Social Profile: 
✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Hours
| Sunday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Monday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Tuesday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Wednesday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–9 PM |
Address and Contact Information
Address: 10 Chesterfield Rd, East Lyme, CT 06333
Phone: (860) 739-2054
Website: http://www.theplumtomato.com/
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
East Lyme Menu – The Plum Tomato
To see our most updated menu, please visit our online menu powered by Toast –. https://order.toasttab.com/online/the-plum-tomato-chesterfield-east-lyme.
East Lyme, CT Location – The Plum Tomato
Welcome to our new location in East Lyme, CT! We’re very excited to serve you.
The Plum Tomato East Lyme – Order Online
Order online from The Plum Tomato East Lyme, including Appetizers, Salads, Quesadilla Corner … The Plum Tomato East Lyme. 10 Chesterfield Road, East Lyme, CT.
Reviews
Nicole Bruce
Ordered online for this one. Pizza was fantastic. So happy that they offer vegan cheese and a vegan sausage. We ended up choosing those toppings as well as hot peppers. Absolutely delicious. Thank you for having vegan options, we will 1000% be getting pizza here again(definitely as a dine in next time) ✨
… moreDan
The service here was great! The person handling the counter was friendly and easy to talk to. I’ve been looking for a good mashed potato pizza for a while so I ordered the large (18″) Loaded Van Gogh (mashed potato, bacon, broccoli, scallions, cheddar, and Alfredo). It tasted great and was right out of the oven when I picked it up.
Few cons though for this order. It unfortunately wasn’t a true mashed potato pizza. There was a crumbled baked potato on top which doesn’t give the same texture. So loaded baked potato pizza, yes. Mashed potato, no. Secondly, the toppings were mostly in the center of the pizza leaving a band of just cheese near the crust (could have used just a bit more potato too, or at least some smaller chunks and better dispersement). Lastly, it’s on the higher end for pizza at $28 for a large (although not alone at that price point in East Lyme). There are A LOT of pizza options within 10-20 minutes of here that are a little cheaper. So if stocking up for a party, this would be a difficult choice.
Overall, I enjoyed the pizza when I brought it home and enjoyed it for multiple days later with the leftovers. It wasn’t a true mashed potato pizza, but it still had a good flavor where the toppings were. The price point might not be as big of a concern if there were more toppings or at least had them better dispersed over the full area, but I found myself rearranging the pieces a bit when heating it up. Customer service was great though!
… moreFew cons though for this order. It unfortunately wasn’t a true mashed potato pizza. There was a crumbled baked potato on top which doesn’t give the same texture. So loaded baked potato pizza, yes. Mashed potato, no. Secondly, the toppings were mostly in the center of the pizza leaving a band of just cheese near the crust (could have used just a bit more potato too, or at least some smaller chunks and better dispersement). Lastly, it’s on the higher end for pizza at $28 for a large (although not alone at that price point in East Lyme). There are A LOT of pizza options within 10-20 minutes of here that are a little cheaper. So if stocking up for a party, this would be a difficult choice.
Overall, I enjoyed the pizza when I brought it home and enjoyed it for multiple days later with the leftovers. It wasn’t a true mashed potato pizza, but it still had a good flavor where the toppings were. The price point might not be as big of a concern if there were more toppings or at least had them better dispersed over the full area, but I found myself rearranging the pieces a bit when heating it up. Customer service was great though!
Matthew Biggins
Dave is amazing! Service was almost better than the food. Pictured is the Ali without cheese but with sauce. Definitely add sauce but go vegan cheese at a minimum or the sandwich is way too messy. Delicious loose sausage and peppers on Gluten-free bread!
… moreMark Hewes
We, and visiting family, have always loved Plum Tomato in Colchester so we did not hesitate to stop for dinner in Flanders when we saw Plum Tomato. We are glad we did for the margherita pizza was spectacular as was the service and wine. Our server waas so pleasant, professional and gracious.
… morekevin thibdeau
First time eating here today. We ordered 4 pizzas and received a 5th one for free. First impressions clean bright atmosphere. Gentleman running the kitchen and dining area was friendly and promptly greeted me upon entering. Took the pizzas to go as we had a birthday party down the road. When we got to eating them was very surprised. Multiple people there commented on the pizza being very delicious. Crust had a good crunch to it, just the right amount of cheese. Generous portions of tasty pepperoni but the star of all of them was the sauce. That sauce was stand out. Had a nice sweet note yet there was a tang that balanced perfectly on your tongue. In a world where we have pizza places all over, next time I’m in town this will definitely be my go to. Excellent all around.
… moreVincenzo Moccia
I love to give a shout out to a restaurant that really comes through with a good product and good service. 4 other guys and myself went here for our lunch break. I decided to get the nutty chicken salad. I’m thinking, yeah, well, they make their chicken salad so hopefully it would be good. I got their creamy balsamic vinaigrette, which uses their housemaid, creamy garlic sauce. I was absolutely blown away. My co-workers around me took bites of their sandwiches and a look of surprise that it wasn’t busier on a Sunday. They all ranted and raved about this place and couldn’t believe that they haven’t been here before. It seemed like everything was made with quality in mind, and i’m glad that we just happened to stop here.
… moreVanessa Russo
The cheeseburger quesadilla might be one of the best things I’ve ever eaten. Great portion for the cost. & they have a points system where you get rewards which is awesome!
… moreAll good things roofing management
Sells gluten free pizza and bread based on my reaction this morning I assume they cook it all in the same ovens or just simple mishandle the product in the kitchen. Not great if you can’t eat gluten avoid here.
Prices are high and taste is boring wish I had my $75 bucks back on this one
… morePrices are high and taste is boring wish I had my $75 bucks back on this one
BlueBox Media
So much potential with these pizzas, but the crusts is utterly flavorless. They need to bomb it with parmasian or something before cooking it, or add more salt to the recipe.
… moreAlice Nisa Gurz
I had ordered pizza for my daughter’s birthday party by using their online ordering system and picked a specific time frame, not ASAP. We were planning to have pizza after the entertainment but pizza arrived 45 minutes early! They didn’t even notice the desired time frame on the order and they sent the pizza early so I had to serve cold pizza to my guests! Once the pizza arrived, I called the place and ask for a fresh pizza at the time specified in online order. Nobody got back to me… I don’t recommend this place at all!
… more