Malik Ajala
Everything was great here. We had octopus, steak tartare with parmigian cheese , fried tomatoes and lamb shoulder!
I love the fact that they had N/A Amaro! Loved it
… moreJennifer Abbott
The most darling dinner spot. Service was exceptional and the flavors new and refreshing! The roasted chicken was incredible. The lemon ice cream with meringue blew our minds and we hadn’t even planned to get it until we saw it at the table next to us.
… moreTasha Edwardh
Hands down the best dinner we’ve had in awhile!! We started out with Burrata & Shishito pepper dish, which was one of the specials that were off menu as well as the fried green tomatoes. Chefs kiss on both. We followed up with the za ‘tar spiced tuna and the grilled bavette steak. Both were exceptional! The service was both excellent and attentive. 20/10
… moreMaura R
I thought I wrote this review before. It’s been two years, but it’s still worth sharing.
My husband and I hosted a long table dinner for 18 friends here two years ago. Most were visiting Nantucket for the first time. When I looked at the menu beforehand, everything sounded good but not particularly remarkable. Once the food arrived, though, we were blown away. Anna designed a small plate menu around a few selections we shared ahead of time. Every dish was prepared so well. So simple and so delicious! .
Service, drinks, and ambiance were all 10/10. It’s such a charming and warm spot. We still talk about that night – it was our favorite meal that trip.
Highly recommend!
… moreDaniel Zezheng Jiang
The best dining experience in town for me in Nantucket. My girlfriend and I had a great laugh chatting in the relaxing environment. I strongly recommend a visit here with loved ones. The staff were extremely friendly. They helped me understand the menu and patiently explain the dishes to me. I was amazed by the creativity of the menu. I loved the arctic char salmon so much that I even licked the plate, not even mentioning how it was well-represented!! We had a great time sitting outside while enjoying the ambiance outdoors. It is definitely a great memory for us.
… moreRobyn Em
Have visited props several times across the years when I have been on Nantucket. They have consistently delivered and I find it refreshing to discover a new menu each season but which carries through the same feeling and quality. I live in London and for this level of food (mouth wateringly, lick the plate good) and the source of the ingredients (local, prepped on site) the prices are in line with major cities.
This restaurant strikes a spot between fine dining but with a relaxed and familial atmosphere. It’s not budget because you are paying for the sourcing. I feel this is overlooked in some reviews. The portions are designed for sharing and trying the broader menu. The cherry snap pea salad sent me to heaven and as a vegetarian there is a great range, with vegetables not left on the back seat unlike many locations. Experienced attentive and friendly service throughout. Love how much fruit they get into dishes. Cocktails not to miss.
… moreBig Frank
The food here is phenomenal. The atmosphere is great. My one knock is the price tag. If you can get past that (if you can’t then you shouldn’t be in Nantucket)then you’ll have a great meal. Standout for us was the carrots but there was nothing that we ordered that we didn’t enjoy. I absolutely recommend this spot.
… moreJoseph Kim
Was seated on the second floor which had really nice vibe. All the plates were unique and vintage which were beautiful.
Portion is bit small, but all the dishes were perfect! – best hummus I had in my life. The server was also very friendly.
The only thing I didn’t like was diet coke because it came out in a tall thin glass with full of ice. It tasted bit like water and charged me $5 per glass. Even after two glasses, it felt little less than regular can.
… moreStacey McKenzie
Unique dining experience. Gourmet flavored food. NOT your traditional dining place. If you are open to try something new and discover new flavors that is your place. Every season menu changes. Drinks are good. Staff is aways friendly. This season menu is mostly vegetable based. As a meat lover i was open to try different veggie options. Be open minded. Menu is definitely better than last summer. Prices are high I guess something normal for downtown Nantucket restaurant experience.
… moreAmanda Reagan
Such a quaint spot. It was very busy when we went on stroll weekend, but we had a great time.
… more