Social Profile: 
✔️Breakfast ✔️Lunch ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out
… View more
Hours
| Saturday | 10 AM–3 PM |
| Sunday | Closed |
| Monday | Closed |
| Tuesday | 10 AM–3 PM |
| Wednesday | 10 AM–3 PM |
| Thursday | 10 AM–3 PM |
| Friday | 10 AM–3 PM |
Address and Contact Information
Address: 428 Grotto St, Eureka, CA 95501
Phone: (707) 273-5012
Website: https://orders.cake.net/11593800
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Related Web Results
The Grotto Eureka | Eureka CA – Facebook
… % recommend (11 Reviews). . $$. . Closed now. . 428 Grotto Street, Eureka, CA, United States, 95501. Services. . Specialties. Dine-in · Outdoor seating …
The Grotto Eureka 428 Grotto Street – Order pickup and delivery
The Grotto Eureka. 428 Grotto St, Eureka, CA 95501, USAOnline ordering hours: 10:00 am–1:00 pm.
Order The Grotto Eureka – Eureka, CA Menu Delivery [Menu & Prices]
Get delivery or takeout from The Grotto Eureka at 428 Grotto Street in Eureka. Order online and track your order live. No delivery fee on your first order!
Reviews
Alecksee Warwick
Had one of the best sandwiches I have eaten in a very long time! Got the Joe’s spice girl and it was a very well put together sandwich. So delicious! The owner was so sweet and really took care of us. Shs has nothing but positive energy and it shows in her costumer service and sandwich skills. We had a lemonade and it was very good(not overly sweet). Looking forward to more good eats and the Grotto!
… moreEthan Caldwell
Stopped in recently and was seriously impressed by the quality of the sandwiches. Everything tasted fresh and perfectly balanced, and you can tell a lot of care goes into the preparation. I tried one of their signature sandwiches along with a lemonade, and both were excellent without being overly heavy or sweet.
What really made the visit stand out was the welcoming atmosphere. The owner was incredibly friendly and created a positive vibe that made us feel right at home. Great food, great service, and a spot I am definitely excited to return to.
… moreWhat really made the visit stand out was the welcoming atmosphere. The owner was incredibly friendly and created a positive vibe that made us feel right at home. Great food, great service, and a spot I am definitely excited to return to.
Korey Barboza
I will start off this review with the fact that I am very particular and critical of food. These are 100% the best sandwhiches in eureka. It’s both bittersweet that their hours are limited because if they were open longer I’d probably go broke! Excellent service, food and very reasonable prices. Seriously can’t recommend this place enough! Awesome vibes and the bacon is cooked to perfection. I am also in LOVE with the egg salad. Definitely the best I’ve had.
… moreRiana Christensen
People are so kind. Food is phenomenal. I had a Reuben breakfast sandwich on a biscuit. The biscuit was so soft and scrumptious, eggs light fluffy and tasty, pastrami super flavorful and spiced just right. House made lemonades, sauces and treats. Just eat there. You wont regret it.
… moreTiger Spots
Sandwiches are FANTASTIC. Don’t let this hole-in-the-wall deceive you, every sandwich item is w o r t h it. The owners and chef are so warm, welcoming and accommodating. Not only do they allow customizations but know how to make the customizations great. Also, they immediately offered to put extra horseradish on my reuben sandwich without me asking, which is a pro move. Bring your hungry self here and you will leave full of belly and heart. Can’t recommend the Grotto enough!
… moreKelly Hemani
Making more than sandwiches here!!! First, the lunch we had was amazing. The Italian, pesto turkey sandwich, and soup was delicious. The bread is on point. Next, the service was welcoming and informative with local areas to checkout for our visit. Last, you make dreams come true. Where you told us to visit turned into an adventure of a lifetime for us. Thank you for more than just lunch!
… moreSara Egloff
Such a fun atmosphere! The service was wonderful and the workers just fun people. Tiny little shop with only a couple places to sit but we got it to go. It’s pricy, but the sandwich I had was SO good. I got Christine’s Turkey Pesto
… moreStan Spas
I had Joe’s Spice Girl and really enjoyed it. I am a big fan of spicy and the spice level was perfect for me. My wife likes less spice, so picked off the jalapeños and then it was perfect for her as well.
… moreAlohas 71Camaro
Very nice ladies that run the place, I’m from Washington State and we stopped by a couple times for sandwiches and they were delicious
We will return when we’re in Eureka next time. Highly recommend
… moreWe will return when we’re in Eureka next time. Highly recommend
Siare Keating
The Grotto in Eureka is one of the most impressive dining experiences on the North Coast and a place I always look forward to visiting. Tucked away in Old Town, it has that cozy and inviting atmosphere that makes it feel like a special find. The lighting is warm, the bar is polished, and the whole space feels both intimate and elevated at the same time. It is the kind of restaurant that works perfectly whether you are celebrating something, out for a date, or just want to enjoy a great meal in a welcoming environment.
The food at The Grotto is absolutely top tier. The menu has a balance of creativity and comfort, and every dish is crafted with real attention to detail. The seafood is especially outstanding, which feels right being so close to Humboldt Bay. Oysters are fresh and clean, scallops are seared perfectly, and every cut of meat I have had here has been tender and full of flavor. Even the appetizers and small plates feel carefully designed and satisfying. The portions are generous and the presentation makes each dish feel like it was made with pride.
The drinks are another highlight. The cocktails are strong, balanced, and always well thought out. Whether I order a classic or something more inventive, it is always crafted to perfection. It is easy to sit at the bar or stay at your table for hours just enjoying the drinks while savoring the food.
The service is consistently excellent. The staff know the menu inside and out, they are attentive without being overbearing, and they always make the experience feel smooth and enjoyable. It adds a personal touch that makes dining here even better.
The Grotto captures what I think a great restaurant should be. It combines atmosphere, flavor, hospitality, and quality into one unforgettable experience. It is the kind of place that feels true to Eureka, local and authentic, while also standing out as a destination all on its own. Every time I leave I feel like I have had not just a good meal but a full experience. The Grotto is easily one of the best spots in the city and a must visit for anyone who wants to enjoy what Eureka has to offer.
… moreThe food at The Grotto is absolutely top tier. The menu has a balance of creativity and comfort, and every dish is crafted with real attention to detail. The seafood is especially outstanding, which feels right being so close to Humboldt Bay. Oysters are fresh and clean, scallops are seared perfectly, and every cut of meat I have had here has been tender and full of flavor. Even the appetizers and small plates feel carefully designed and satisfying. The portions are generous and the presentation makes each dish feel like it was made with pride.
The drinks are another highlight. The cocktails are strong, balanced, and always well thought out. Whether I order a classic or something more inventive, it is always crafted to perfection. It is easy to sit at the bar or stay at your table for hours just enjoying the drinks while savoring the food.
The service is consistently excellent. The staff know the menu inside and out, they are attentive without being overbearing, and they always make the experience feel smooth and enjoyable. It adds a personal touch that makes dining here even better.
The Grotto captures what I think a great restaurant should be. It combines atmosphere, flavor, hospitality, and quality into one unforgettable experience. It is the kind of place that feels true to Eureka, local and authentic, while also standing out as a destination all on its own. Every time I leave I feel like I have had not just a good meal but a full experience. The Grotto is easily one of the best spots in the city and a must visit for anyone who wants to enjoy what Eureka has to offer.