Pastas, pizzas, stromboli & a children’s menu dished up in an easygoing restaurant.
Nicole Smallwood-Otero
It was a good dinner overall but there were some issues. Firstly, our server was lovely but kept forgetting things. She seemed new so we were ok with that but it took a long while to get our beers, as she had to have the bartender walk them to us. The place was packed but I did not mind the noise. Most of the food was great. The calamari was surprisingly large rinds of salt and pepper goodness. The mozzarella sticks were huge! We ended up with one deluxe calzone, one pepperoni stromboli, one Mamma Mia pizza, and one Cajun cod on fettuccine. Everything was excellent except the cod. It was overly fishy-smelling and flaky but so dry. I couldn’t even eat half of it. The sweety pepper drops served with it were amazing and the sauce and fettuccine were so delicious!! I will go back but never for fish. We have the fried cheesecake with strawberry toppings for dessert. It was…odd? The cheesecake has a semi-melty texture that was goopy if that makes sense, just odd. Overall, excellent except for the fish!
… moreMichelle S
I have stage 4 cancer, so I could not be present for dinner. However, this is the absolute worst.Italian food i’ve ever had in my entire life! My husband brought me takeout. The salad was a bowl of spinach. No dressing, no croutons, no parmesan cheese, just spinach. The bread had no oil, no seasoning, just a loaf of bread that was soggy. I got the combination with lasagna, chicken parmesan and fettuccine alfredo… I splurged, thank god, a meatball with meat sauce that cost me two bucks. I can’t even tell you how horrible this was. It had a tablespoon, maybe, and that’s being generous of meat sauce.
And half of a meatball! The Lasagna had 0 cheese. It was plain noodles with a teaspoon of ricotta inside plain noodles. I have never seen a Lasagna made like this 0. Cheese on top, however, the pictures look amazing.At least what they put online. The chicken parmesan was a very small, frozen piece of chicken with again. No cheese whatsoever.
Just a simple piece of frozen chicken, not even any sauce! The fettuccine alfredo was a tiny amount again, extremely dry, barely any sauce! I cannot believe this was twenty six bucks for this tiny amount of food and it had absolutely no flavor whatsoever! Again the online pictures look absolutely delicious But I find it very hard to believe that I actually even made this food pictures or not always wet you see!! I will never go here again ! My husband it stated that it was absolutely generic and not authentic as they advertise.At all! Take yourself down to carabas, or somewhere else.Save your money!
… moreErin Stevens
We had a Retirement Party last night at the Italian Oven with 20+ people.
The manager, Ryan and our waiter, Jason were both exceptional! They were so accommodating, friendly, helpful and fun.
We were extremely happy with the excellent service and the food was absolutely delicious.
Thank you!
… moreJoy Smith
Stopped in after church on a busy Sun afternoon but only had to wait maybe 15 min for a table. Our server was Giovanna and she was absolutely the best- sweet, cheerful, professional, attentive and a very hard worker! We were visiting from out of town and my father who was with us is local. He said he is absolutely coming back even if he has to take an Uber!
He had the calzone, I had the portobello ravioli with a meatball and my husband had the lasagna. The bread was hot and fresh and so yummy! All the dishes were outstanding and the portions are generous and reasonably priced. Next time we are in town we will be coming back!
… moreKathy Randolph
Was in town for a birthday dinner and was pleasantly surprised by this restaurant, as a first timer. Everyone enjoyed their food. The server, Moxy, did a great job w our large party and it was a busy evening for them. Would definitely return. I tried the Jambalaya pasta w Cajun cream sauce and had leftovers which disappeared from the fridge the next day. That means my sister LOVED my selection, as much as i did.
… moreLului Miam
I had an amazing experience! Everything I ordered tasted fresh, hot, and full of flavor. It was clear that everything was made from pure, high-quality ingredients with real Italian seasonings, nothing tasted pre-made or processed.
The spinach and artichoke dip was creamy and delicious, especially with their fresh, warm bread right out of the oven. My eggplant parmesan was perfectly cooked. For dessert, the tiramisu was light, smooth, and absolutely divine.
The restaurant was spotless, the atmosphere was cozy, and my waiter was excellent (sorry but I forgot his name) but he was friendly, attentive, and made sure everything was just right.
Everything about my visit felt genuine and freshly prepared. I’ll definitely be back and highly recommend this place to anyone who loves authentic, flavorful Italian food!
… moreKara Ashley Lopez
Manager was super nice when i had placed my order at the wrong location. They took care of the problem and made sure that i had lunch.
… moreChris McCalla
Service was pleasant and friendly without being overbearing. Food was disappointing. My marinara had a tangy, yet spicy flavor– enjoyed it. Meatball was pretty good. The noodles for both of our dishes were overcooked. Her fettuccine sauce looked unappetizing with it’s dull sheen. Tasted like everything was microwaved…
… moreCassie Dee
I enjoyed a great lunch, during a work day, at The Italian Oven. The restaurant was clean and neat, and nicely decorated. The service was quick and friendly. The food was fresh and delicious. The bread with oil served right when sat was so good! I even enjoyed a little art time with the crayons and paper at the table. I certainly recommend this place!
… moreSam B. Hearn
LOVE, LOVE, LOVE Italian Oven in Peachtree City! The best, homemade local Italian food in PTC. The staff is very hardworking, friendly, and attentive too. This isn’t a chain Italian restaurant, all their dishes are uniquely crafted for the utmost deliciousness. The Fettuccine Alfredo soup is to die for too, highly recommended!
… more