Social Profile: 
✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
The Other Guy Pizza
… community. Pick-up Location · 15910 SR 37, · Sunbury, OH. Follow us: Facebook. 2024 TheOtherGuyPizza.com 15910 east state route 37, Sunbury, OH (740) 913-0694.
The Other Guy Pizza | Sunbury OH – Facebook
The Other Guy Pizza, Sunbury. 881 likes · 101 were here. we are OPEN!! We have pizza, wings, subs and more! We also have beer!
The Other Guy Pizza – Destination Delaware County Ohio
The Other Guy Pizza. Add to My Trip … Ideal for those seeking a casual yet delicious dining experience. 15910 east state route 37. Sunbury, OH 43074.
Reviews
Andrea Betts
Just tried this for the first time ever tonight and told my family I’m going once a week!
Absolutely amazing! One of the best pizzas
… moreAbsolutely amazing! One of the best pizzas
Tyler Coldwell
Probably the worst pizza within 30 minutes of Sunbury. The guy who took my order was short and not very welcoming. The pizza was undercooked and tasted like what I got in my gradeschool cafeteria. I got there a few minutes prior to when they said it would be ready just to make sure it was hot out of the oven, which did work out.
… moreBrandon
Some of the best pizza an stromboli I’ve had keep up the great work if u want good food this is the place to be
… moreJoseph Y
Is it good? Let me put it this way: I drive past four other pizza shops to eat here. Rocco uses quality ingredients, the dough is made fresh, and his cannoli are excellent.
… moreAlex Flint
Great pizza. Was looking for NY/NJ style pizza for a while around here and finally found it. Perfect sauce, crust is great. Chicken wings weren’t great (too much fat compared to meat), but this is strictly my taste. so place, owner, service, food is straight up 5 stars! Be back definitely.
… moreSara Smith
We’ve ordered carry out several times, always thought it was solid. The Dine in experience was even better. Excellent pizza, subs and service.
… moreChris
Might be the best pizza I’ve had in decades in the metro area. Off the beaten path, reasonable prices, and Rocco the owner was interesting as well as an excellent host. If you like hitting the small independents, good food, nice people, orders are correct, and the way places used to be – definitely a must do. Heard rumors on the cannoli which sell out fast on Fridays only – we are definitely coming back to test those 5 star reports!
… moreRachel
We ate here for the first time and it was so delicious and the owner and his staff were very courteous and went above and beyond. We will definitely be back.
… moreAndrew Melnyk
First time ever ordering from here…. The cannolis were great. I will be ordering these again.
… moremark matheis
The Other Guy Pizza is close to our place in Sunbury and this is the first time having it. Ordered the meat lovers pizza and it was done and ready on time (about 25 minutes) . The toppings and sauce had an excellent taste and the amount of toppings was just right. The crust was also very good and I’d rank that part higher but we tend to like Neapolitan style crust that places like Paulie Gees and Sextons have but for a non-Neapolitan style, this crust was very good and I felt it was a better crust than a number of places that have a “Columbus style” pizza crust. Excellent pizza and not quite 5 stars for us only because our personal preference in crust. Don’t take that to mean , we didn’t like the crust , just like a Neapolitan style crust a bit better. Appreciate having a privately owned pizza place like this so close to home…We will definitely be back!
… more