Social Profile: 
✔️Breakfast ✔️Brunch ✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Delicious handcrafted subs, sandwiches, wraps, pizza and more. We have been awarded the Best Sandwich Shop in the Milwaukee area for 5 years in a row! We’re your local restaurant serving Nashotah and the Lake Country community the freshest ingredients – using hand carved meats, daily baked breads, local dairy and fresh vegetables. Delivery available Monday-Friday 11am-2pm. We cater for your groups from 6 – 1500 people with Sub Trays, Salad Trays, Wrap Trays, Box Lunches, homemade desserts and delis salads.
Mom-and-pop eatery serving specialty pizzas, sandwiches & salads in a homey atmosphere.
Address and Contact Information
Address: W329 N4492 Lakeland Dr, Nashotah, WI 53058
Phone: (262) 367-6288
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Picnic Basket Restaurant serving the Lake Country area
Delicious handcrafted subs, sandwiches, wraps, pizza and more. A local restaurant located in Nashotah, Wisconsin, we serve the Lake Country community …
Picnic Basket – Nashotah (@picnicbasketresturant) – Facebook
May be an image of text that says ‘THE Picnic Basket NOW RESTAURANT HIRING! … 3barn is in Nashotah, WI. Feb 10 . Right off the highway is a place where …
Picnic Basket: Online Ordering
Picnic Basket. Store Details. Picnic Basket; W329 N4492 Lakeland Dr; Nashotah, WI 53058; (262) 367-6288. Online Ordering Hours. Sunday, 8:00 AM – 7:00 PM.
Reviews
Chris Knight
This place is really busy near lunchtime. Takeout was the best option for our visit. Not much room to wait for your order thoug, but they have curbside delivery. Sandwiches and side salads were outstanding. Would definitely go back when in the area.
… morePeter Young
My first time here, I got the bada bing to go. I was ready for how big this was. I thought 8″ would be enough to hold me over. I was wrong. When I finally got home and went to unwrap it was huge, girthy, meaty, delicious, and filling. Definitely the best 8″ I’ve ever had. The giardiniera is a must on any cold sub.
… moreNicole Wittkopp
EDIT AS OF SUMMER 2025- I revise my prior review to give this place all FIVE STARS!!
The kicker: take the time to EAT IN the restaurant!! We had a delicious meal at the restaurant that totally resurrected itself from my last review. I will be back because of how delicious and fresh our meal was!! Great customer service as well!!! Our salad and sub were amazing!!
Wow, was I DISAPPOINTED.
First, we got less than $30 of food, used a coupon for $15 for $30 and still had to pay a full $15 (dispute not buying $30 of actual food- it should be half of what you buy but this isn’t my real issue).
I got the guacamole chicken bacon wrap- WHAT A SCAM. I didn’t read the fine print and realized upon my first bite, that there is NO ACTUAL GUACAMOLE ON THIS WRAP. It’s guacamole mayo- overall, it was very, very bland. Pasta was mid and chips came in a weird, greasy tied bag that made me uncomfortable.
I don’t think I’ll be back. Can’t believe how high the ratings are.
… moreThe kicker: take the time to EAT IN the restaurant!! We had a delicious meal at the restaurant that totally resurrected itself from my last review. I will be back because of how delicious and fresh our meal was!! Great customer service as well!!! Our salad and sub were amazing!!
Wow, was I DISAPPOINTED.
First, we got less than $30 of food, used a coupon for $15 for $30 and still had to pay a full $15 (dispute not buying $30 of actual food- it should be half of what you buy but this isn’t my real issue).
I got the guacamole chicken bacon wrap- WHAT A SCAM. I didn’t read the fine print and realized upon my first bite, that there is NO ACTUAL GUACAMOLE ON THIS WRAP. It’s guacamole mayo- overall, it was very, very bland. Pasta was mid and chips came in a weird, greasy tied bag that made me uncomfortable.
I don’t think I’ll be back. Can’t believe how high the ratings are.
amy jo schroeder
My husband and I ate lunch here for the first time. Excellent service! We were greeted when we entered. Our server, Tracy, was amazing!!!! Being new customers, Tracy made suggestions, took our order and checked to see if we needed anything. They were busy and other employees also checked on us. The food was very good, nice variety. Portions are large and prices are reasonable. The restaurant is very clean and all of the employees we met were happy, attentive and sociable. A lovely experience. We will be return customers.
… moreNicki Stocker
Picnic Basket continues to impress with outstanding sandwiches and salads, and very generous portions. (I have not had their pizza) Aporkalypse hands down my favorite glutinous hot sandwich. Best part is the army of employees, who constantly are upbeat, positive, kind and genuinely seem to care about you. Kudos and thank you for the excellent food and service!
… moreSkyler Donner
I love this place so much! Hands down one of the best sandwich shops you will ever go to. The subs are massive and very reasonably priced. Everything is very fresh and it shows in the quality of the food. The service is top notch, they are always walking around checking on all the tables. The food comes out hot or cold rather quickly. It’s a great atmosphere by yourself or with company. They always have some really cool specials so there is always something new to try! Word of advice, always get a rice crispy treat, you’ll thank me later.
… moreKimber Kaya
I stopped in with my sister at high noon, the place couldn’t be busier. We were seated within minutes and waited on promptly. I got a “hot” sub but my turkey was barely warm. The bread is so soft and FRESH! I had a side choice with my sandwich, my sister did not. I got pasta salad and it was EXCELLENT, I would stop for takeout on this item alone! My sister’s sandwich came with a half a handful of potato chips. I feel like for the price of these subs a side should be offered for all, my sister added on a pasta salad. The sodas come in plastic bottles with a cup of ice if you choose to use it. Our waitress Laura was very friendly and attentive. There is street parking if you’re lucky enough to get it and ample parking around the corner. The street is very busy so be careful, this is right off the highway.
… moreJill Bacon
Amazing creative, delicious sandwich. Everything was fresh. Was greated with a sample platter of the available sides as a first timer. Friendly and welcoming.
… moreElise O’Hare
Great place to eat!!! We stopped here after a trip to Holy Hill to see the fall leaves from the tower. The subs we had were great! They offer gluten free bread for all the sandwiches!! We also HAD to have a huge Rice Krispie treat and that was super yummy! They offer deli sides such as pasta salad, coleslaw and kettle chips. I would recommend stopping and trying it out. They also offer curbside pick up if you order online! I can’t forget to mention the service was amazing too! Everyone there was super nice!
… moreCharles Paul
Great carry-out. Nice online and phone ordering. Nice loyalty Basket Bucks if you don’t mind the paper approach. Too small seating seat count to be sure a visit won’t result in disappointment if wanting to eat indoors. A local favorite.
… more