Bailie Barrington
This place was very busy! I recommend ordering online prior, that way it’s ready when you get there. They do have a sign when you walk in indicating the wait time between ordering and getting your bagel. I ordered a breakfast sandwich and wow! It was larger than I expected and delicious! Highly recommend!
… moreBritt Harrison
The breakfast bagels were good. They had a wide variety of items you cana choose from. They have a variety of coffee and shakes as well. Food was pretty good, just a little over ripe on the avocado. The staff is very friendly and yhe service was quick.
… moreIan Harrington
Bagels here are okay. Don’t seem like they’re baked from scratch here. Sandwiches are pretty great, my wife and I ordered the Tex Mex and Veggie Bagel and we left satisfied. Wait is a bit long, we had to wait 25 minutes. They even have a sign at the register warning about the wait time. I had a food allergy and the girl at the register was very attentive and so were the food preparers (we heard them express concerns while they were making our bagels as we were waiting). It’s just not a place that knocks your socks off but still very good.
… moreVikki Kulju
The food is delicious and the service is amazing. My only complaint is that their cream cheese is watered down so much that you have to pour it on your bagel instead of spread it on your bagel. The first few times I went through the drive-through I got the cream cheese on the sandwich and it was pouring out the sides. I thought it was maybe because it was just sitting in the heated sandwich that it melted, but when I started ordering it on the side it was the same thing only worse because it wouldn’t really spread. I had to pour it or dunk my bagel.
… moreToni Sacco
Must have stopped in at a busy time. Waited 30+ minutes for our meal, including our drinks. The tuna salad on an everything bagel was worth the wait. So delicious! Just be prepared to invest time.
… moreAutumn C.
Read reviews online & had to go while visiting Marquette. Got the tempting turkey bagel which is fantastic, love the sprouts. Also got a strawberry banana smoothie. Everything was so good that I went back the next morning and ordered the exact same thing.
… moreStephanie Garn
Definitely use the online order pick-up and go to the pick-up window (you can drive or walk up)! This place can get super busy at breakfast and lunch so the wait time can be 25+ minutes. Prices are good for what you get. I absolutely loved the Mediterranean salad, pictured is 1/2 order. Bagels are a bit too large for my liking but at least they are really good. Great food experience after not being here for awhile.
… moreAshley Yaldo
So this review is about just the bagels themselves. They are a good size, great chew and a really nice texture after being toasted. I didn’t get anything crazy, no sandwich or anything on the bagel. Just a toasted bagel with a side of jalapeño cheddar cream cheese. The cream cheese has tiny pieces of fresh jalapeno chopped into it which gave a nice bite and you could see the shreds of cheddar in it as well. It spread really nicely as well.
… moreMadeline Johnson
Really bummed with my experience here. We tried Third Street Bagel for the first time and when we got to the counter they had a sign saying a 15min wait, no problem! Unfortunately, we waited 40 minutes for our bagels and coffees on a Saturday morning. Everyone enjoyed their coffees and the egg/sausage sandwiches were great. Bagels are yummy! This honestly wasn’t that big of a deal, so I decided to try again the next day on our way out of Marquette. Sunday morning at 7:50am, I walked in and there was two other ladies ordering in front of me, two couples sitting down, no wait sign. I ordered two bagel sandwiches, and a hot chocolate. Received my bagels 25 minutes from ordering, and kept waiting on the hot chocolate. It was 40 minutes after ordering and I still did not receive it. Multiple people were getting very frustrated and making comments around me as they were waiting for their drinks, as well. After 50 minutes of waiting for the hot chocolate, I let the girl at the barista bar know I was headed out and she no longer needed to make it, no refund offered (and honestly at this point I didn’t even care). Hadn’t even started on it. The guy next to me commented “I’m ready to just walk out”. Unfortunately, this long wait experience two days in a row really was frustrating and I most likely would not be back. The bagel concept itself is a cool concept, the space is a very cute modern space, and the drinks when we received them were good.
… moreKrishna
Best bagel store in Marquette, offering a wide variety of breakfast options with a delightful atmosphere enhanced by cozy lighting. However, it’s worth noting that there is a waiting time of approximately 30 to 45 minutes for your order. If you’re staying in Marquette, I highly recommend giving this place a try.
… more