The Cookie Lady’s Cafe

  4.6 – 358 reviews  $ • American restaurant

Social Profile:

Burgers, sandwiches & all-day breakfast are offered at this informal venue with a convivial vibe.

Service Options:  Dine-in · Takeout

Health and Safety:  Staff required to disinfect surfaces between visits · 



Address and Contact Information

Address: 2501 NJ-88, Point Pleasant, NJ 08742

Phone: (732) 714-9494



Menu Link:

Menu not currently available

Photo Gallery

Related Web Results

Cookie Lady Cafe – Home | Facebook

Inside dining, takeout, and Grubhub / DoorDash delivery 2501 Route 88, Point Pleasant Beach, NJ 08742.

Cookie Lady Cafe Delivery Menu | 2501 NJ-88 Point Pleasant

Order delivery or pickup from Cookie Lady Cafe in Point Pleasant! View Cookie Lady Cafe’s May 2022 deals and menus. Support your local restaurants with …

The Cookie Lady’s Cafe – 2501 Rt 88, Point Pleasant Beach, NJ

The Cookie Lady’s Cafe · 2501 Rt 88. Point Pleasant Beach, NJ 08742. Directions · (732) 714-9494. Call Now · Order Takeout or Delivery. Start Order · Full menu.

Reviews & Complaints

Kyra Sica
A breakfast/brunch staple at the shore! The food is always wonderful and the owners are so friendly and welcoming. Staff and servers are always excellent and make you feel right at home too! I love the specials but there is something for everyone on the menu. Definitely a place to check out for excellent food and a friendly atmosphere! (Banana split french toast pictured)
… more
Lynn Postlethwaite
Just had a delicious breakfast at the cookie lady. Steak was seasoned and cooked perfectly. I subbed potatoes for fruit today but the potatoes are amazing as well. We come here often and the food NEVER disappoints!!
… more
Tara Vitale
TLDR: go here, double thumbs up, 5 starsMy mom and I tried it for the first time this morning and WOW it was delicious! I got the Apple strudel French toast and she got the avocado toast. The French toast was just sweet enough to satisfy my sweet tooth but not too sweet where it could have given me a headache. We’ll definitely be back! She said this may be her new favorite go to breakfast place (and she LOVES breakfast)
… more
Jeffrey Elrose
Amazing spot! Care and passion is evident. Service was great everyone is so friendly and cares so much. Find it almost impossible to find good hollandaise sauce that isn’t broken which is always a bit disappointing. Theres is perfect. The effort and attention to detail is obvious and appreciated!
… more
Rita Joaquim
Best service, great food and friendly outgoing staff. Owners are hands on and very accommodating. Don’t pass this one up you will be missing out!
… more
Cristian Randeau
With new owners I thought it may be time to update my review. This morning my husband and I snuck away to our favorite little eatery. We were sad to hear that Christine had sold the business but our fears were eased when we met the new owners. They were personable and seemed to want to leave well enough alone. The food was as I have always loved it. The waitress was sweet and attentive. I will definitely be going back again. Pictured: special: Muellers cinnamon raised French toast with fresh fruit and granola. Yum!!
… more
Alyssa Kelley
Came for the first time today and it was awesome! I got the chicken salad sandwich on toasted Rye with a chocolate shake, my boyfriend got the open face scrambled with Turkey bacon. Small, cozy place with attentive and smiling servers. We’ll definitely be back!
… more
Rosemary Marinho
Enjoyed the best breakfast ever here last year in 2020 with a close friend of mine. The new owners had just taken over the business recently and were very personable and accommodating. There was a pretty atmosphere outside in the back with beautiful flower pots and plants. Visited again in Sept 2021 and had the same experience and they even remembered us.The food was delicious and didn’t even have to call the server for more coffee she was very attentive. A definite spot to visit when in Point Pleasant. ☕️
… more
Fallon Goodman
A local gem with the warmth and homeyness that its name conveys. Walk into The Cookie Lady and you’ll be greeted by owners Maria and Gerard. After taking the helm last year, this husband–wife team have kept menu favorites that launched The Cookie Lady into a Point Pleasant staple (such as their Biscuits & Gravy), while also adding unique alternatives for adventurous eaters (such as Crab Cake Benedict). They even added a “Bob’s Burger” after a regular named Bob! My recs: for those with a sweet tooth, go with Challah French toast or Full Stack of pancakes (I usually add fresh fruit). For a savory option, I love the Continental Scrambler for breakfast or Patty Melt for lunch. On your way out, grab an oversized crumb cake. Between the reliably good food and kind staff, you can’t go wrong at The Cookie Lady.
… more
Bill Hopkins
First time visiting the Cookie Lady and Wow was it worth it. The Cookie Lady is very friendly, her staff was outstanding and the food was awesome. I will be going back next time I’m in town. I look forward to the next Point Pleasant visit!
… more
… Load more reviews

Leave a Comment

Please rate