Social Profile: 
… View more
A local favorite for casual dining, The Horse & Plow in Kohler, WI, serves up classic pub fare, craft beers, and game-day specials in a lively, historic tavern setting. Perfect for Sheboygan locals, Milwaukee visitors, and sports fans looking for a fun atmosphere.
Dark-wood & brass-accented lounge with casual pub fare, American microbrews & premium drinks.
Hours
| Tuesday | 11 AM–11 PM |
| Wednesday | 11 AM–11 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–11 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–12 AM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–12 AM |
| Sunday | 11 AM–11 PM |
| Monday | 11 AM–11 PM |
Address and Contact Information
Address: 419 Highland Dr, Kohler, WI 53044
Phone: (920) 451-2178
Website: https://www.kohlerwisconsin.com/dining/dining-locations-list-page/the-horse-and-plow
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Reservations: destinationkohler.com
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Classic Pub Fare at The Horse & Plow | Kohler, Wisconsin
Enjoy classic pub fare, craft beer, and a lively atmosphere at The Horse & Plow, a historic gastropub in Kohler, Wisconsin. A favorite casual dining spot …
The Horse & Plow | Kohler WI – Facebook
The Horse & Plow is temporarily closed due to staffing, and we are also conducting deep cleaning as a safety precaution for our guests, staff, and community. We …
The Horse & Plow Restaurant | Travel Wisconsin
The Horse & Plow Restaurant. Address. 419 Highland Dr – Kohler, WI 53044. Phone … At The Horse & Plow, they believe in enjoying the best of both worlds.
Reviews
Ýsel Nicholson
My boyfriend and I had dinner here during our 3-night stay at a nearby Airbnb, and wow – this place is fantastic! The food absolutely blew us away. We shared everything (which made it feel like a feast), and still had some leftovers – totally worth it.
Here’s what we ordered:
Half order of cheese curds
Chicken tenders with fries
H&P steak hoagie with truffle fries
Wagyu bolognese
Every single dish was a 10/10 – seriously. Perfectly cooked, great portions, and full of flavor. If you’re in the area or looking to visit, this spot is a must-try!
… moreHere’s what we ordered:
Half order of cheese curds
Chicken tenders with fries
H&P steak hoagie with truffle fries
Wagyu bolognese
Every single dish was a 10/10 – seriously. Perfectly cooked, great portions, and full of flavor. If you’re in the area or looking to visit, this spot is a must-try!
Adrienne Hartman
Fantastic atmosphere, great service and diverse menu! As a vegan, I’m happy when I have a few options on a menu. The beet hummus and power bowl were delicious! There were several vegetarian items as well. My omni family loved the club sandwich and maverick burger.
… moreScott W
Spent the weekend at the American Club and loved the ability to eat at several different restaurants within the same resort. Each one is distinct, with its own menu and atmosphere. The Horse and Plow is a great spot if you have a group or family where noise is not a bug but a feature. We came here on our second evening around 7:00 for dinner.
Food:
The menu has a good selection of beverages and pub-style food. There is an extensive list of whiskeys, including bourbon and rye, lots of beers, and some specialty cocktails. We settled on a draft beer and the Plum Crazy cocktail, which was super yummy.
For food, they offer appetizers, soups, salads, sandwiches, and a fish fry. There is even a Wagyu flat iron steak if you are interested in paying $75. We decided on the Double Butter Smashburger with truffle fries and the Walleye Fish Fry.
The burger was good, although it could have been cooked a bit more to create more caramelized edges. The bun was good, but a bit too much bread for me, so I ate it open-faced. The truffle fries were delicious and could have been a meal in themselves.
The walleye was battered and breaded with good texture, and the fish was flaky. I felt it was a bit overcooked, and the last several bites were very tough.
Service:
We did not have a reservation, and there were no tables available when we arrived. We took a spot at the bar, where the bartender got us an order of drinks. The service, both at the bar and at the table, was efficient but not especially friendly or outgoing. The food came out nice and hot, waters were kept full, and the check arrived promptly after the meal was finished.
For those looking for a pub experience, this is a good spot. However, being at the American Club, I think I was looking for more of an elevated experience.
Atmosphere:
It is a pub, and that is exactly what you get. It was very noisy at times, especially as larger groups were enjoying themselves.This felt more like a place for a quick meal than somewhere I would feel compelled to return to.
… moreFood:
The menu has a good selection of beverages and pub-style food. There is an extensive list of whiskeys, including bourbon and rye, lots of beers, and some specialty cocktails. We settled on a draft beer and the Plum Crazy cocktail, which was super yummy.
For food, they offer appetizers, soups, salads, sandwiches, and a fish fry. There is even a Wagyu flat iron steak if you are interested in paying $75. We decided on the Double Butter Smashburger with truffle fries and the Walleye Fish Fry.
The burger was good, although it could have been cooked a bit more to create more caramelized edges. The bun was good, but a bit too much bread for me, so I ate it open-faced. The truffle fries were delicious and could have been a meal in themselves.
The walleye was battered and breaded with good texture, and the fish was flaky. I felt it was a bit overcooked, and the last several bites were very tough.
Service:
We did not have a reservation, and there were no tables available when we arrived. We took a spot at the bar, where the bartender got us an order of drinks. The service, both at the bar and at the table, was efficient but not especially friendly or outgoing. The food came out nice and hot, waters were kept full, and the check arrived promptly after the meal was finished.
For those looking for a pub experience, this is a good spot. However, being at the American Club, I think I was looking for more of an elevated experience.
Atmosphere:
It is a pub, and that is exactly what you get. It was very noisy at times, especially as larger groups were enjoying themselves.This felt more like a place for a quick meal than somewhere I would feel compelled to return to.
Ankit Mahajan
We came here today for the first time. Server Larissa and the supervisor Holden were very friendly and helpful. Even though one dish was brought my mistake, they took care of that. Food was yum, service was awesome. Highly recommended fot vegetarians. One of the few places in Kohler with a good number of veg options. We tried veg soup, mushroom tacos and cauliflower appetiser weren’t disappointed at all.
… moreAmanda
I come here about once a month to meet up with an old friend from college, have been for about 8 months now. The food is consistently good, the atmosphere is phenomenal, the staff are all incredibly sweet, and they never say anything about us staying for 3-4 hours. The menu gets a few new dishes changed out maybe every month or every other month, and a few new cocktails get cycled in every season (I think.) We love this place and look forward to coming back every month.
… moreMichael
Wonderful restaurant! Great dining options. Really eclectic menu of beer and drink options. It was a busy holiday evening and we were seated without delay. Great service! And the steak hoagie was excellent! All of our dinner choices were so good! Five stars!
… morePatrick F
The last few trips here have been less than impressive. This latest time this is what we got for a kids cheeseburger. A paper thin, dry, way overcooked smash burger. This is a joke for a restaurant like like this. Need a entire bottle of ketchup to eat this thing. McDonald’s seriously has better burgers for less money. The burger is literally crunchy.
… moreMarissa Guse
They had board games and tabletop shuffleboard, so it can have a bar feel or a fancy dinner.
… moreansumania
Deep fried cheese curds and the spotted cow draft beer (only sold in Wisconsin) are must haves! Since this establishment is part of the American Club on the Kohler Resort, all the plumbing fixtures are uniquely Kohler.
… moreAdam Aguliar
We visited Horse & Plow recently and were seated right away, which was great. Unfortunately, the service was very slow from the start. We waited quite a while before being greeted, even though staff walked by our table several times.
Once our server, Heather came over, drinks took longer than expected and there seemed to be some lack of knowledge of the drink menu. I asked questions on IPA’s and didn’t get any answers, I ended up Googling my questions before she came back.
When ordering food, the interaction felt rushed. I wasn’t asked how I wanted my burger cooked or what side I wanted, so the overall experience felt a bit impersonal. The food itself was good, but the service really impacted our visit.
On a positive note, the manager who cleared our plates was very kind and checked in with us, and the atmosphere was nice. The live singer was also enjoyable, her country covers were great. Overall, the food was good, but the service left us disappointed.
… moreOnce our server, Heather came over, drinks took longer than expected and there seemed to be some lack of knowledge of the drink menu. I asked questions on IPA’s and didn’t get any answers, I ended up Googling my questions before she came back.
When ordering food, the interaction felt rushed. I wasn’t asked how I wanted my burger cooked or what side I wanted, so the overall experience felt a bit impersonal. The food itself was good, but the service really impacted our visit.
On a positive note, the manager who cleared our plates was very kind and checked in with us, and the atmosphere was nice. The live singer was also enjoyable, her country covers were great. Overall, the food was good, but the service left us disappointed.