Social Profile: 
✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Pizza joint with a mix of Italian & American food such as burgers, sandwiches, pasta dishes & wings.
Address and Contact Information
Address: 18 Marshall Hill Rd, West Milford, NJ 07480
Phone: (973) 728-2228
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
TJ’ s pizzeria cafe | West Milford NJ – Facebook
Details ; . 66% recommend (11 Reviews) ; . Closed now ; . 18 Marshall Hill Rd, West Milford, NJ, United States, 07480 …
TJ’s Pizzeria Cafe
34 West Clinton Street, Dover, NJ. 973-442-7600. Serving Dover and the Surrounding Area. 18 Marshall Hill Rd. West Milford, NJ. 728-2228. Serving West Milford.
TJs Pizza Cafe: Authentic Flavors and Local Favorites in West Milford
Discover TJs Pizza Cafe in West Milford, NJ, where crisp pizza, hearty calzones, and delightful seafood unite to create a family-friendly dining experience.
Reviews
michael martyn
The food is really good, butbits pizzeria food in north jersey. They serve the best pizza in the area and definitely have plenty of competition. Their Chipotle chicken pie is out of this world. The owners are incredibly amazing and hospitable. Wouldn’t go anywhere else!
… morelinsay setzer
I’ve lived in WM for 7 years, and TJs is my & my boyfriend’s absolute favorite go-to. The food is fresh, well made, and incredibly affordable. The woman who runs the register & answers the phone is so polite and kind, she honestly is one of our favorite parts about ordering! When we pick it up, even the guys behind the counter say hello, and wish us a good night. They keep our number in their computer so we don’t have to worry about constantly giving our information. We’ve had their pizzas, calzone, stromboli, wings, calamari, salads, wraps, sandwiches. Its always amazing and unlike most places, we don’t feel heavy and gross after eating here. Thats a huge nod to the quality of their food. We are forever fans of TJ’s!
… moreChris Sims
Anybody that knows me i have been in the pizza resturant buisness my whole life! This TJ’S of West milly is spot on! I have ordered from every variety of the Menu. I Swear it has been just positive every bite of every order! Impressed and Happy! They Deliver and also spor on! Thanks guys and gals
… moreNazir Ahmad
As always I am so happy that we have such a wonderful family owned business (TJ’s Pizza), tonight after My son’s soccer game he was so hungry and asked me for Grandma square pizza I ordered for pick up and I met such a great lady the owner of the restaurant, I am telling you try the Grandma square here once and you will fall in love with it , me and my son finished the whole pizza as shown in the picture, go to TJ give it a try and share your experience ,
… moreN. H.
Excellent food. Pizza is crispy with a not too thick crust, filled with flavor. Pepperoni nice and robust. And I CHALLENGE you to find a better House, or Anti-pasta, Salad. Buffalo chicken bites are crispy and taste like the original Buffalo NY sauce. Italian Hoagie almost as good as Bellvale Market. True gem. Recommend take out. Not much room to dine in.
… moreHunter
I used to go across the street to Franks, however Franks quality has declined and their prices are outrageous. Decided to try TJ’s about a month ago and have been hooked ever Since! Friendly staff, fair prices, and top notch pizza! I find the pizza to be a perfect ratio of Sauce, cheese and crust. Never under or over cooked, just consistent perfection. Chicken bacon ranch is phenomenal!
… moreSebastian Davila
Ordered a pepperoni ham calzone. Not even $15 and it was big, delicious, perfect amount of cheese and meats. A lot better than the ones across the street 😉
… morePG
I strongly support local merchants, but never again TJ’s. They charged me $8 for 2 slices of pizza, yes 2, two. I can go to Domino’s & purchase 2 medium pizzas with 2 toppings for $6.99 each.
… moreKitKat Kreationz
Found this gem of a place over covid 2020 shut down … and to this this day they are just amazing …. this eggplant spinach panini is my go to after 3 years!!! Love this place and the staff is awesome ❤️
… moreAlyssa Davis
Their disco fry pizza is comfort food at its best. Friendly staff is the added gravy on top.
… more