Social Profile: 
✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out
… View more
Traditional American comfort dishes & cocktails served in a comfortable space with old-world charm.
Address and Contact Information
Address: 200 N 2nd St, Watertown, WI 53094
Phone: (920) 261-6262
Website: http://eliasinn.com/
Menu Photos
Related Web Results
Elias Inn to be reborn as “The Goose & Gander” | Local News
For Watertown residents who have been used to the building’s history as a supper club, the Friday and Saturday nights will be familiar. But the …
Is The Elias Inn Supper Club still open?? – Facebook
Is The Elias Inn Supper Club still open?? Watertown, WI Community Network. Lisa Topel Sep 15, 2025 . . Is The Elias Inn Supper Club still open …
Restaurant Review: Elias Inn is BACK! | Visit Watertown, Wisconsin
Guest blogger, Jody Purtell takes us through a memorable evening at the iconic Elias Inn Supper Club. Elias Inn has been an establishment in Watertown Elias …
Reviews
Jamie Adcock RUNNING DIVA MOM
Cute lazy susan relish tray and cozy atmosphere that immediately took us back in time. Cheese curds and prime rib were okay. Stuffed shrimp and risotto were delicious. Also appreciated that they had NA ice cream drink options.
… moreKevin Golliher
Very nice German themed Super Club in Watertown. The building is classic Supper Club with lots of old wood and a nice bar.
I had an old fashioned, it was muddled and fresh, but seemed to be lacking something.
The service was great, helpful and knowledgeable without being overbearing.
This place still has a free Relish Tray, which was refreshing, with a nice selection of veggies and cheeses. Definitely a plus.
I had the Veal Schnitzel, which came with soup or salad, I got both. The salad was fresh and tasty. The soup (beef stew) was good, could have been warmer. My friend got the French Onion and said it was thick and great. The Schnitzel was cooked perfectly and I would get it every time I go here. Menu didn’t mention it comes with Sptätzle, so was happy to see that included and was also very good.
Definitely a recommended stop if looking for a place to eat in Watertown.
… moreI had an old fashioned, it was muddled and fresh, but seemed to be lacking something.
The service was great, helpful and knowledgeable without being overbearing.
This place still has a free Relish Tray, which was refreshing, with a nice selection of veggies and cheeses. Definitely a plus.
I had the Veal Schnitzel, which came with soup or salad, I got both. The salad was fresh and tasty. The soup (beef stew) was good, could have been warmer. My friend got the French Onion and said it was thick and great. The Schnitzel was cooked perfectly and I would get it every time I go here. Menu didn’t mention it comes with Sptätzle, so was happy to see that included and was also very good.
Definitely a recommended stop if looking for a place to eat in Watertown.
Eric Wild
I recently visited the Elias Inn Supper Club for a Friday Fish Fry and was pleasantly surprised to learn the Fish Fry includes Fried Chicken, Fried Cod and Baked Cod served family style with the sides featured on a Lazy Susan. All the food dishes served were very good along with the service. The restaurant does get quite busy on Friday so be prepared for a wait. The Elias Inn Supper Club does unfortunately fall short on the value scale as the only Fish Fry option available is all you can eat. 4.0 (5.0 if you typically order all you can eat).
… moreTravelsalot1988
First time here. Just happened to find the place by driving by a few days prior to our visit. I called at 4pm and was able to get a 6:30pm reservation for 2 on a Sat night. The relish tray was ok. We ordered the baked French onion soup which must have been served right from Mercury, because it took a while to cool to a temperature that was feasible to put in our mouth. After that, we left it. There was hardly any onions, no taste/ flavor and topped with the wrong cheese. I had told the waitress we were French onion soup connoisseurs and she didn’t even question when she cleared away our half eaten bowls! I don’t recommend. We also had the king cut and queen cut prime rib. The king appeared to be same size as queen. Good flavor. Only creamy horseradish, not pure served. Was halfway done when waitress finally checked on us. Each had a couple beers, no dessert. Total bill was $111.
… morePatrick T
Wonderful evening last night at The Elias Inn Supper Club in Watertown, courtesy of our cheerful, delightfully kind and attentive server Whitney H. The Elias Inn is the undisputed king of the relish tray – brought to the table on its own lazy Susan. Good thing we had an empty seat at our table. I had the Queen cut prime rib and the ladies had the ribeye steak sandwich special – both entrees superb, seasoned and cooked to perfection. I also can’t remember a time I wanted to rave about mashed potatoes (well… not true – it was the last time my mom made them for me) but still, they were positively delicious and I would actually recommend them. Brandy Old Fashioned Sweets were also top notch. We capped off the night with a Brandy Alexander for us and a Grasshopper for our guest of honor. If you’re anywhere near Watertown, treat yourself to a fantastic meal. And ask for Whitney. She’ll carry it over the goal line for you.
… moreBryDeV
Stopped on a Friday, while in Watertown, limited Friday lunch menu was smaller but had some decent non fish fry options (I was gonna have one with my wife later). I had the Chopped Steak Sandwich. It was chopped prime rib with horseradish cream, sauteed mushrooms, onions and peppers on a toasted French bread served au jus and topped with a pile of fried onion strings. It was an awesome sandwich. Very cool smaller supper club.
… moreDaniel
Excellent service! Casual laid back vibe. Loved the traditions of a supper club service. The bread was warm and served with the garnishes on a lazy susan, the soup and salad were just ok. The scallops with risotto were very nice and prepared well. Enjoyed the stuffed shrimp and rice. Wrapped up the meal with crème brûlée. Overall a nice meal.
… moreRachel
The Elias Inn servers the BEST fish fry!!! They don’t take reservations on Friday nights. The wait is usually an hour or more. I promise, it is worth the wait!!
… moreRochelle Didier
Best. Breakfast. Ever. Came here for Sunday Brunch and had The Family Style Breakfast which came with fruit, pastries, bacon, pancakes, hashbrowns, and eggs. The hashbrowns and bacon were some of the best I’ve ever had.
… moreTed Pittman
Elias Inn Watertown, WI – this was a fun first visit. Ron Faiola’s “Wisconsin Supper Clubs” brought us in. We started at the bar, enjoying a couple Wisconsin classics – Brandy Old Fashioneds while learning a little history of the place from the bartender. The evenings host prepared our table and escorted us into the eclectic dining room where our server, was great – she signed our book and informed us she’d been serving at Elias Inn over 20 years and loved it – and it showed, she took great care of us. “She” had the scallops and I had the Rib – our entrees and sides were all delicious – this was a really fun visit. We’re looking forward to visiting Elias Inn again when we get that direction. Stop in and have cocktail, stay for dinner – I know you’ll be glad you took time to experience Elias Inn in Watertown, WI
… more