Social Profile: 
✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out
… View more
Address and Contact Information
Address: 318 New York Ave, Rochester, PA 15074
Phone: (724) 300-2226
Website: http://www.hilltop15074.com/
Menu Photos
Related Web Results
Hilltop 15074: Home
top of page. Home · Location & Hours · Menu · Gluten Free Menu · Apply Online. hilltop.png. Instagram; Facebook. bottom of page.
Hilltop 15074 – Facebook
Hilltop 15074. 5763 likes · 64 talking about this. A Rochester Landmark back on the Map! #15074 724-300-2226 www.hilltop15074.com.
Menu – The Hilltop Restaurant
Starters, Chicken Wings (6) 9.00 (10) 15.00, Party Sizes Available, See Our Catering Menu, House dry Rubbed and House Smoked.
Reviews
Amy Robinson
Heard so much about this restaurant from people who are originally from here and couldn’t wait to try it. We came in hungry and we left impressed. The steak salad lived up to all the expectations that I had. The steak was tender, juicy cooked exactly how I like it. I like the chunks of cheese and the ranch dressing was delicious. Our server was so friendly and our drinks were never empty. We’ll definitely be back.
… moreSusan Coe
Being a Rochester native, I was very excited to try Hilltop. I have such fond memories of eating the delicious steak salads. and socializing with friends.
This visit did not disappoint !!!! The steak salad was absolutely delicious….. just as I remembered ♥️♥️♥️ The service was excellent.
The bar area is beautifully appointed and welcoming. I am not sure what is going on with the decor on the restaurant side. Two large frames with what appears to be concrete. I think that this would be a great space to pay homage to Rochester and put black and white historical memorabilia / news clippings and photos in the space to honor the wonderful community of Rochester.
So I have returned at least 1/2 dozen times since my review. Food still does not disappoint however the dining room remains unfinished and leaves a lot to be desired. Myself along with the 6 people in my party will only sit on the bar side as it is very welcoming. I am attaching a photo of an idea for the wall.
… moreThis visit did not disappoint !!!! The steak salad was absolutely delicious….. just as I remembered ♥️♥️♥️ The service was excellent.
The bar area is beautifully appointed and welcoming. I am not sure what is going on with the decor on the restaurant side. Two large frames with what appears to be concrete. I think that this would be a great space to pay homage to Rochester and put black and white historical memorabilia / news clippings and photos in the space to honor the wonderful community of Rochester.
So I have returned at least 1/2 dozen times since my review. Food still does not disappoint however the dining room remains unfinished and leaves a lot to be desired. Myself along with the 6 people in my party will only sit on the bar side as it is very welcoming. I am attaching a photo of an idea for the wall.
WE THE PEOPLE 1776
Cozy place. Food was great. Good menu. The grilled cheese bites and cheeseburger soup was great! Salad was really good too.
… moreKaylin M.
Was very excited to hear this gem was opening again!
Just had lunch and our server Saharra was wonderful!
The calamari was delicious, but it wasn’t served with a lemon. So we used a drink lemon.
The steak salad was good but oddly…. you dont get tomato, onion or cucumber unless you get the “deluxe” which seems silly because those are very basic vegetables…. it was also a $2 upcharge. The shaved ribeye was okay.
They also dont have their liquor license yet, but she did tell us it was approved and they may be selling alcohol in a week or 2.
… moreJust had lunch and our server Saharra was wonderful!
The calamari was delicious, but it wasn’t served with a lemon. So we used a drink lemon.
The steak salad was good but oddly…. you dont get tomato, onion or cucumber unless you get the “deluxe” which seems silly because those are very basic vegetables…. it was also a $2 upcharge. The shaved ribeye was okay.
They also dont have their liquor license yet, but she did tell us it was approved and they may be selling alcohol in a week or 2.
Jeannette Hergenroeder
So happy to see an investment in my home town. Went there for lunch with my sister and niece. Got the wing dings and seriously sparked a core memory of going there with my mom. Beyond the memories, the food was amazing, my family loved theirs as much as I did mine. Customer services was outstanding in a world where customer service is slowly dying. I can’t wait to go back with my husband.
… moreKathie Ross
We sat at the bar. Very very nice! Our bartender was Ty ♥️ she was so nice and very attentive she also made the best espresso martini. We also ate dinner , the house chips with hilltop sauce were delicious. The French dip sandwich was great. And their salads are very fresh! Everything was awesome. This was our first visit since new owners and we will definitely be back!
… moreSonya Domaracki
This was our first visit to this restaurant, and unfortunately it will also be our last. The food was disappointing. The French fries tasted and looked like they came straight from a freezer bag, and the egg on my sandwich was overcooked on the edges but still raw in the middle. The mayo at each table was also expired (October 2025).
While the atmosphere was clean and the servers were friendly, the quality of the food simply doesn’t justify the price. Overall, it wasn’t worth the visit.
… moreWhile the atmosphere was clean and the servers were friendly, the quality of the food simply doesn’t justify the price. Overall, it wasn’t worth the visit.
Melissa McCoy
I got a salad with no salad dressing. The only thing that was on my salad was meat, cheese and lettuce terrible and I want a steak and chicken salad and they gave me one steak salad ones chicken salad however no dressing for neither. They only have meat and cheese and lettuce and I have to pay $36. I would never do it again.
… moreJason Frederick
Should have taken a picture of the aweful brown grease soaked piece of fish that i cant believe they even brought out looking like that. Didnt even take a bite it looked so bad. I didnt even want anything else after that. One would have thought that at least a manager would have came out to apologize. Service was good though, but nothing like the old Hilltop. Gonna send Gordon Ramsey this direction, he would have freaked out. First and last time im coming here
… moreJohn Bernauer
Great to see they reopened. 1st time visiting, wife and I both thought our food was excellent. We will definitely go back!
… more