crushed garlic for my pizza.
… moreDeliah Flores
I don’t know why I haven’t eaten here before- the food is delicious! We had the McCall special pizza and I got the chicken fettuccine alfredo and boy, was I impressed! The pizza had a nice thin crust with generous toppings (reminds me of Lucky 13 in Boise). The pasta was a real treat because the Alfredo sauce was very flavorful and the chicken was grilled and delicious. Usually I’m disappointed with Alfredo because it’s often runny or bland sauce but not this time! The staff was very friendly and attentive for such a busy weekend! I’ll be going back!
… moreR. Scherer
The Toll Station has been here for as long as I can remember and has always had some of the best pizza and pasta in McCall.
They have a variety of things on the menu, from gluten-free, vegetarian, and everything in-between.
It’s worth the stop if you’re ever in the area.
The staff is friendly, the atmosphere is great and the food is delicious.
They have outdoor seating weather permitting.
Afterward, take a stroll down town and see the amazing sights and activities that are happening year round.
… moreThey have a variety of things on the menu, from gluten-free, vegetarian, and everything in-between.
It’s worth the stop if you’re ever in the area.
The staff is friendly, the atmosphere is great and the food is delicious.
They have outdoor seating weather permitting.
Afterward, take a stroll down town and see the amazing sights and activities that are happening year round.
Jay Bigley
Nice atmosphere and friendly staff but pizza is not worth the money. Paid over $25 for a large pizza that I thought was worth $15. Nothing special. We ordered 3 pizzas to go on line. When I went to sign the receipt I saw $2 for one pizza box, another $3 for another box, and $4 for the third box. $9 for pizza boxes. Never heard of such a thing. Am I supposed to bring my own box? I asked the cashier about it and she said ”We did?” like she was not aware of it. I showed her the receipt to which she said “oh yeah, we did”. There was no mention of it on the website when ordering nor was I advised about it before I paid. On top of that we paid 3% for using a credit card. That is somewhat normal with small businesses but it was a slap in the face after paying too much for pizza and the $9 for boxes. Did not expect this in Idaho. Will not return. Can’t afford it for what you get.
… moreNoah Chumos
Went here with a couple of friends and split 3 pies. All were fantastic and tasted amazing. The Mac and Cheese pizza was to die for. The hot honey they added on one of the pizzas was perfect, usually not a fan but tasted great. Highly recommend. Prices are a little steep for pizza but quality and service sure make up for it.
… moreDaniel Flud
Talk about a surprise place. We almost came for pizza, which looked amazing. But the moment we saw sandwiches go to another table, I had to get one.
The prime dip sandwiches were absolutely amazing, the flavor spot on. My dad tried the fish and chips and said they were really good as well. My wife tried the chicken sandwich and it had so much flavor.
The prices were extremely fair as well, making this a place we will certainly try it again next time we come to visit.
Great food!
… moreThe prime dip sandwiches were absolutely amazing, the flavor spot on. My dad tried the fish and chips and said they were really good as well. My wife tried the chicken sandwich and it had so much flavor.
The prices were extremely fair as well, making this a place we will certainly try it again next time we come to visit.
Great food!
J B
We ordered a medium chicken popper/Walter pizza and an order of loaded fries. I’ll start with the fries because they were phenomenal! The alfredo sauce on them was amazing. They were perfectly crispy and so delicious! They even held up being a takeout order and didn’t get soggy or cold! Had we only gotten those, this would be a 5-star review.
Now to the pizza. The chicken popper comes with a hot honey “drizzle,” but whoever was responsible had a very heavy pour! The entire bottom of the pizza was completely puddled and saturated in the honey. This completely ruined the entire pizza. We were so sad because the pizza looked amazing until we pulled the pieces up. My husband’s piece of pizza was so drenched in it that all of the toppings slid right off of the crust when he attempted to pull his slice out of the box. Our hands were so sticky and covered in honey.
… moreNow to the pizza. The chicken popper comes with a hot honey “drizzle,” but whoever was responsible had a very heavy pour! The entire bottom of the pizza was completely puddled and saturated in the honey. This completely ruined the entire pizza. We were so sad because the pizza looked amazing until we pulled the pieces up. My husband’s piece of pizza was so drenched in it that all of the toppings slid right off of the crust when he attempted to pull his slice out of the box. Our hands were so sticky and covered in honey.
nick Lawrence
On my stop to mccall this was the first pizza place I stopped at. I ordered take out and an employee delivered it straight to my car with a smile.
Sadly the pizza was the same as the other places in town with a thin bland crust. The sauce had almost no flavor and the toppings and cheese felt like decoration than savory.
Price was around the same as other pizza places in mccall 30$ for a large
The menu has plenty of other options and I feel like sitting down with a group of friends or family would change my experience as the employees are amazing.
… moreSadly the pizza was the same as the other places in town with a thin bland crust. The sauce had almost no flavor and the toppings and cheese felt like decoration than savory.
Price was around the same as other pizza places in mccall 30$ for a large
The menu has plenty of other options and I feel like sitting down with a group of friends or family would change my experience as the employees are amazing.
Cody Solders
We’ve been going to McCall for a long time. I thought the atmosphere was really nice, compared to going here in the past. It’s much lighter, and more inviting.
The menu is robust. The service was good – our beer was clearly flavored with cleaning product, but the staff brought out a substitution readily.
Our food was the sticking point – the otherwise good experience was ended with soggy pizza. The flavors were good, and the salad was quite tasty. For an established restaurant in McCall, I thought it was alright but not amazing.
Probably will give it another try. It’s a staple.
… moreThe menu is robust. The service was good – our beer was clearly flavored with cleaning product, but the staff brought out a substitution readily.
Our food was the sticking point – the otherwise good experience was ended with soggy pizza. The flavors were good, and the salad was quite tasty. For an established restaurant in McCall, I thought it was alright but not amazing.
Probably will give it another try. It’s a staple.
Ted Colclazier
This evening we ordered out, first time. We usually dine in. The lasagna was ok not up to its usual. But the fact that it was just slapped down on the cardboard box bottom, no proper container. See picture. I’ll call on this.
I return to the Toll station to again have lasagna. This time I ate in and had a very delightful dinner and the lasagna was spectacular. I will continue to come I think twice maybe about ordering it out but the service and everybody’s hospitality. There was great. I do recommend this place for the best lasagna on the mountain.
… moreI return to the Toll station to again have lasagna. This time I ate in and had a very delightful dinner and the lasagna was spectacular. I will continue to come I think twice maybe about ordering it out but the service and everybody’s hospitality. There was great. I do recommend this place for the best lasagna on the mountain.