Social Profile: 
✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out
… View more
Address and Contact Information
Address: 775 Montauk Ave, Fishers Island, NY 06390
Phone: (631) 788-7246
Website: http://www.thepequot.com/
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
The Pequot | Fishers Island NY – Facebook
. $$$. . Closed now. . 775 Montauk Ave, Fishers Island, NY, United States, 06390. Links. . thepequot.com. Contact info. . (631) 788-7246. . info@thepequot …
The Pequot! (@the_pequot_inn) • Instagram photos and videos
Merry Christmas Fishers Island family & friends, tell the people that you love them. Photo by The Pequot! on December 03, 2025. That’s right you heard it …
The Pequot – 246 Montauk Ave, Fishers Island, NY, 06390 – MapQuest
Get more information for The Pequot in Fishers Island, NY. See reviews, map, get the address, and find directions.
Reviews
Steven Ballot
Drinks and pizza and Caesar fries and cod bites and cheesy bread. What a great experience.
We had a pepperoni pizza that had great flavor and I asked for a side of jalapeños, which I added to my slices. Absolutely delicious. The Caesar fries were quite unique. I’ve never had them before but it was love at first bite. That shows creativity can be delicious ! If you’re ever on One by Nine, this is a must stop.
One by Nine ~ if you know, you know.
… moreWe had a pepperoni pizza that had great flavor and I asked for a side of jalapeños, which I added to my slices. Absolutely delicious. The Caesar fries were quite unique. I’ve never had them before but it was love at first bite. That shows creativity can be delicious ! If you’re ever on One by Nine, this is a must stop.
One by Nine ~ if you know, you know.
David Hughes
Excellent little bar and grill slash Dance Floor tucked away in the heart of Fishers Island. They know how to make a drink. I had shrimp cocktail while waiting on the ferry. Has the friendliest staff I’ve ever encountered. New goto when on the island my only complaint is I didn’t get enough time here, but I will be back. Like and follow for more hidden travel well ⛳️
… moreRaymond Lewicki
Food is so-so but good place to meet up large parties. Monitor your credit card on-lint to insure you are not being charged for more than what you ordered. They take your credit card up front most likely they were burned in the past.
… moreTaha Güneş
It has a great team of employees. The food is very delicious. They party after 10pm on Friday and Saturday nights.
… moreLily Starbuck
Like coming home. I love this bar. Ian & Zoe are the best. Can’t go wrong with a smash burger & fries
… moreChandler Reedy
Very special place. Food is awesome, bar is perfect and staff is even better. Place has soul. Thanks to everybody for doing what you do. Keep it going all night long and forever.
… moreAndrew Gasworth
Pizza is good. Portions of the protein in the chicken sandwich and fish tacos were VERY small. Our table of 5, left and had to find more food to make up for the small portions. 2 of us had the blackened chicken sandwich. Basically like eating a bread (basic hamburger roll) sandwich; so very little chicken. 3 of us had the fish tacos, 2 tacos served on each plate, but very little “fish”. One person commented that she found 2 small pieces of fish between the two tacos. $128 for the meal that included 4 drinks. Service was OK, not good, certainly not great. If you go, stick with the pizza!
… moreJaime
Food was ok, although the menu was limited. It’s kinda dark and bar like, which is not my scene but everyone seemed to enjoy themselves. Despite it being the only restaurant on the island, the prices aren’t too bad.
… moresara weber
Typical bar food. Burgers, fried things..tried to be fun and get the gazpacho..but it seemed more like cold Campbell’s tomato soup. Not bad for the only bar on the island
… moreJim McGovern
food was good. very small, unique place. they were out of several menu choices. mostly local people.
… more