Social Profile: 
✔️Brunch ✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Straightforward pizzas, subs & cheesesteaks are served over the counter in a low-key setting.
Address and Contact Information
Address: 3523 49th Street N, St. Petersburg, FL 33710
Phone: (727) 522-2717
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
tobysoriginallittleitalypizza.com
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Toby’s Original Little Italy Pizza
ORDER PREPARATION · 3523 49th Street N, St. Petersburg, FL 33710 · 727-522-2717 · Sun-Thurs: 11am-10pm – Fri & Sat: 11am-11pm.
Little Italy Pizza | Saint Petersburg FL – Facebook
… Toby’s Original Little Italy Pizza is located at 3523 49th Street North, St. Petersburg, FL 33710 and has been operating since 1972. No photo description …
Toby’s Original Little Italy Pizza (St. Petersburg, FL … – YouTube
Dave starts the great Tampa trip at Toby’s Original, where it is always a good sign when the people know who he is. Use code “PIZZA” on …
Reviews
Jerry T
Tried Toby’s for the first time, even though I’ve lived in Pinellas County for years.
Everything was solid. Great NY Style pizza, meatball sub, garlic knots. Even the cheese steak sandwich was good. Service is extremely fast as well. Wish I knew about this place years ago. We’ll definitely make this a regular stop!
… moreEverything was solid. Great NY Style pizza, meatball sub, garlic knots. Even the cheese steak sandwich was good. Service is extremely fast as well. Wish I knew about this place years ago. We’ll definitely make this a regular stop!
B Green
Best cheese steak hoagie and pizza in all of Pinellas county! A taste of Philly and New York in your own back yard. Pizza size is either small “Big” or large “Bigger”! Salads are fresh and crisp and the house made Italian dressing is excellent. A must stop for lunch, dinner, or just a snack. I dare you to try their garlic knots!
… moreMatt C.
We have lived in St. Pete for 5 years and have been in pursuit of a good quality pie and salad that can satisfy. Well we found it here. You start by ordering your items at thr counter and then seat your self at an empty both. Gives you a vibe of an original pizza restaurant from the 80’s and 90’s. Ordered a side sald with cheese. It was thinly shredded iceberg with tomatoes and onions. Homemade vinaigrette dressing was delicious, but was very heavy ( we will order on the side next time). Pizza was huge and delicious, cheese was high quality and pepperoni was flavorful. It was finished off with a very thin hand tossed crust that was perfectly cooked and not burnt as many competitors are. Will be back soon, and can’t wait to try again. As of now #1 pizza in St. Pete. I still have more places to try.
… moreBrock Grady
Went here because of the rating. Overall idea would say this is a safe bet for New York style pizza. Got a 1/2 cheese & 1/2 pepperoni, would say the pepperoni was a bit better. Enjoyed the pie, but will also consider trying other pizzas in the area if this is considered a 4.7+ star parlor. I liked the inside/atmosphere a little more than the pizza.
… moreTrisha Miller
Great and friendly service. Reasonable prices. Was not a fan of the pizza. Maybe overcooked or stale. Never seen pizza break apart before.
Very crowded and narrow restaurant. Some of the seating was occupied by pizza boxes and other supplies. Very busy.
… moreVery crowded and narrow restaurant. Some of the seating was occupied by pizza boxes and other supplies. Very busy.
E L
Listen, I was so excited for a yummy pizza Friday night. I’m blown away at all the 5 star reviews that had my hopes so high. Either everyone here is so desperate for a good pizza that they don’t know one, or we had a truly off night experience. Either way, it was inedibly bad. We were so excited to try Toby’s. The only redeeming thing was the garlic knots. Yum!
The pizza was sooooooo bad. For multiple reasons. It looked like someone slopped it into a box at an angle too hot and in a hurry. This is how it looked in the box when we got it. We should have gone back inside but I was hurry and worried about the dogs at home in thunderstorms. Got it home and just got more annoyed at myself for now going back inside before driving away. I used 2 paper towels to sop up the puddles of grease. The crust under the toppings was limp, soggy, and I wish I could say tasteless but no, it tasted gross, even the fluffy edges were gross and reminiscent of soggy cardboard. I am bummed. What a flop. The garlic knots were scarfed down and delicious as the only edible thing. This was dumped in the trash after a few bites we tried to salvage. Still hungry and out the money for this. Sorry Toby, it was not your night.
… moreThe pizza was sooooooo bad. For multiple reasons. It looked like someone slopped it into a box at an angle too hot and in a hurry. This is how it looked in the box when we got it. We should have gone back inside but I was hurry and worried about the dogs at home in thunderstorms. Got it home and just got more annoyed at myself for now going back inside before driving away. I used 2 paper towels to sop up the puddles of grease. The crust under the toppings was limp, soggy, and I wish I could say tasteless but no, it tasted gross, even the fluffy edges were gross and reminiscent of soggy cardboard. I am bummed. What a flop. The garlic knots were scarfed down and delicious as the only edible thing. This was dumped in the trash after a few bites we tried to salvage. Still hungry and out the money for this. Sorry Toby, it was not your night.
Luke
Id say it was about a 3.5 stars so I rounded up. I got a cheese pizza and while the flavors were pretty decent it was quite the floppy mess. I ate one piece in the parking lot too make sure I got the full experience. I definitely prefer my pizza a bit more done, but im sure some would like this just fine. Not something i would drive a ways for again but if you live close by its a decent choice.
… moreBarbara Keller
Best pizza ever. Been going there for many, many years with sons, d friends and other family. We love the extra large meat lovers to feed everyone and still have a slice or two to take home. Lots of sodas or cold teas to choose from. Staff are great and you can actually watch your pizza go in the ovens. Tables are cleaned immediately for the next people to sit. People of all ages enjoy their food. Video games in back room, restrooms are clean and supplied. They have a wide choice of foods and salads to choose from. There’s always plenty of parking available. Wait time for food is very minimal. Check them out. You will go back year after year like our family does.
… moreAlicia Montalvo
My daughter and I came across this pizza joint and I must say the garlic knots are delicious and the pizza slices are delicious and big. We have eaten there 3x this week
… moreMichelle Pierce
Hands down, the best pizza around! You can grab a quick pepperoni or cheese slice, but the specialty pizzas are the real stars. The crust and sauce are absolute perfection, creating the best possible base for everything else they offer.
… more