Kevin “MonkeyAnvil” Huffaker
A proper cultural gem, steeped in Northern Irish charm. A perfect place to sit and meet new folks. And yes you can actually talk and hear others easily.
I settled in as the lovely Audrey brought the perfect Guinness. I had a massive Reuben with a side of non-spicy chili crowned with green onion and sour cream. Met a couple and we shared an amazing buttery hot pretzel with dipping cheese. It was like desert, and a great finish to the Guinness.
If you’re looking for polished well-loved surroundings, you’ve found your haven.
… moreJoshua McKellar
Place is wildly mediocre. Reuben didn’t have much meat and the bread was overcooked (think about how the top of your mouth will feel after eating it). Mac and cheese had a weird grittiness to it. Drinks weren’t good or balanced. Service was great though and they’re friendly.
… moreboo
Ordered the smoked bratwurst flatbread as well as the peach cider. They compliment each other right well. My partner ordered The new Pilgrim and that came with his choice of side as well. He ordered the winter ale to try with it. There were conversations, starter game/card stuff nearby and we end up having a joyous time deeply developing our connection. Environment was well organized to have a decent environment.
… moreAmanda Webber
Very chill environment. Happy Hour from 4-6. $1 of apps and wells. As it gets busier, service gets behind (to be expected). I’ve been here several times. 95% of the time, we have excellent service. That 5% (not today) happened during summer on the back patio, so I don’t know if you that still applies. Usually people are sitting in the darts-zone, so I’ve not been able to play. But, it’s real darts, not the creepy rubber ones.
… moreBastian C
Absolutely amazing experience! After all 13 of us ordered, ate, and drank, Audrey split the check perfectly based on who was with who — without us even asking. Different splits, all done flawlessly. We were so amazed by her attention to detail and incredible service!
The food was outstanding — highly recommend the Bavarian pretzel with mustard, shepherd’s pie, chicken pot pie, and the corned beef sliders. Every dish was hearty, flavorful, and perfectly cooked. The drink selection was just as impressive, with tons of beers on draft and a great variety of specialty cocktails.
It was packed when we arrived on a Saturday night (totally expected without a reservation), but that only added to the fun, lively Irish pub vibe. The energy, service, and food were all top-notch. Love, love, love this place — can’t wait to come back!
… moreJeff McBride
We are here all the time. Its a great, cozy pub. Tends to get crowded around dinner time, so go early, go late, or be prepared to find all the seats filled. Go for a drink, or for dinner.
Why great?
– Amazing selection of rotating kegs.
– They have mostly the same bartenders they had when we started coming years ago, and they are all amazing.
– I usually get a beer, but they’ve made me some great cocktails too.
– The crowd in this place is usually friendly and fun.
– Food ranges from decent to great. Love the shepards pie. Flat breads are nice.
-Cozy, friendly atmosphere. Been around for ages.
Whats wrong with Churchkey?
– just one thing really: they took the best food off the menu. The bahn mi tacos were amazing. WHY?!
… moreElaine Anderson
First time in tonight, and so glad we decided to try it! Comfy atmosphere (though definitely a pub feel at 9pm), cozy warm despite sitting by the window and door, server was lovely and accommodating, cocktails were perfection (and the menu is great with lots of old fashioned cocktails you don’t see on menus often as well as more “signature” drinks and some standards), and the food was great! Started with cocktails and the pretzel with cheese, which was fluffy and not too greasy or salty. Then had a house salad which comes with sunflower seeds (love that!) and the chicken pot pie, which was heavenly, probably the best I have ever had. Partner had the Reuben with a cup of tomato soup and he thought that was delicious as well. Overall great experience and we will definitely be back again! Thanks for having us!
… moreLex Starwalker
I’ve been here so many times, I can’t believe I’m only now leaving a review. This place has really good comfort food. Also a great beer selection. They’re often busy, and there are good reasons why. Service is top notch and super friendly. If Edmonds has a Cheers!, this is it. I highly recommend the mac and cheese with bacon and green onions, but all the food is excellent. You really can’t go wrong.
… moreCrystal Clemens
All I can say is OMG. Little Irish pub off the beaten path. Delicious food and great staff. Good is fresh and flavorful. Shepherd’s pie was amazing, not dry, lots of flavor and made very well. House chili had a little kick but also delicious. Banana bread pudding and cinnamon brown sugar ice cream….yes please. TO DIE FOR. Drinks here are amazing. Great selection. Staff wad welcoming, friendly and ready to help you pick Drinks and food if you’re having a hard time deciding. Place is clean, open seating and steadily was busy. Will definitely come back here.
… moreHolly
This place has a charming Irish pub vibe. It’s quaint and small, with great food and service. I came in hungry and left full. We started with the artichoke dip. It was a little different than your average artichoke dish. I couldn’t pinpoint what was so different maybe the onions but still a good start of the meal. A couple of us ordered the bangers and mash, while my friend got the Smoked Bratwurst Flatbread. The flatbread was a decent size, and I even had leftovers from the bangers and mash because you get two sausages—plenty of food for one. I was delighted!
We also had the brownie with ice cream, which just melted in your mouth—a perfect treat after a hearty meal. The drinks were your standard beers and ciders, no complaints there.
… more