Nicole R. C.
AMAZING ice cream! Exceptional service. Friendly, accommodating and had great suggestions. The ice cream is second to none. Perfect consistency, creamy, velvety smooth. I tried seven different flavors and each one was better than the next. Can’t wait to try more.
… moreBill D’Onofrio
This new ice cream shop is an absolute gem! The ice cream is hands-down some of the best I’ve ever had — rich, creamy, and full of flavor. The owner is incredibly talented and truly a master at creating unique, fun, and delicious flavors that keep you coming back to try more. The old-fashioned atmosphere makes the whole experience even sweeter — it’s warm, welcoming, and feels like stepping into a simpler time. You can feel the love and creativity in every detail. A must-visit!
– Donna and Bill D’Onofrio
… moreR Benanti
Kirsten, the owner, is amazing!!!!! Not only is she the sweetest, kindest person, but she is also a kick-a$$ cake decorator. I followed her all the way from West Caldwell. She did such a great job with my daughter’s 21st birthday cake!! And the ice cream is creamy and delicious! You must go!
… moreSteve Martini
Bright, clean & cheerful environment. Warm & friendly staff. The ice cream is excellent with a good selection variety. They even have the rare bubble gum flavor which is absolutely excellent.
… moreMelissa Carter
Really great tasting ice cream with some unique flavors and some classic favorites too. I liked that they didn’t just have the same old stuff. Shop is cute and the young women at the counter were very friendly and helpful. Will definitely be back.
… moreMariaCristina Garcia
Staff was very inviting, centered on customer satisfaction. I had a custom sundae “MC” made with homemade icecream consisting of Caramel Pretzel Chocolate and Mississippi Mud with Caramel and crushed Heath Bar topping it off with whipped cream and a cherry on top. Fantastic flavor combination and a great treat for a busy week! Thank you for a lovely experience
… moreMichelle Olson
I was home in New Jersey for Thanksgiving and stumbled on this hidden gem!! This sweet little parlor is tucked in a cool little courtyard with a train store and a basketball court. It has an inviting porch and the inside is bright and welcoming. The ice cream was so good, and generous portions. I was so excited to find that they dip soft serve into bonnets (like magic shell without the chemical taste), which is a favorite of mine. I can see this being a great summer destination for a dog walk or time with my teenager. A perfect addition to Mountain Lakes!
… moreMarc
Absolutely, the Best Ice Cream! Incredible selection, creamy and absolutely delicious. Gourmet Ice Cream, incredibly crafted, flavorful, an absolute must have anytime of the year. Go treat yourself and the whole family to something wonderfully delicious.
… moreelizabeth blanco
Love the warm environment. The range of flavors, makes it hard to choose. Their pints of ice cream maintain its creaminess.
… moreJonathan Hemenway
Just started coming to this place and it has not disappointed so far! The ice cream is soo good and we recommend the Nutella Crunch.
… more