Social Profile: 
✔️Breakfast ✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out
… View more
Address and Contact Information
Address: 305 N Main St, New Salem Borough, PA 17371
Phone: (717) 792-1355
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
The Sherwood Inn | York PA – Facebook
The Sherwood Inn Bar & Grill is located just west of York in York-New Salem, PA. Jumbo fresh … See more. Pub · $$.
The Sherwood Inn – New Salem Borough: A Culinary Gem in …
The Sherwood Inn – New Salem Borough … Welcome to The Sherwood Inn, nestled in the heart of New Salem Borough, Pennsylvania. Located at 305 N Main St, this …
The Sherwood Inn in York New Salem – Ask AI | mindtrip
The Sherwood Inn is a charming inn situated in the heart of New Salem Borough, Pennsylvania. This historic establishment features cozy accommodations that …
Reviews
Prometheus
Good place, a couple nick picks, mens restroom had no toilet paper holder, and the waiting room could be bigger if they removed the stairs and just made it one big ramp up to the door that they could extend out the inside.
… moreBrayden Howard
Always great food, great service by consistent waitresses, Renee and Christina are great! good drinks both alcoholic and non-alcoholic. Parking is always available and the outdoor seating is nice to enjoy all seasons! Highly recommend for a small town bite.
… moreJames Danielle
Love the new modern rustic look since they remodeled. I had a work trip in PA and met up with my family for dinner here. I’m completely in love with their bbq cheesesteak (no bun) on top of sweet potato fries and their dessert is out of this world. It’s very laid back and no rush. I enjoyed eating here and will definitely come back in the future when I visit!
… moreNicole Flowers
Christina was an EXCELLENT server! Very accommodating and personable. The filet and shrimp special was extremely delicious. The filet was the best cooked steak I’ve had from a restaurant in a very long time.
… morepattie valencik
I just hosted a retirement party for a very special friend. Tara worked like crazy to make sure the night was flawless. The food and drinks were amazing and everyone spoke about how much fun they had. I highly recommend Sherwood for a stop in for a drink, a dinner, or any event and if you call them for that be sure to ask for Tara.
… morePittman Family
Such a good night at the Sherwood inn! I was out first time and it had such a cool atmosphere and excellent food. We loved their specialty cocktails and specials. Great service from Chloe and Hilary!!!
… moreDesiree Martin
Tara the front house manager was able to accommodate a large party last minute for a birthday party!!!
Brittany our waitress was phenomenal!!!! She handled our large group with such ease and she was so friendly!!!
Everyone LOVED their food!!!
Highly recommend!!!
… moreBrittany our waitress was phenomenal!!!! She handled our large group with such ease and she was so friendly!!!
Everyone LOVED their food!!!
Highly recommend!!!
Tim Miller
Been coming here for years. Good bar to watch a game. Bad place to sit and eat. Food is decent but frequently mistakes with orders. The staff is nice but the wait staff is clearly miserable. Not exaggerating, new servers every week. Not a good sign. Management is poor to say the least. Sorry, I’m going to a new spot from now on.
… moreRobert McGee
A friend had ordered food while I was there, I saw it and it looked fabulous! Went home and ordered food from here myself and went to pick it up. 3 meals can’t to $75. Now I don’t mind paying for good food but everything else that follows will be the reason why I never go back. I went in picked up the food planning to check it in the car. I already realized I didn’t get my drinks. Went back in and told them they forgot one of my sides and two drinks. The lady told me we only ordered one drink. My wife had ordered two drinks. I want gonna argue so I left. Got home, opened food, tater tots for the kids in both meals we’re saturated from steak juice. They didn’t like them. One meal was nachos and cheese, the nachos were so saturated and flimsy and there was nothing in the container that would’ve made them that way. The cheese was separate. My meal was the only one that was decent. Steak was pretty good, the baked potatoe skin was rubbery and not like the one I saw two hours before at my friend’s. Asparagus was nasty. We were not pleased at all. I thought I had found a new favorite spot when I saw my friends food. This is the first and last time I will ever order from there.
… moreBrian Martini
We had an excellent dinner. The new york strip steak was cooked to perfection. The soups were very tasty as well. Our server was the best. Angelina was professional, friendly and very knowledgeable of the menu. Can’t wait to try the prime rib on my next visit.
… more