Social Profile: 
✔️Brunch ✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Serving up authentic, handcrafted pies made with the freshest ingredients and a whole lot of love. From classic favorites to creative specialties, every slice is made to bring people together. Beyond pizza, we’re proud to serve a variety of Italian dishes and offer catering for any occasion. We also feature a full bar, perfect for pairing your meal with your favorite drink. Dine in, take out, or order online — your neighborhood pizza spot, done right.
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Bay Shore, NY – The Pizzeria
11 Maple Ave., Bay Shore, NY 11706 (631) 686-3555 Hours VIEW MENUS Enjoy a diverse menu, full bar, and daily specials at The Pizzeria in Bay Shore.
Pizzeria Restaurant | The Pizzeria | Long Island
A restaurant with tables and chairs and a bar. Bay Shore. 11 Maple Ave, Bay Shore, NY 11706. ( …
The Pizzeria of Bay Shore – Order Online
THE PIZZERIA Locations and Ordering Hours ; The Pizzeria of Babylon. (631) 314-4500 · 217 East Main Street, Babylon, NY 11702 ; The Pizzeria of Bay Shore. (631) …
Reviews
Rain-e Dio
Decent grandma slice…. and the eggplant with arugula, peppers balsamic slice pretty good. Place is a pretty noisy party atmosphere on a Friday night. So if you like quiet its probably not a good place to go to sit and eat unless you’re OK with not hearing yourself think or not bring able to talk/hear someone at your table. Grab and go or stay and enjoy the pub type atmosphere.
… moreDaniel Miranda
Absolutely incredible experience at The Pizzeria of Bayshore! From the moment you walk in, you can tell this place is special — the restaurant is beautiful, spotless, and has a welcoming atmosphere that makes you feel comfortable right away.
The service is truly top-notch. Every staff member I interacted with was friendly, attentive, and genuinely kind, making sure everything was perfect throughout the visit.
And the food… outstanding. Everything not only looks amazing when it comes out, but tastes even better. You can really tell they care about quality and presentation. They also have a bar with fantastic drinks that pair perfectly with the meal.
Honestly, I’ve been to a lot of pizza places, and this one blows all the others out of the water. If you’re looking for phenomenal pizza, great drinks, and exceptional service, The Pizzeria of Bayshore is an absolute must-visit. I can’t wait to come back!
… moreThe service is truly top-notch. Every staff member I interacted with was friendly, attentive, and genuinely kind, making sure everything was perfect throughout the visit.
And the food… outstanding. Everything not only looks amazing when it comes out, but tastes even better. You can really tell they care about quality and presentation. They also have a bar with fantastic drinks that pair perfectly with the meal.
Honestly, I’ve been to a lot of pizza places, and this one blows all the others out of the water. If you’re looking for phenomenal pizza, great drinks, and exceptional service, The Pizzeria of Bayshore is an absolute must-visit. I can’t wait to come back!
Michelle C
Stumbled upon the Pizzeria while going to a show. The place is super cute , Jaime our waitress was a doll. The food well hot damn run don’t walk! We had the arancini in vodka sauce, the aunt Danielle pizza and the pesto chicken sandwich. The vodka sauce was 10/10. The chicken sandwich was perfect you could smell the basil
… moreLiz
My boyfriend and I had a great experience here on several occasions. Our first time we had 2 appetizers and some slices – ALL delicious. Another time we went with friends and ordered meals (not pictured) and the food was fantastic. It’s the perfect place for a quick bite or a dinner. The outside seating was perfect for the summer and the staff are very friendly. We would highly recommend!
… moreMimi Sorrentino
I had the best chicken parm sandwich with vodka sauce, and it was nothing short of spectacular. The flavors were perfectly balanced, and the sandwich was cooked to perfection. My friend enjoyed an amazing chicken salad, which was fresh and full of flavor. The welcoming atmosphere and attentive service made our visit even more enjoyable. A fantastic spot for a delicious meal!
… moreBilly Vec
Pizza on BOGO night was almost uneatable. Tasted like a reheated frozen pie. Babylon spot is great but genuinely have never had a slice of pizza that bad in my life.
… moreTara
I ordered this tasty caesar salad pizza wrap from the pizzeria made to perfection. Their service is awesome and welcoming. Their food is just as delicious. Both pizza and pizza wrap, I have ordered so far made to perfection!
… moreAme Chicas
great food but service is a bit rude. Place has great seating though
… moreEric Proctor
THE EPITOME OF DELICIOUS! Took me back to Italy, the pizza is SPOT ON. Wow. I couldn’t think of anything else while inhaling my slices except how happy I was. Atmosphere is excellent. Place was very busy but very efficient and friendly. Lots of people coming in for lunch and roomy for everyone to stay. My first time trying them, they’re going on my food map, would 10/10 buy again.
… moreMin Hee Yang
Their pizza was one of the best pizzas we ever had. No wonder why they were so high in ratings. The food, service & the atmosphere were top notch. Our server, Ashley, was so sweet and attentive and made us feel welcomed.
We aren’t from this area but will definitely come back when we visit this town again!
… moreWe aren’t from this area but will definitely come back when we visit this town again!