Social Profile: 
✔️Brunch ✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out
… View more
Address and Contact Information
Address: 1 Rittenhouse Ave, Bayfield, WI 54814
Phone: (715) 779-3330
Website: https://www.bayfieldpierplaza.com/
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Pier Plaza | Bayfield, WI: Hotel, Bar, Restaurant
The locals know it famously as The Pickled Herring. This location has been a local hangout since 1937. Come gab some stories and take in a cold beer or one of …
Pier Plaza Restaurant & Lodging | Bayfield WI – Facebook
Pier Plaza Restaurant & Lodging, Bayfield. 2671 likes · 69 talking about this · 6261 were here. A family-owned and operated restaurant for four…
The Pickled Herring: A Culinary Gem in Bayfield – Evendo
Nestled along the scenic shores of Lake Superior, The Pickled Herring offers a delightful grill experience in Bayfield, Wisconsin.
Reviews
Jen K
This is a fantastic spot for dinner and drinks. If you have a herring lover in your midst, this is a must: theirs is locally caught and made in house. The smoked trout dip was also out of this world, and the salmon salad with green goddess dressing was 12/10 stars. Plus great cocktails, and they have the local Apfelhaus cider (sadly not on tap but still good). Nice to find a good Hugo spritz in northern WI of all places!
… moreJoe Murphy
I had the chilli and a bowl of wild rice soup and both were outstanding.
Seven people ate and all seven had different things and everyone LOVED it.
Toni was our server and she is so good that even the if the food was trash (absolutely delicious) we would still come back again. She is friendly, and knowledgeable.
We ate outside and what a perfect atmosphere and view.
Six starts for service and food.
… moreSeven people ate and all seven had different things and everyone LOVED it.
Toni was our server and she is so good that even the if the food was trash (absolutely delicious) we would still come back again. She is friendly, and knowledgeable.
We ate outside and what a perfect atmosphere and view.
Six starts for service and food.
Deanna Lopez
We decided to visit this restaurant based on the reviews. It’s also across the street from the Apostle Island Cruise we took. I ordered the whitefish and fries because I heard that whitefish is good. It was delicious…so flakey and tender. I also tried cheese curds for the first time. They were good even though I’m not really into fried cheese. I highly recommend and will definitely return.
… moreJ Lynn
We stopped here for dinner on a chilly winter night. Super welcoming staff and excellent service. We had a great chat with the bartender! He makes a really great espresso martini. We ordered sprouts, steak salad, and shrimp tacos. The food was a little over sauced for our preference (heavy balsamic glaze on the sprouts, heavy coleslaw dressing) but otherwise was great! And of course, the view can’t be beat. Really tasty meal, we’d definitely go back next time we visit Bayfield!
… moreJason The Doodler
I enjoyed my food here. The whitefish was delicious. My wife had the chicken Alfredo and really loved it. Our wait staff was awesome as well. Great view of the lake from our outdoor seats. Will be going there again!
… moreAmanda Turcotte
Visited the Pickled Herring for a late lunch/early dinner before an Apostle Islands cruise, since it was right across the street from the docks and rated pretty well. It’s definitely a fun place to relax and have a drink or a full meal. I ordered the Hugo Spritz and it was exactly what I was looking for in a cocktail….light and crisp. I ordered the fish sandwich so I could try the local Lake Superior white fish. Blackened was a good choice for how it was cooked. Flaky and juicy…delicious. ibopted for the sweet potato wedges as a side, and wow, were they good and a generous serving. I think I ate the equivalent of two medium sweet potatoes in one sitting…lol. everything tasted great and the staff were very friendly. The dinner seating overlooks Lake Superior, always a plus, and their bar area looks like a fun vibe, too. I would come back. Thanks!
… moreKaylynn Morrow
My boyfriend and I came to The Pickled Herring for the first time after coming to Bayfield for the third time in the winter. Every cocktail was AMAZING! We had to take a picture of the menu so we could attempt to re create them at home. We had the Steak Naan for an appetizer and that could have been an entree . It was so delicious. Jody is a great bartender, he knows everything about the bar, restaurant and the city. We will be back every visit! Thank you for the wonderful experience, Jody!
… moreMichael Calhoun
We loved it. A throwback. I had the surf and turf it was delicious. Love the white fish and the steak was cooked perfectly medium rare. The split pea and ham soup alone was worth the trip. Waiting in the bar was also a great time, the place is warm and welcoming!
… moreEmily Richmond
We had a nice dinner at The Pickled Herring. Service was good, and even though we had to wait a short time for a table, it worked out perfectly—we grabbed drinks at the bar and stood at a little standing bar that kept us out of the way. My husband and I shared the fish fry, which was more than enough for the two of us, and we also split the onion rings with homemade blue cheese dressing (so good—definitely the highlight!). The fish fry itself was decent, though nothing to write home about, and the drinks were on the pricey side. Overall, a solid spot with great onion rings and friendly service!
… moreSteven Butler
Dined here twice, first dinner outside. Good food, good service at a relaxed pace with a nice view of the harbor. Bottom bun if the burger was very soggy. Second lunch inside, food was excellent, but very slow, probably 30+ minutes after we ordered, for poutine and a sandwich. We sat next to the door and there were quite a few flies, much louder than outside, also took quite a while to find our waiter for our check after we finished. Over probably 4.5 dinner outside, 3 lunch inside.
… more