Social Profile: 
✔️Breakfast ✔️Brunch ✔️Dine in
… View more
Address and Contact Information
Address: 51425 IN-19, Elkhart, IN 46514
Phone: (574) 399-5220
Website: http://www.toastedturtletavern.com/
Related Web Results
Toasted Turtle Tavern | Elkhart IN – Facebook
It’s Turtle Time! We’re finally open! This week’s hours Thursday-Sunday 8AM-3PM. May be an image of text that says ‘TOASTEDTURTLE …
Toasted Turtle Tavern | Elkhart IN – Facebook
The Grand Opening 3/12 of the Toasted Turtle Tavern in Elkhart, Simonton Lake area. Beginning this week , hours are Thursday thru Sunday 8a-3pm for breakfast …
Toasted Turtle 54124 SR 19
Food · Tavern BLT. Tavern bacon, romaine, tomatoes, toasted sour dough, and mayo sauce. · Wake & Bake Burger. Brisket, Ribeye, Ground Chuck Patty, Char-Grilled …
Reviews
Christopher Guffey
If you’re looking for one of the most unique brunch and dining spots in Elkhart, Toasted Turtle Tavern absolutely delivers. The interior feels fresh and modern, but what really makes the space special is the community-sourced memorabilia displayed throughout the restaurant. Instead of generic décor, the walls tell the story of Elkhart through items donated by longtime locals. It gives the place a character you won’t find anywhere else in town.
The menu is just as impressive. Their brunch lineup is easily one of the most creative in the area, and everything feels thoughtfully prepared rather than rushed. From hearty breakfast plates to elevated tavern favorites, there’s something for everyone. Pair it with one of their drinks or cocktails and you’ve got a perfect weekend stop.
What stands out most is how the restaurant manages to feel both new and deeply connected to the local community at the same time. It’s the kind of place that quickly becomes a regular hangout.
Definitely worth checking out if you’re in Elkhart
… moreThe menu is just as impressive. Their brunch lineup is easily one of the most creative in the area, and everything feels thoughtfully prepared rather than rushed. From hearty breakfast plates to elevated tavern favorites, there’s something for everyone. Pair it with one of their drinks or cocktails and you’ve got a perfect weekend stop.
What stands out most is how the restaurant manages to feel both new and deeply connected to the local community at the same time. It’s the kind of place that quickly becomes a regular hangout.
Definitely worth checking out if you’re in Elkhart
Andrew Martin
Fantastic breakfast, excellent service and awesome lake vibes!
Food: …
… moreFood: …
Tirzo Cabrera
Great Food like always. I’ve been to all of Cam’s Restaurants. Love em all. I ordered the Crabby Cam’s Benedict and it was delicious! I just wish it had a little more of that Awesome Deep Water Red Crab!
… moreSiera Murphy
Food and service was amazing. Shaye took great care of us
… moreMarissa Cook
Amazing service and food! I will be dreaming of The Turtle Stack
… moreBruce Ballow
Fantastic meal at The Toasted Turtle! I had the Turtle Stack and it was amazing—great flavor, perfectly cooked, and a generous portion. Friendly service, fun atmosphere, and a great location. Definitely a spot I’ll be coming back to for my breakfast/brunch fix! ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
… moreSam S
Absolutely excellent. Great service, fantastic cocktails, and delicious food. Generous portions for a reasonable price!
… moreLori Holmes
All personnel were welcoming, friendly & accommodating. Tavern Ham Benedict w/potatoes were very good. Chairs at bar are awesome with lots if room, great service. Casual, comfortable atmosphere. Simonton Lake decor is heart warming, being an original Lake Girl from North Shore Drive. So many items on menu I want to try, will go back soon for a Bloody Mary and another satisfying meal Highly recommended
… moreVonnie Ragsdale
We had a great first experience for brunch . Very good food. Highly recommend
… more