Social Profile: 
✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Hours
| Monday | Closed |
| Tuesday | Closed |
| Wednesday | 4–10 PM |
| Thursday | 4–10 PM |
| Friday | 4 PM–12 AM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–12 AM |
| Sunday | Closed |
Address and Contact Information
Address: 4135 Lake Rd, Williamson, NY 14589
Phone: (315) 904-4407
Website: https://pizzastoppultneyville.hrpos.heartland.us/menu
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
The Pizza Stop Pub and Bistro | Williamson NY – Facebook
The Pizza Stop Pub and Bistro, Williamson. 2841 likes · 4 talking about this · 27 were here. Welcome to the newest Pizza Stop location! The Pizza…
The Pizza Stop, 4135 Lake Rd, Williamson, NY 14589, US – MapQuest
Pizza Stop Pub & Bistro is a casual dining establishment in Williamson, NY that offers a variety of pizzas, pub fare, and bistro-style dishes.
Reviews
Chris Savage
Very unique experience for NY Pizza. It’s been a while since I’ve had true authentic NY style pizza. It was delicious. My wife enjoyed the 3 slices I brought home. Even cold, she loved it! Will definitely go again.
… moreWilliam Stubler
The pizza and wings here are phenomenal and I had a great experience ordering takeout for a party (17 people). The order was ready on time and everything was just as amazing as it is when we dine-in! The choke n’ chicken pizza and the garlic parm wings are particularly delicious.
… moreNathan Bantle
Located in parallel with another restaurant now. The pizza was great. We kept it very simple and the sauce, dough and texture was spot on. Getting it fresh the bottom is crispy and not soggy which is a bonus with sheet pizza. It’s a touch on the thicker side if you like that. Can’t wait to try again with some more fun pizzas!
… moreChip Eats
Stopped in late after a day playing on the lake. Google had some information wrong and we walked in a few minutes after the kitchen closed. They were super friendly and still fired up an over to make the best pizzas I’ve had in years. Close your eyes and you’re in Brooklyn, maybe even better because they nailed the Buffalo too!
I can’t say enough about the staff, atmosphere, and HOSPITALITY we received. This was the perfect end to our day. They took us from a great day to FREAKING AMAZING!!!!
… moreI can’t say enough about the staff, atmosphere, and HOSPITALITY we received. This was the perfect end to our day. They took us from a great day to FREAKING AMAZING!!!!
Michelle
We visit Pultneyville regularly and always like to get some takeout locally. The last time we ordered a 2 topping medium pizza it was $20 and it was one of the absolute best pizzas we ever had. We just got another one Sat Sept 20th 2025, A medium 2 topping pizza… the toppings were disappointingly very few, the taste wasn’t all that good and it cost $27! Sadly we won’t return here with the price hike and lower quality.
… moreCole Jensen
Bustling place on the shores of lake Ontario. Employees are extremely friendly and helpful. They had a gluten free pizza option which was awesome as well. The meatball Parm pizza and mozzarella garlic knots were killer. Pizza Sauce was flavorful and crust was crispy. The location and layout of the restaurant was fun as well.
… moreSarah C
So since you won’t return my calls or answer my messages, I am going to post this here:
I ordered a pizza on 9/11. When I got there I could smell something burning and was told they burnt my pizza and they are making another one right now, so I had to wait, again. Finally get my pizza, drive 15-20 to get home. We open the box, the cheese is barely melted, the crust on top isn’t really brown but the bottom is burnt. I tried to call that night to talk to the owner or manager, but was told no one was available and I would get a call back. Still have not received any calls. You were our favorite pizza place, I mean we drive from Ontario (closer to Webster) to get this pizza. We were disgusted with the pizza and very upset we never received a call back. This is very disappointing!
… moreI ordered a pizza on 9/11. When I got there I could smell something burning and was told they burnt my pizza and they are making another one right now, so I had to wait, again. Finally get my pizza, drive 15-20 to get home. We open the box, the cheese is barely melted, the crust on top isn’t really brown but the bottom is burnt. I tried to call that night to talk to the owner or manager, but was told no one was available and I would get a call back. Still have not received any calls. You were our favorite pizza place, I mean we drive from Ontario (closer to Webster) to get this pizza. We were disgusted with the pizza and very upset we never received a call back. This is very disappointing!
Abraham Long
Who knew you could get amazing pizza in the middle of nowhere? Like seriously better than most in Rochester. Fun fact: there is another Pizza Stop location in the city that’s just as good.
… moreKevin James
I’m an understanding guy so this review is well deserved. The pie wasn’t prepared as I’d requested and also was over 20mins late out of the oven. Had it atleast been decent I would’ve gladly overlooked the shortcomings. But it wasnt. It was honestly one of the worst pizzas I’ve ever had which is why half of it was thrown in the trash!!
Hey Josh and Amanda. Heres a tip. Go back to the drawing board and do some research and development on your product and then you won’t need to have your friends and family come to google and load these reviews with unworthy 5 stars.
… moreHey Josh and Amanda. Heres a tip. Go back to the drawing board and do some research and development on your product and then you won’t need to have your friends and family come to google and load these reviews with unworthy 5 stars.
Allen Pickard
Just opened ,bar will be open Friday night, we had the chicken bacon ranch,and the sweet and sour bacon ranch, and some garlic knots,pizza was amazing, but he did let us have a beer with are pizza,there might be a few people from the reunion bar, from Seabreeze that will be bar tending,so come check it out, take out is avalable
… more