Homey polished eatery with some fairy-tale flair serves burgers, quesadillas & more eclectic fare.
Tom Diethrich
Went here for the first time on a Saturday afternoon around 4. There were four of us, ages 55-60. We were seated right away, and I didn’t time it, but it seemed to take longer than usual for our server to come.
Server was friendly and efficient. We ordered the Crab Soup, which was amazing, a basket of fries, which we also loved, and a Cobb Salad. The salad was pretty disappointing. Lettuce was super fresh, but only one cherry tomato and one egg on the salad was very different from most places we have ordered Cobb Salad in the past. We split a pitcher of Grimsters White, which was very good. We asked our server if we could try some first since we didn’t know exactly what it was and it only came in a pitcher, and she said she didn’t think so, which was no big deal, just inconvenient.
Overall a good experience. Quiet enough to talk, old time Gettysburg feel inside. We will go back if we end up in the area again!
… moreJosh
We stopped in for a bite to eat on a Saturday. The square was busy with people but we were able to get seated very quickly. We started with the Buffalo Fries which delicious with just right about of heat. I went with the chipotle bbq wings with ranch and they were really good as well. As you can see from pictures the portions were more than enough. My wife had the French onion soup and she agreed that it was one of the best she had had. Our food arrived quickly and the service was outstanding. Our server was knowledgeable of the menus and answered all our questions. Restrooms were nice and clean. Also have a room upstairs for large parties.
… moreDaryl Holstay
It had been awhile we had dined at the Pub, and we brought some friends for their first time. Overall service from Tim was great and they loved the atmosphere, but both our sandwiches were a bit dry. I ordered extra sauce which helped a bit. My wife and I split a Hawaiian Chicken sandwich and our friends ordered the Grimster Beef. Both had good flavor, but harder to chew due to being dried out. Our sweet potato fries and their beer battered fries were great. Started with the Crab soup, which was great also. It just might have been an off night for us. Always was a great stop before tonight.
… moreCourtney Greiner
Went for an early dinner so the place wasn’t very crowded. Food was great and drinks were wonderful. Inside decoration made the place fun and a perfect date spot. Would definitely go there again.
… moreEmily Good
A lovely experience at The Pub. Delicious food and drinks, friendly staff. No wait on a busy Saturday evening. The mozzarella sticks were great, the American chicken sandwich was good, and the sweet potato fries were amazing. Super happy with our choice to dine here while visiting town.
… moreDrew S
We came in around 2p looking to have some drinks and lunch. We sat down at the bar and ordered drinks to start. After sitting there for alil it was clear the bartender was overwhelmed as she was handling the drinks for the dining room, the bar, and also waiting on the tables in the bar area all by herself. She truly was doing the best she absolutely could. What was odd to me was it seemed as though there was no manager on site at that time. Someone had made a complaint about a food item and she had to call someone justifying why it needed to be taken off the check.
I didn’t appreciate upper management not being in the building and supporting their team like they should be, and if they were in the building they weren’t doing a great job at supporting them.
Ultimately we had 1 drink and left. The 2 starsI am leaving is for that bartender, for how hard she was hustling, I would give zero stars to the owners for putting her through that, if I could.
… moreRon-amoe
Wonderful Street Cafe and Pub. We chose to sit outside on the sidewalk. The View of the circle after the Memorial Day Parade was awesome. The salmon and the mahi-mahi I never tasted great dishes. The dessert carrot cake was the largest cake I ever seen LOL. The service was outstanding.
… moreChristina Danley
Great food with unique vibes. Fairy’s in Tiffany style glass but still maintaining historical charm. The food was delicious. My burger was cooked perfectly medium and my husband loved his French onion soup; as did our toddler who devoured the pretzel dipped in the soup. Portions are generous, and we were too full for dessert so decided to get one of their desserts in a jar to go. Service was good and prompt even on a busy weekend evening during the reenactment weekend.
… moreterrance townsend
Five-Star Experience in Gettysburg: Shout-out to Brianna!
I have to post this review immediately because the service and food here are genuinely outstanding!
Yesterday, I had the homemade clam chowder, and it was absolutely phenomenal. Today, I followed that up with the crab soup served in a bread bowl, alongside a crisp Cobb salad—the soup is truly to die for!
What makes this place exceptional is the staff. I’ve had the same server, Brianna, for the last two days, and I cannot even begin to express how impressed I am. Her professionalism, service, and attitude are all 100% spot on. She is friendly, attentive, respectful, and perfectly engaging.
The atmosphere of the restaurant is laid-back and friendly, making it a perfect spot to relax. Between the extraordinary food and the top-tier service provided by Brianna, this place is a must-visit. Highly, highly recommend! Thank you for making my trip so enjoyable.
… moreShan
The smell when we walked in concerned me. It didn’t smell like food…more of a musty, dirty carpet smell. We both had chicken in our meals and it was quite chewy and dry; however the flavor was good. The carrot cake was absolutely amazing and our waiter was great.
… more