4.6 – 123 reviews • Pizza restaurant
Family-Owned Pizza Restaurant in Tradition, Port St. Lucie
Nestled in the vibrant Tradition master-planned community of Port St. Lucie, Florida, our family-owned restaurant delights locals and visitors with authentic Sicilian pizzas, hearty pastas, fresh subs, and crisp salads.
✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out
Menu Photos
Related Web Results
Times Square Pizza: Home
Online ordering menu for Times Square Pizza. Times Square Pizza has been serving the best Italian dishes to-go in the Ft. Lauderdale for over 20 years.
Reviews
Наталя Михлик
Stopped by today and tried the Park Avenue pizza with prosciutto and arugula, a really good combo! The prosciutto was fresh and salty, the mozzarella melted perfectly, each pizza bite was crispy. Also ordered the waffle fries on the side and they came out hot and crunchy. Glad we came earlier in the day because I hear the place gets really packed towards the evening. Simple food done right. Definitely a spot I’d come back to.
… moreVira Tkachenko
Stopped by this new pizza place yesterday and it was fantastic! I had the eggplant parm hot sub and it was delicious—crispy eggplant, great sauce, and perfectly melted cheese. Great service and a really nice atmosphere. Looking forward to coming back if I’m in the area again!
… moreAndriy Kuktenko
I don’t really write reviews but honestly this place earned it.
Got the parm chicken and it was SO good. Like, better than I expected for a local spot. We ate there and then took a Hell’s Kitchen pizza home for later and it was still perfect. That doesn’t always happen with pizza, so props to them for that.
The people working there were really friendly too. Not in a fake way, just actually nice and helpful. Made the whole thing feel relaxed.
PSL needed a place like this, no joke. Really happy it’s here. Already thinking about going back.
… moreMarnie Greenblatt Sherman
Excited to try a new local New York style pizza place. Ordered over the phone: one pie, one salad and a chicken Parm hero.
Told us 45 minute wait. Got there a little early and it had been sitting out for at least 10 minutes. While I try to look for the positives in any meal and service, we could not find any. The pizza was burnt. It was trying to be coal fired, but yet says it’s New York Pizza. On a scale of one to 10 for salt, it was a 15. The only positive was fresh, not canned mushrooms. You could barely cut it with a pizza cutter, and most of it stuck to the paper in the box. All of that disappointment for almost 30 bucks!
The salad was $15 and was just a bunch of lettuce, a few tomatoes and way too many olives.
The chicken parm hero was in some sort of under baked bread that was doused in flour. It was underbaked on the inside and looks like it was missing ingredients. The chicken was dry & had no flavor.
The best part of the meal was the bottle of soda we got at the gas station next-door.
Definitely sticking with our usual pizza place.
… morePavlo Yakovych
Stopped by to try this new pizza place that just opened. Honestly, the pizza was great! Got myself bronx bomber – good crust, fresh ingredients, and everything tasted really good 🙂
The people working there were very nice too, as I spoke with staff it’s a family own business.
I’ll definitely come back
… morerichard
The whole experience was good the waitress and the rest of the workers are friendly. the place is nice and the food was good the only complaint is since it’s called Times Square I was expecting New York pizza but they don’t have traditional New York slices but the pizza that they do have is good especially the buffalo chicken pizza
… moreP A
It’s so nice to have a sit down ny style pizza place in the community. The atmosphere is great, really warm and welcoming. And the food is delicious. Enjoyed the option of square and round pizzas, the eggplant sandwich was yummy, I enjoyed the sauce/cheese ratio and I loved the cannolis. I’ll be back
… moreKiara
This place is absolutely amazing! From the moment we walked in, we were received with some of the friendliest, warmest service I’ve ever experienced at a Pizza place. The environment is very welcoming and it seems like they put a lot of thought into their presentation, which is nice to see. As far as the food, they went above and beyond to accommodate my dietary needs with a delicious pasta with eggplant, and gave my husband the best chicken wings he’s tried in a long time. We’re definitely coming back! This is exactly the kind of delicious treat this area needed.
Next time we’re coming for the pizza.
… moreAlexis Emanuel-Faullin
Times Square Pizza is my new favorite place! I work right next door and get to eat yummy fresh food instead of DoorDashing wilted salad for double the price. The pizza, pasta, salad and subs always hit the spot and hostesses are super nice. I love how I always see their team helping each other out. Really feels like a warm welcoming place to be ✨
… moreJerline B.
I was really looking forward to trying this place since it’s close to my neighborhood, but it ended up being a total disappointment. A large pizza here is only 14 inches and costs about $30, which is already pretty expensive. For a family of four, that’s honestly not enough food.
On top of that, the pizza barely had any sauce and mostly tasted like bread and cheese. For the price, I expected much better flavor and quality.
It’s a shame because I was hoping to find a good pizza spot nearby, but this place just didn’t live up to the expectations. I personally won’t be going back. I’d rather drive the 40 minutes to Bella Roma because at least there the pizza actually tastes good and feels worth the money.
If you’re curious, try it yourself and see what you think, but it definitely wasn’t worth it for me.
… more … View more