Social Profile: 
![]()
✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Address and Contact Information
Address: 604 W Jefferson Ave, Effingham, IL 62401
Phone: (217) 347-7766
Website: https://www.pizzamaneffingham.com/
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
The Pizza Man – Restaurant in Effingham, IL
The Pizza Man in Effingham, IL. Call us at (217) 347-7766. We offer pizza dine-in, delivery, carryout, salad bar, wings, subs, sides, dressings, and more.
Pizza Man of Effingham Inc. – Facebook
Pizza Man of Effingham Inc. is in Effingham, IL. Dec 22, 2025 · . . When the GRINCH shows up and decides to help in the kitchen!!! Come see us TODAY …
The Pizza Man – Visit Effingham
The Pizza Man. Visit Website · 604 W. Jefferson Ave, Exit 159 Effingham, Illinois 62401 · +1 (217) 347-7766. Hours of Operation: Monday: Closed; Tuesday …
Reviews
Tom Z
First, this review is written by someone that lives in a city that has a family owned pizza place on nearly every couple of blocks of a main street.
The pizza was good. I really liked the sauce, the flavor was spot on. The sausage had a very good flavor, though there was a limited amount of sausage on the pizza. There was a little too much cheese for my taste. Where the pizza dropped off was the crust. I think it has potential, but I don’t get the foil on the bottom of the box, I think it holds the moisture against the bottom of the crust.
I also had garlic bread and it was pretty good.
The people there were super friendly and had the order done very quickly. I love the the quality of the customer service.
… moreThe pizza was good. I really liked the sauce, the flavor was spot on. The sausage had a very good flavor, though there was a limited amount of sausage on the pizza. There was a little too much cheese for my taste. Where the pizza dropped off was the crust. I think it has potential, but I don’t get the foil on the bottom of the box, I think it holds the moisture against the bottom of the crust.
I also had garlic bread and it was pretty good.
The people there were super friendly and had the order done very quickly. I love the the quality of the customer service.
Matt J
Some of the worst spaghetti and lasagna I’ve ever had. We wasted $26 on them and ate three bites total. Pizza wasn’t bad but overdone for sure. Salad not great and horrible placement of the salad bar. Complete waste of $50 we will not give it a second chance. Ordering at the counter is not a restaurant. Leave that to fast food places. Shocked the place is still in business
… moreSharon W
I’m 52 & I absolutely LOVED going here my whole life! I moved away in 2010 and just recently ate here for the first time in many years. I was super disappointed that they put sheetrock over 2 of the brick walls and took away the red lights above the tables and installed puck lights on the ceiling instead. They also took out the pinball machine. I really missed the old Pizza Man that I grew up with. It was a piece of history that never should’ve been updated. The pizza still tasted the same, though, which was excellent!
… moreMichelle
This place is amazing!!! It was very busy but the staff remained friendly and worked diligently on each order. Very organized. We don’t have anything like this in my home town unfortunately. The Italian sub was a bit salty but thick with meats. We drove over an hour to try this place….worth it.
… moreNancy Durbin
I would of gave a 5 stars food is delicious. The problem is I had was the salad bar. Last time I was here 4 boys reached over to the shoestring potatoes and was eating with their fingers out of the container over and over and this time 2 girls was doing the same with sunflower seeds. I think this is very unsanitary . It makes me sick enough to not want to go back. If it was me I would post a sign and put sunflower seeds in a pour container . Maybe turn salad bar opposite way. Kids are doing this and parents aren’t even paying attention because they are ordering and paying.
… moreMark Risacher
So bad.
20 min late, so cold
Only 2 peps on entire pizza,
Wings soggy when sauce should have been on side.
How do you stay in business?
Never again for me Pizza Man
… more20 min late, so cold
Only 2 peps on entire pizza,
Wings soggy when sauce should have been on side.
How do you stay in business?
Never again for me Pizza Man
Jags Fan69
Really the worst wings and sauces I’ve ever had I hate to say bad things about anybody’s business but what I had tonight was a travesty just terrible they pictured them on they’re website as what wings I’m used to but what we got was bread heavy chewy lack luster wings with just as terrible sauces to match bbq Buffalo and garlic parm that one not even close to what I’m use to not dry rub just some moist creamy mess AVOID the Wings
… moreSally Jones Reed
The last several times my friends and I have eaten there we have been really disappointed. It used to be our favorite place for pizza at lunch. We thought maybe just a fluke the first time but after several times definitely not. The crust is like eating cardboard. It’s just not what it used to be. We just can’t do it anymore.☹️ Other than the cardboard crust everything else is great.
… moremichael fassnacht
We stopped here to grab some food on our way home. I’m glad we did. The place was packed and they were super busy but it was worth the wait. The staff was friendly and the food was great. I’m glad we got 2 pizzas since we loved it so much. People must have thought we were starving we were eating so fast! Luckily I remembered to grab a photo.
… moreWayne Moran
Always great pizza, service, and value at one of the best locally-owned places in Effingham. The lunch special (well done) is fantastic.
… more