Christopher LeBron
Toasted Bagel is the absolute best bakery/deli in a five mile radius of its location. Bar none the best prices, tasting food, and amazing employees. Beth runs a tight ship out in the counter area and Nolan is one of the best cooks in the business. Naz is super sweet always smiling and working her tail off. Other employees under “FD” the manager are well trained and offer a pleasant greeting. The dining area is always clean. They generate almost 50 percent of their businesses from online pick up orders, door dash and uber eats drivers are constantly in there picking up (tells one others like their food too! ). Their fresh muffins and breakfast platters are to die for. Coffee is unlimited refills as is hot chocolate, tea, and cappuccino on same visit.
… moreMr. Tuzcu
The menu looks amazing. Their bagels were absolutely delicious, super fresh, perfectly toasted, and served warm. My cream cheese sandwich was perfectly made. The staff were very friendly and quick. Everything was clean and organized. The prices are good too. We LOVE Toasted Bagel! Thanks to Toasted Bagel for the great service! My kids were so happy to be there. I definitely recommend it.
… moreTiffany Macartney
We haven’t been here since it changed ownership (formally East Northport Bagel Cafe formally Long Island Bagel Cafe), but WOW what a great change. It looks beautiful inside…bright, open, organized. The bagels are absolutely delicious. We got egg everything bagels and both sides are heavily seasoned with small seasoning, not those chunks of onion flakes on other everything bagels (if you love everything bagels, you know what I mean). My sons devoured their ham/egg/cheese bagel sandwich and egg everything bagel with extra vegetable cream cheese, so I didn’t get a picture. I got a sausage/egg over easy/cheese on egg everything bagel and my fiance got sausage/scrambled eggs/cheese on a roll. It took about 10 minutes to prepare which I’d expect on a busy Saturday morning. I met the owner and he asked we give him feedback on how we enjoyed it and gave my son a chocolate pudding for coming in for the first time… really nice guy. For those 4 breakfasts and a big jug of orange juice it came to $36 cash price, card was a bit more. We all fully enjoyed our breakfasts and will 100% return.
… moreStephanie Kossman
Best egg sandwiches and bagels around!
I’ve been coming here regularly for the past year. My order is always made quickly and accurately, which is rare for a bagel place. The breakfast sandwiches are made with hearty portions of meat, and the sandwiches aren’t too greasy. Bagels are excellent quality and they always have a good variety freshly made.
… moreLaura Jean
Stopped in for a roast beef sandwich and was pleasantly surprised! Place looks great! Menu looks fantastic and the prices seemed reasonable. My sandwich was made well and tasted great! It came with a pickle & side of really good potato salad! Would definitely recommend! Even gave me some free delicious bonus bagels!!
… moreIpek Gezmis
Love this place!
Toasted Bagel is honestly the best spot to start your morning! Their bagels are super fresh, perfectly toasted, and always served warm. The staff is super friendly, the place is spotless, and the vibe is cozy. Plus, they offer free coffee, which is such a nice touch ☕️ Grab your bagel and coffee, and your day is instantly better. Highly recommend!
… moreEmel Taskakan
Everything was clean and organized. You can tell they take pride in the place. The bagel with cream cheese and hashbrowns was delicious. The coffee was top notch and fresh. The staff was friendly and quick. You can tell they respect themselves and the business, and it shows in the way everything runs smoothly.
Definitely the kind of spot you leave thinking, I’ll be back.
… moreEm
I usually dont write reviews, especially when im upset. Makes me feel like a real “karen”. Called in today to speak with someone regarding a current delivery order i need to adjust for this weekend. The girl who answered placed me on hold and I could hear it busy in the background, so im patient. However, being on hold for 1 hour, 3 mins and 15 secs is insane. (Yes I have the time to wait because im not a monster, but this is beyond busy, its forgetful). I hang up and attempt to call back and the phone is ringing in as busy!! All I wanted to do was call and speak about an order, but this experience has me worried about the care and attention my large order will get coming up this weekend.
… moreyasin Camlica
Best bacon egg and cheese salt pepper ketchup on a Kaiser roll that I’ve tasted in 23 years! Well done! This place is legit bagels are awesome as well! Anybody that knows me knows not to doubt my taste buds you will be thoroughly impressed with this place come eat come all come any!
… moreSam
Such an amazing deli, food is always amazing, fresh, and just taste so good. From breakfast sandwiches to lunch sandwiches I’m never disappointed always have a happy belly! I always order from DoorDash and it’s always perfect!
… more