
Address and Contact Information
Address: 1410 Grape St, Whitehall Township, PA 18052
Phone: (484) 274-6781
Website: http://thirstyturtle-tavern.com/
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Reservations: opentable.com
Related Web Results
Thirsty Turtle Tavern: Home
Whitehall, PA – Thirsty Turtle Tavern
Thirsty Turtle Tavern review in Whitehall – Facebook
Reviews
This was our first visit and we loved it so much that we came back again. The second time the service was different, but still very good. The atmosphere is wow, the service is wow, the food is so, so good, and everything came out fast.
Definitely a place worth coming back to!
The menu offers a unique twist on traditional pub dining. While you’ll find classic favorites like wings and burgers, the restaurant also features tavern style pizzas and sushi.
My friends and I dropped in for the first time last Thursday. Overall, it was a mixed experience. Some of the dishes were well executed and enjoyable, while others fell short of expectations.
We started with Chipotle honey tavern wings, Wisconsin cheese curds, and nachos. I also had a crock of French onion soup. The wings were sweet, crispy, and easily the standout. The cheese curds were decent but slightly under-fried. The nachos were awful, with barely any toppings and mostly crushed, bottom of the bag chips. The French onion soup was hot, flavorful, and topped with onion straws.
After the appetizers I moved onto the BBQ pulled pork mac & cheese. It’s made with a five cheese sauce, macaroni, pulled pork, and seasoned breadcrumbs. While it sounded promising, the flavors didn’t quite come together. It was decent, but not something I’d order again.
One of my friends ordered the chicken vodka dream, a much better choice than mine. The hand breaded cutlet, homemade vodka sauce, fresh mozzarella, and pesto made for an awesome sandwich. The sweet potato fries were undercooked and bland, but the sandwich more than made up for it.
Service was great overall. Tyler was attentive and very helpful with the menu, and the manager checked in a few times, which is always appreciated. The only downside was timing. Appetizers took awhile, and entrees followed almost immediately after.
Pickup is available, but there is no delivery. Happy hour is Mon – Fri 3PM – 6PM.
We tried a variety of dishes: the TT Trio appetizer was enjoyable, while the Sea Bites had a batter that was a bit too salty and heavily sauced, which overpowered the flavor of the seafood. That said, the pizzas really stood out—both the four-cheese and a custom version with goat cheese, bacon, and blistered cherry tomatoes were fantastic and came out at just the right time. The rainbow sushi roll was a pleasant surprise—fresh, well-presented, and clearly made with care. The Cuban sandwich wasn’t traditional, but it was absolutely delicious, especially with the seasoned fries on the side.
Service was friendly, though just okay given how busy the place was. Still, we felt welcomed and comfortable throughout the meal. Overall, we had a positive experience and do plan to return. It’s a solid spot for a casual night out with good food and great vibes.
Our server, however, seemed upset when she realized we were ordering food, and from that moment on, the experience declined. She ignored us throughout the evening, and when she brought our plates, she placed them down in a dismissive manner. Even when we thanked her, she did not respond.
We also noticed her arguing with the hostess, who had told us it was still okay to order. After that, she focused on cleaning the bar and the area around us, even while we were still seated, which made us feel unwelcome.
I’ve worked in customer service for a long time, and I understand how much reviews can impact a business, so it’s disappointing to have to write this. But I also know how important service is, especially when we are paying for a dining experience. The food is wonderful, but the service needs serious improvement.