Hours
| Tuesday | 11 AM–8 PM |
| Wednesday | 11 AM–8 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–8 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Sunday | 12 AM–7 PM |
| Monday | 11 AM–8 PM |
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Islip | The Pizzeria in Islip, NY
Visit The Pizzeria in Islip, NY at 591 Main St. Open Monday – Thursday: 11 am – 8 pm, Friday & Saturday: 11 am – 9 pm, and Sunday: 12 pm – 7 pm.
Islip | The Pizzeria | Pizza Place in NY
The Pizzeria in New York is a quick serve pizza slice shop. Pizza, Takeout, Dinner, in Bayport, Islip, and Lake Grove, NY.
The Pizzeria of Islip – Islip, NY Restaurant | Menu + Delivery
Order with Seamless to support your local restaurants! View menu and reviews for The Pizzeria of Islip in Islip, plus popular items & reviews.
Reviews
Magali Gomez
I found this place by change in Google. We were 3, and loved the fact that we could sit and dine in as an informal setting. We ordered a few slices and wow, everything was delicious! Drinking a refreshing beer made everything better. I will definitely go back when in the area again.
… moreMichael Kaiser
Great Buffalo chicken slices and I like the Buffalo garlic knots. I need to try the regular knots next time. The only thing that through me off was there are 3 doors in the front. 2 go to the pizzeria but only 1 actually opens and the middle door goes upstairs.
… moreKrystal
5 Star for both food and Price. 2 huge slices of NY pizza, 8 garlic knots, and a drink for $10 and change. That’s amazing to me.
… moreJoseph Armetta
I ordered a regular pie half pepperoni, After I waited over 1hr I received an uncook pizza, therefor, I called to complain and they offered to send another pizza which I specified well done! Unfortunately, I didnt receive a well done pixza but worse than the first pizza. Don’t waste your money in this place….. unprofessional pizza makers
… moreSharon Hendricks
Just tried this pizza spot for the first time today. I tried the one in Islip because the Bay Shore one doesnt deliver yet where I live. The pizza tasted really good. The ingredients tasted fresh, crust was baked to perfection and sauce did not tasty like it was canned. Unfortunately, the garlic knots disappointed in size as they were not actually “garlic knots”, but ” garlic bites”. They were however really good well seasoned and not soggy like other pizza places. I think if anything they should change the name to, ” garlic bites” and charge according to that size.
… moreGlenn Brewer
This pizzeria gives us one more reason to LOVE our town. Delicious, hot , fresh pizza. Before we left, they even asked if our two kids wanted to come behind the counter and help! These people know how to make excellent pizza , but also know excellent service and genuinely love what they do. We will be back!
… moresharon butler
One of the best pizza places around. Great variety, clean restaurant, friendly attentive staff. Kassy is the sweetest. Such a warm welcoming smile in her face.
… moreMatt Ferraro
Very Good food, very good local business that appreciates the town and allows kids to go there after school….and a huge bonus they have clean bathrooms! Well done pizzeria!
… moreLois Kim
Chicken bacon ranch is mediocre, it’s under seasoned. The zeppolis are way too doughy. It was still wet inside. Mediocre pizza place at best.
… moreAnthony Boodhai
My taste buds are in UTOPIA, this slice of pizza makes me feel EUPHORIC. Exceptional Service. Thank you Danny, Falco, Greg, James and all the staff at “the PIZZERIA. Love you guys!!! Islip/Bayport.
… more