Social Profile: 
✔️Brunch ✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Italian eatery serving a menu that has included classic pizza, subs & pastas for 40+ years.
Address and Contact Information
Address: 4057 Asbury Ave, Tinton Falls, NJ 07753
Phone: (732) 922-6760
Website: https://www.theoriginalattiliospizza.com/?utm_source=gbp
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
The Original Attilio’s Pizza – Tinton Falls, NJ – 4057 Asbury Ave …
Order Hours About. 11:00 AM-9:30 PM; Shop address is 4057 Asbury Ave, Tinton Falls, NJ 077534057 Asbury Ave, Tinton Falls, NJ 07753; (732) 858-0517.
Attilio’s Pizza
4057 Asbury Avenue, Tinton Falls, NJ 07753. 732-922-6760. Attilio’s Pizza. Copyright © 2024 Attilio’s Pizza – All Rights Reserved.
The Original Attilio’s Pizza – 4057 Asbury Ave, Tinton Falls, NJ 07753
Order online at one of the best restaurants in Tinton Falls, NJ! The Original Attilio’s Pizza is a neighborhood favorite. Quick delivery and exclusive …
Reviews
DaveT
I have only ever had one thing here, Pizza. I personally think their pizza is the best in the area. I used to really Like Luigi’s, but when they got new ownership, the quality fell through the floor. Before a few years ago, I thought Attilio’s was just average pizza, but hen they seemed to change the recipe and it became my favorite. The crust has a great chew and the cheese along with their sauce is rich and well balanced. They always cook it just right, they ae very consistent.
… moreMisty Jade
I came here with my fiancee a couple weeks ago on a mini vacation to NJ and this was one of my favorite places I had while I was here. The food is SO amazing. I’ll say the pizza was a bit greasy but honestly it was so good that it didn’t bother me much. It felt and tasted more real than most pizza I’ve had. We also had garlic knots and a sub and it was all so good I cannot wait to visit again so I can have this food. It’s my favorite pizza place now so far I haven’t had anything comparable yet. Customer service was great and the restaurant was very clean and ordering and getting our food there was no hassle at all. Really pleased with my experience here and I can’t wait to come back. I would definitely recommend this place. Please keep doing what you’re doing and serving delicious food!!
… moreChuck Mound
Was passing through Asbury Park and came across this hidden gem. Would have been 5 stars if the customer service was at least good. Not sure why in the Pizza Industry as a whole, it’s so hard to engage with your customers, makes for such a better experience..Especially here because they have a really good slice of pizza. You take a bite and the sweet sauce just explodes in your mouth. So good. It all works perfect with the cheese and crust. Very good slice of Pizza. I am sure they will receive a high grade on the Pizza Hunters App. I would go back just for the Slice. Great Job.
… moreCasey James Scheiner
Stopped by Attilio’s for a quick bite this weekend.
Food:
I had a plain slice, which was fine but didn’t really have much personality or standout flavor. It’s serviceable pizza, but nothing that sets it apart.
Service:
The guy working behind the counter was nice, but the girl at the register had a bad attitude and really dragged down the overall experience. Service definitely left room for improvement.
Aesthetic:
There’s a lot of seating available, making it convenient for larger groups or casual dine-in. Otherwise, the setup is standard for a local pizza spot.
… moreFood:
I had a plain slice, which was fine but didn’t really have much personality or standout flavor. It’s serviceable pizza, but nothing that sets it apart.
Service:
The guy working behind the counter was nice, but the girl at the register had a bad attitude and really dragged down the overall experience. Service definitely left room for improvement.
Aesthetic:
There’s a lot of seating available, making it convenient for larger groups or casual dine-in. Otherwise, the setup is standard for a local pizza spot.
Kim Carlisle
I got it via delivery so don’t know about atmosphere. But the food was delicious and one of the most reasonably priced around!
… moreSašo Luznar
We have been here a few times and we have ordered home once. So far everything has been great.
The food tastes great, everything from pizza to pasta so far we liked. The delivery was fast and all the food was still hot when we ordered home.
The staff was very friendly at the restaurant even when they were busy, and our waitresses have all been great. The restaurant is clean and has a friendly atmosphere.
The strip mall has plenty of parking and has a brewery next door and a great bakery, a few establisments down. We definitely recommen it and we will be bask again.
… moreThe food tastes great, everything from pizza to pasta so far we liked. The delivery was fast and all the food was still hot when we ordered home.
The staff was very friendly at the restaurant even when they were busy, and our waitresses have all been great. The restaurant is clean and has a friendly atmosphere.
The strip mall has plenty of parking and has a brewery next door and a great bakery, a few establisments down. We definitely recommen it and we will be bask again.
jack bradshaw
The pizza is awesome but the customer service lacks. They never have slices after 830 pm ad they are open till ten. Guys behind counter on phones ignore you when entering. And when it’s busy you can cut the stress with a knife. Chaos at dinner time
… moreAims M
I was absolutely mortified after they gave me a grand total of $65 for 2 large pies and a large California cheese steak. This is the most expensive pizzeria I’ve ever ordered from. I paid the order because I needed to feed my employees but I will not be a returning customer.
Oh excuse me….according to the owner, I forgot to mention the ONE requested topping…. pepperoni.
… moreOh excuse me….according to the owner, I forgot to mention the ONE requested topping…. pepperoni.
Yvette Deas
I wish 0 stars was an option. I went here late evening to order food for a family member who wasn’t feed while waiting in the ER all day. So I decided to grab baked ziti for her. Soon as she opened it, I just knew it wouldn’t be good. She told me it taste just the way it looked, disgusting! It was not baked! They threw sauce in pasta with some cheese and barely even mixed it. You should be ashamed of yourself for putting food out like that!
… moreIsabella Rene
They are so friendly here. There was a young gentleman that was at the register who was so kind, welcoming and polite. I only purchased 2 Stewart’s soda, but the interaction with him was unbelievable. You don’t get this kind of service anymore. Thank you for being kind.
… more