Miah Labrador
We went to The Nesst for Valentine’s Day and had the absolute BEST experience. Bradley was our waiter and he was incredible. Bradley is so well spoken, warm, kind, and genuinely friendly. He elevated the entire night. You can tell when someone truly cares about the experience they’re giving, and he absolutely does.
We loved it so much that we came back just a few days later to repeat the exact same meal, and it was just as flawless the second time.
The filets? Unreal. The softest, most tender and perfectly cooked steaks I’ve maybe ever had… and we LOVE steakhouses. I would genuinely put this experience above $500 meals we’ve had elsewhere. That says everything.
The brussel sprouts could convert even the harshest veggie critic — crispy, flavorful, sweet yet savory, and incredibly addictive. We also fell in love with the cottage potatoes. They taste like something straight out of a Michelin-star kitchen. The fresh bread is served piping hot and is completely divine. And don’t even get me started on the desserts! Every single one was phenomenal, and we’ve tried several already lol.
They’ve absolutely made repeat customers out of us. The Nesst is a gem, and Bradley made it unforgettable. Can’t wait to go back again (and again, and again).
Bradley told us they have a special on Monday nights.. delicious burgers and crazily crispy flash fries chips. Needless to say, I’ll be bringing my kids again this week for that specifically.
I also noted they had a little sign saying they have live music Tuesdays.. which is definitely on my “must do” list now.
Even when the music isn’t live though, they’ve had such a phenomenal playlist going and I found myself singing along to the best 80s songs while enjoying my perfect meal.
… moreGreg Morris
Do you want excellent food, knowledgeable and friendly service and a great atmosphere to enjoy it all? The Nesst is your place. And you support local ownership as a bonus! Our team member who helped us was Bradley and he could not have been more hospitable and accommodating. The owner stopped by our table and was very generous with his time with us. Highly recommend the Nesst!!
… morePaul Dwigans
We were taken aback by the incredible professionalism of the waiters and staff. The food was superb, especially the New York Strip and the weiner schnitzel. We plan to start a new tradtion of regular visits to our new favorite steakhouse.
… moreAllison Robbins
It was our first time dining at Nesst in noblesville and we had the best dining experience, Bradley was our server and he was delightful. The lemon drop martini was perfect. Cesar salad with home made dressing was so good. Chicken parmigiana was so tender you could cut it with a fork, salmon with soy drizzle was perfectly prepared..Get the mashed potatoes (I know what you’re thinking) they are better than your grandma’s. For dessert try the apple cobbler and baklava was the best we’ve had. Everything about this dining experience was 5 ⭐️ atmosphere is cozy and comfortable.
… moreNina Fox
We always have an amazing dinner anytime we come to the Nesst! They have top notch service, delicious food with lots of options (highly recommend the Cevapi for an entree, and the charcuterie and crab cakes as appertizers), and overall a great ambiance. The staff is excellent. Gabbie greeted us with a friendly face and welcoming presence. Our waitress, Cori, went above and beyond to ensure a great service. And Juan was so kind, attentive, and helpful! The Nesst is an excellent spot for great food with awesome staff and operated by an exceptional owner!
… moreKevin B
We needed a recommendation for a dinner spot and someone said “you’ll have a great experience at the nest” so we decided to give it a go. They were right!!! We were immediately greeted by Gabby. She is awesome! The waiter (Bradley) was prompt and took our order accurately. Food came out in a timely manner but not to rush us. The food was great! From apps to dessert not one mistake. The dessert was a perfect portion as to not make you feel guilty about it. We walked out very comfortably and having felt the money spent was WELL WORTH IT!! 100% recommend this place!! We will back. I heard they have a smash burger special on Tuesday! Might have to give that a try since I will be in town for business. Oh and the owner swung by and greeted us too. VERY VERY nice gentleman!
… moreLesa Turner
This was our first visit, and they opened an hour earlier to accommodate Valentine’s day. In selecting a restaurant, I saw the business had 4.9 reviews, but they deserve 5 stars. Food was exquisite! I had 6oz butterflied filet mignon, loaded large baked potato and asparagus with hollandaise sauce. My husband had the ribeye and loaded potato. Superb, compliments to the chef. Waitress was prompt to meet every need. Fair pricing for the quality. Best kept secret in Indiana. Atmosphere was romantic. I had no idea they were voted the most romantic award in indiana a few years ago. We will return to dine for a sequel. I wholeheartedly recommend this restaurant. You won’t be disappointed!
… moreAmela Vejzovic
Amazingly tasteful food (if you’re Balkan, everything is so nostalgic in a sweet way), beautiful and peaceful atmosphere, perfect volume, and incredible service! Our server Everette D. was so kind, attentive, great with conversation, had a gentle tone, and really made us feel taken care of. We appreciated his kindness! Will be back again and again! Highly recommend to anyone in the Indianapolis- Hamilton county area! Try some of the “out of town” menu items- the cevapi is my personal favorite. From the other part of the menu, my husband loves the steak frites, veal and lamb shank! Well seasoned, cooked perfectly and tasted amazing!
… moreDeSean Redwine
I came to the Nesst of Noblesville to celebrate a special evening with my girlfriend. I initially was looking for a restaurant that had a good ambiance and amazing food!
The Nesst definitely checked off all those boxes!
With it being our 1st time trying out this restaurant our AMAZING serving Bradley explained everything to us very thoroughly, explained the history of the restaurant, and all the specials/menu options.
Nonetheless. The food was amazing and so was our wonderful server Bradley!!! 5/5 would definitely recommend to anybody!!!
… moreChristopher Lee
Put this on your list to try. It’s a solid choice.
We had a party of 4. First, the cocktail I got was really good. It was a bourbon smash but I think they called it The Nesst. My wife ordered a whisky sour. The don’t have egg whites for it, but a substitute, which is more than most places. However, they forget to add it to her drink.
The calamari was good. Pretty standard for calamari but no complaints.
The fried green tomatoes were really good. They would be better if sliced a little thinner but that’s too subjective.
I wanted the lamb shank but it was unavailable. I got the veal shank instead. It was pretty good. Nothing mind blowing but it was flavored nicely and cooked well.
My wife had the wienerschnitzel. It was really good except I would have preferred it without the mushroom sauce. It just wasn’t for me. It was more like of a jagerschnitzel than a wienerschnitzel.
The atmosphere felt like upscale casual. I’d like to come back and try more dishes.
… more