Jacob Roedell
Pizza tastes mid (i.e I’ve had more flavor in a dominoes pizza), but they don’t know how to properly time the oven. No real form. Mushy. Impossible to pick up. Avoid if possible as the price is ridiculous for only being pickup.
… moreTim
A very good and huge slice of pizza! I will say one slice was a complete dinner for me! Keep in mind this is their second location and it doesn’t have everything that the Germantown location has. BUT if you want a nice slice of pizza this would be a good spot! The Germantown location is much bigger with a complete bar but with just as good pizza also!
… moreRobyn Brandon
My husband and I just had a pepperoni slice and a cheese slice. They were massive and only $5.50. The crust was crispy and the flavor was great. If you want a New York style Alice, go here.
The staff was also super friendly!
… moree t
The pizza here is perfect. I especially love that they pile on toppings and offer great olives. The restaurant decor itself, though, leaves a lot to be desired, and sitting outside can be nice, but it’s right on Bardestown so traffic noise is incredibly loud. I prefer to carry a pizza out, but they also offer slices which are nice.
… morehank marshall
We purchased a 20 inch pizza and breadsticks. Prepaid for take out. Food was ready prior to estimated pick up time.
The food was delicious and one of the best NY style in the area. I honestly wish there was a post closer to where I live. But it will still be a nice treat to come and order from here now and again.
… morerachel lenard
We ordered a pie from here on vacation. I’m pleasantly surprised by how awesome this pizza is. It was thin crust and so flavorful. Also, extremely affordable. We ordered it for pick up. Would recommend to anyone!
… moreZach Fry, The Real Estate Guy!
You’re not coming to The Post’s carryout location for the ambiance — you’re coming for the pie. And the pie is on point.
This is what pizza’s supposed to taste like: thin, crisp bottom with that whisper of cornmeal, just enough chew in the crust to keep it honest, and toppings that are balanced instead of chaotic. No grease-slicked regret here — just clean, thoughtful execution by people who clearly care about doing it right.
The vibe? It’s a pizza pickup joint. No candles. No curated playlists. But if you’re the kind of person who cares more about what’s in the box than what’s on the walls, this is your spot.
Skip the fluff. Order the pie. Thank yourself later.
… moreSerge
Best pizza in the city! Stopped the bardstown location and Marty was very friendly and gave great recommendations! Will be back !!
… morePete McClellan
The Post G-town may have a bar and restaurant but Bardstown Post has the best staff- hands downs!!
The guys there are always on their game with customer service and consistent quality. I live clear to G-town but go out of my way for the Bardstown experience and taste.
… moreMichael Culver
10/10 There is nothing to improve about this pizza quality. Huge slice, perfectly seasoned and built, baked to perfection. Excellent quality crispness and foldability. Great decision to stop here.
… more