Social Profile: 
✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
We’re a small, family-owned and operated pizzeria run by two brothers right here in Middletown, Ohio. What started as a love for great pizza has grown into a place where quality, creativity, and community come first. Every day, we make our dough and sauce from scratch because we believe the best pizza starts with the basics done right. We’re proud to be known for our one-of-a-kind creations like our original Pickle Pie and Pickleroni, along with classic favorites made with care. Whether you’re grabbing a quick bite or sitting down with friends and family, our goal is simple: to give every customer a great experience, great food, and a reason to come back.
Address and Contact Information
Address: 1300 Central Ave, Middletown, OH 45044
Phone: (513) 217-0051
Website: http://www.theslicepie.com/
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Related Web Results
THE SLICE PIE
At The Slice Pie, we take pride in handcrafting each pizza with care and … To cancel, press Escape. Visit Us. 1300 CENTRAL AVE, MIDDLETOWN, OH 45044, US.
The Slice Pie Middletown – Facebook
Whether you’re hosting the party or ditching the dishes, 1300 Central ave Middletown, Oh 45044 Let’s eat. Let’s cheer. Let’s gooooo!. May be an image of …
The Slice, 1300 Central Ave, Middletown, OH 45044, US – MapQuest
… pies, setting them apart from the traditional pizzerias. Aside from their specialty pizzas, The Slice offers a diverse menu featuring wings, salads, and …
Reviews
Jamie Zayas
Cozy family friendly spot, with great food and service❣️ Handmade dough and bagels. A must try … All-American Bagel with Sausage gravy or A Pickle My Roni!!!! Yum ❤️,
… moreSalem Baker
Fred is a super cool and friendly bartender. The pizza is super rad. As a Philly guy, I definitely approve of the pizza. Come check out this spot, anyone else who voted it down – you don’t know what a cool pizza spot it!
… moreKenny Pearson
I really enjoy going to the Slice. They have a wonderful team that is welcoming. The food is always top notch. I love the menu but my favorite is the Buffalo Chicken Hoagie. The Slice takes the time to make their own dough, and buns and it shows. When looking for a place in Middletown to eat this is top choice!
… moreJames Landers
Zero customer support. I placed an order online by mistake 5 days ago, I have never even stepped foot in this location. I called IMMEDIATELY and spoke with a cook who advised they were unable to issue a refund but would ask the bartender when they come in, they were closed at the time. No call back, no follow that day. I have had called back every single day ONCE and speak with someone regarding my refund. EVERYONE says they can’t and will need a manager or the owner process the refund. Here I am, now 5 days in and still no refund or call back. I am now forced to take time out of my day to drive to this location to physically speak to someone to get my refund as the customer service is non existent and apparently no employee has the capacity to issue a damn refund. I’m furious and pissed something so simple has been brushed to the side. My wife and I were excited to try this spot, NO WAY IN HELL I am giving this location a single dime once the refund is processed. I hate writing reviews like this but damn, this is reached new heights of incompetence and agitation.
Update: day 5 I spoke with the manager Brandon, he was helpful and explained they’ve never had to refund an online order but he would look into it and asked me to call back the next day after 5 when he gets in and he should have this taken care of. I do as I was asked but unfortunately just as things looked up, I call back and spoke with the Jamie, the escalator. The situation was fine, until Jamie took offense to my review here and began to call me a liar regarding the mistaken online order and refused to let me speak with Brandon, refused to give me her name and told me Brandon would follow up with me later and did her best to stay vague and talk down to me while “helping me”. As shocked as I was I asked for her name, she refused and continued to speak over me and hung up on me. As my next call was to my CC company to dispute the charges since JAMIE refused to help me with, guess who called back with a completely different attitude and cadence, JAMIE! She explained the refund was submitted and I should expect it in 3-5 days. When I asked why she was so combative with me I received everything as my fault. It wasn’t until I explained everyone I’ve spoken with and ZERO apologies for the inconvenience, THAT is when she said, “We are sorry” begrudgingly. Moral of the story, good customer service goes a long way, so does shitty service too. I wanted to erase this review once the refund was addressed, I planned to make Brandon aware of that on my scheduled call back to him. But not after the convo with Jamie who clearly needs help with her emotional responses. Review my reviews, I RARELY do this, but when push come to shove and you feel like nobody is listening, gotta take it to the next step ♂️. Let’s see if I get that refund in the next 3-5, I’ll keep you posted.
Update: Look at that, less than 24 hrs after the request was submitted my refund shows up. I do want to thank BRANDON for helping, once this concern was brought to his attention, he promptly found a solution, I appreciate your help Brandon. I’d suggest Jamie to stay in her lane moving forward as the goal to help customers is to de-escalate not escalate. So if you order online, yes, you can get a refund and rather quickly when addressed within a reasonable time frame.
… moreUpdate: day 5 I spoke with the manager Brandon, he was helpful and explained they’ve never had to refund an online order but he would look into it and asked me to call back the next day after 5 when he gets in and he should have this taken care of. I do as I was asked but unfortunately just as things looked up, I call back and spoke with the Jamie, the escalator. The situation was fine, until Jamie took offense to my review here and began to call me a liar regarding the mistaken online order and refused to let me speak with Brandon, refused to give me her name and told me Brandon would follow up with me later and did her best to stay vague and talk down to me while “helping me”. As shocked as I was I asked for her name, she refused and continued to speak over me and hung up on me. As my next call was to my CC company to dispute the charges since JAMIE refused to help me with, guess who called back with a completely different attitude and cadence, JAMIE! She explained the refund was submitted and I should expect it in 3-5 days. When I asked why she was so combative with me I received everything as my fault. It wasn’t until I explained everyone I’ve spoken with and ZERO apologies for the inconvenience, THAT is when she said, “We are sorry” begrudgingly. Moral of the story, good customer service goes a long way, so does shitty service too. I wanted to erase this review once the refund was addressed, I planned to make Brandon aware of that on my scheduled call back to him. But not after the convo with Jamie who clearly needs help with her emotional responses. Review my reviews, I RARELY do this, but when push come to shove and you feel like nobody is listening, gotta take it to the next step ♂️. Let’s see if I get that refund in the next 3-5, I’ll keep you posted.
Update: Look at that, less than 24 hrs after the request was submitted my refund shows up. I do want to thank BRANDON for helping, once this concern was brought to his attention, he promptly found a solution, I appreciate your help Brandon. I’d suggest Jamie to stay in her lane moving forward as the goal to help customers is to de-escalate not escalate. So if you order online, yes, you can get a refund and rather quickly when addressed within a reasonable time frame.
Kait Barnes
A favorite since they were Cincy by the Slice in OTR. To this day, the pickleroni is perfect and the environment reminds me of Cheers. My forever home away from home in the form of a restaurant, no matter how far I have to drive. If you like pickles, pizza, or beer, this is the place for you!
… moreMaxwell Hughes
Came here on a random Sunday passing through with my son. We ordered a large pepperoni pizza, it arrived quickly and we devoured it in a few minutes. Very good pizza, old school building and environment. Great place to stop in for a slice(or whole pizza).
… moreAndrea Hamlin
This place was perfect for a quick dinner after ice skating for my daughter’s birthday. They gladly accommodated our large group and the pizza was delicious!
… moreScott Bush
We met here before a high school football game and it was the perfect environment for some pregame fun! The pickle pizza is a must try! Our bartender/waitress Jamie was awesome!
… moreSarah Miller Martin
Wonderful atmosphere great food terrific employees just all around. Good time in great environment with a cozy little atmosphere.
… morealiyah flores
everything here is a no. a lady whom worked there had disrespected my daughter while i was in the restroom and told her to leave because she didn’t “see us order anything “ . (remind you i reserved a table online.) then i seen roaches running in the restroom and mold in the ice holder . if i were you i wouldn’t bring friends nor family around this disgusting place .
… more