Matt Felice
Went into this diner today and the male server was terrible. I ordered a burger meal and he didn’t ask me how I wanted it or anything. My girlfriend ordered a Reuben and on the menu that is offered with a couple types of meat. He didn’t ask and she had to stop him as he was about to walk away to tell him what she wanted. He was very short with us and seemed miserable. Our food arrived and her Reuben was served with no sauce or anything, just dry. She has to ask for Russian dressing. My burger arrived and if it wasn’t 18.99 I wouldn’t complain but it was tasteless and the onion rings were ice cold. Once we were served we were never checked on again until we were ready for the check. As a matter of fact one of the other waitresses checked on us probably knowing how terrible and miserable of a server he is. Thank you to her for caring. Two people with a burger meal and a Reuben meal was over 50 dollars with tip. Why go out to these places when I cook better and no one is short with me. Ill never be back. Thanks for the disappointment and confirmation that going out to eat is a huge waste of money. Stay home, don’t come here. Its terrible..
… moreBobby Gianakis
Almost everything is made from scratch.
Great portions , very friendly And clean.
I love many of there meals .
Love the salmon dish.
… moreCalypso (Ashley)
For it being a diner, the overall experience was pleasant.
It seems locals frequent the diner often. Wing specials are promoted on Wednesday and special dinner options are available fri-sun.
I went with a small group for dinner and each ordered unique plates.
Onion soup ($12) – 7/10, I think there was great balance in flavors. I don’t have a reference for onion soup. The sweetness came through.
Cajun burger w/ fries ($17) – came with a generous amounts of jalapeno. For the first time ever, we got medium rare when we asked for it! 9/10
Vegetarian burger w/fries – $16, 8/10 – giving it a good score because it was simple and straightforward. Tasted homemade as well! Not from frozen patty.
Prime rib special (came with cream of broccoli soup and mashed potato’s) – $27. Prime rib was decent, did the job, cooked medium rare and it was pretty generous as well. Cream of broccoli was ok 6/10, nothing crazy. Mashed potato’s were nice 8/10. The person who ordered this was able to take roughly half home to eat from it tomorrow.
The burgers all came with fries.
Service was fast: atmosphere feels a bit outdated but not a damper.
… moreRichard Blahut
The food has been and is spectacular, this is a one star review because of the way the food is prepared to go. I ordered a cheeseburger with french fries on the side, who the heck wants to pick french fries off the top of the cheese on the burger. The fries are ARE A SIDE ORDER, NOT TO BE THROWN ONTOP of the burger. Furthermore, stop cheapening out on the ketchup packets. Years ago, the supplies were adequate and the orders to go had presentation. If the cook just took a few more seconds when preparing the order, the visual presentation would be spectacular matching the taste of the food. Serve the proved properly or I won’t be coming there no more
… moreJ Every
Awful. I had meatloaf sandwich. The “meat” had so many fillers. I made the mistake of looking closing at the meat and I was done. My friend had the cheeseburger… same thing. Gross. The fries were good, Cole slaw was NOT good. Service was slow, but no big deal. The big deal was the mystery meat meatloaf and cheeseburger.
… moreBud 937
We went around 2:30pm on a Saturday, place was not crowded and it was brightly lite.
They have a small selection of desserts right at the front, everything looked fresh.
The fried seafood platter was good, fish and scallops were fried golden brown and tasted fresh.
The turkey burger was not the best, it tasted bland, the fries was perfect.
Our waitress was absent after she served us, she was very nice, and got our order to us quick.
OH! they have good coffee.
We will visit again in the summer and try something else.
… moreLucky Man
It was busy on a Sunday at lunch. I had high hopes, but was disappointed. Everyone has a standard for breakfast food and maybe upstate New York doesnt do it like they do in the midwest and anyone’s explanation as to why would only be the expression of their own subjective values. That said, this menu was a mess. Way too big. It becomes clear that when a restaurant does it all, none of it is very exceptional. The food was fine, the service was great.
… moreChris Bender
My wife and I have eaten at the Red Hook diner many times and always enjoyed it. The owner and the staff are very friendly and attentive to the customers. The food is always delicious and prices are reasonable. I specifically love the hot roast beef plate, and the Cobb salad.
… moreTML
Stopped in while I was passing through. The place was large, clean and airy and we were seated immediately. The food was fresh and hot and served quickly. The attention to customers was excellent and my coffee cup was never empty. Prices were very reasonable. Enjoyed everything.
… moreKaren Mac
Horrible! I got the taco salad. It had no flavor except salt. My mom got the eggplant sub. Not enough sauce and burned. Our experience was awful. Mom was sick in an hour and I was sick the next day. Never going there again! Don’t do it! Also pricy for lunch.
… more