Social Profile: 
✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
The business was formerly known as Baby Tommy’s Taste of New York… The Best Pizza Marietta is the #1 spot in town for an authentic New York experience. The staff at the Best Pizza Marietta is devoted to serving customers mouthwatering dishes that feature the highest quality ingredients available.
New York-style & stuffed pizzas, plus pasta & subs, in a simple space designed with takeout in mind.
Address and Contact Information
Address: 497 Cobb Pkwy SE, Marietta, GA 30060
Phone: (770) 794-0045
Website: https://bestpizzamarietta.com/
Menu Photos
Related Web Results
Best pizza place? : r/Marietta – Reddit
I would say MTH is the best pizza in the area. It’s in Cobb County, but Vinings/Smyrna rather than Marietta/Kennesaw. It’s fantastic and pricey, …
Best Pizza Places in Marietta 2026 – Slice
Top Pizza Restaurants in Marietta, GA in 2026 Near You · Italy’s Pizzeria logo. Italy’s Pizzeria · Marietta Fusion Pizza (Halal) logo. Marietta Fusion Pizza ( …
PEACE LOVE AND PIZZA – PIZZA IN MARIETTA, GA MILTON, GA …
GROOVY, FUN, FAMILY PIZZERIA. TRY OUR JAM UP SPECIALTY PIZZAS, CALZONES, BUFFALOVE WINGS, PEACEFUL SALADS AND MORE. DINE IN, PICK UP AND DELIVERY.
Reviews
David Bernardino (Bernit)
UPDATED: Delicious! As someone from Buffalo, NY where there’s a mom and pop pizza shop on every corner, this took me bake home. Love this place! 2 slices of pep, a drink and a blue cheese for the crust. As it should be! UPDATE: They’ve remodeled the whole place! Had to do a double take. Looks great!
… moreDavid
Overpriced for what you’re getting. The food isn’t bad, but it’s not worth the cost. I also had problems with my order: they forgot several things that they had to be reminded of and one of my slices was completely cold in the middle.
As for the taste, it’s decent but nothing special. The dough is vaguely sweet, which is weird. I don’t know if that’s a regional thing or not. The slices were ok (when they were actually heated), stromboli was greasy and not great but was edible, white pizza was ok, salad tasted fine but tiny and hugely overpriced, and the cannoli was good.
… moreAs for the taste, it’s decent but nothing special. The dough is vaguely sweet, which is weird. I don’t know if that’s a regional thing or not. The slices were ok (when they were actually heated), stromboli was greasy and not great but was edible, white pizza was ok, salad tasted fine but tiny and hugely overpriced, and the cannoli was good.
Tricia Clements
Pizza was OK, not the best. The crust was good, but I was hoping for a bit more taste. Service was not the best, but they have outdoor seating, which I always look for. May try again if I’m in the area, but won’t make specific plans to. Not outstanding pizza or service.
… moreMandy S
Updated Review July 2023:
I came back here a few times after learning this place changed names (from Baby Tommy’s) and absorbed Legion Pizza in Kennesaw (where I frequented).
I will be coming here a lot less than Legion, mostly because it is farther away and much less convenient for me personally. There is plenty of parking, but it is right on US-41 with no light if you are coming from the North and having to turn left into it.
The menu is different than the former Baby Tommy’s (missing sundried tomatoes which was the hero of my last review) and different from Legion BUT does have the Roman crust.
Here is what I thought of the food I have tried
NY Style Pizza, Cheese and Ham: Its OK doesn’t taste like NY slices but is decent pizza
Roman Pizza: This is why you should go here, the only place in town that sells it. I would usually get pepperoni. It isn’t as good as Legion, which was a disappointment, the crust wasn’t as fluffy inside/crisp outside. The last one I had had almost no sauce and TONS of cheese which just slid right off (crust is pre-baked then recooked with toppings). Needs work but has promise.
Cheese sticks: These were good but the last time too much chees the dough didn’t cook (same day as to too cheesy pizza). This could have one a one time issue because previous versions were better.
Bruschetta: This was good, but the price for what it is is just too far off for me to re-order.
Slices:
BBQ Chicken Roman: I like the crust but the chicken here wasn’t as good as the Baby Tommys cutlets, i dont really know what changed
Sometime in 2022:
Probably a 3.5 but I rounded up since I don’t know of another slice spot in the area and that is a nice feature. Good, but not spectacular.
The service was good, I was greeted and got my order pretty quickly.
What I ordered:
BBQ Chicken Pizza (Medium $22.49)
Choose your own, Cheese + Sundried Tomatoes (Medium $19.99)
The crust was foldable while still having some strength. It had no flavor on it’s own but held up to the toppings. Neither of my pizza’s were cut all the way through, so a knife or your own cutter required (or tearing it which is not easy when doling out quickly). One of the slices had a hole in the crust, so it was just toppings on parchment.
The red sauce was good nothing overpowering. The BBQ sauce was listed on the website as “tangy”, it wasn’t just very sweet. This isn’t a bad thing but if you were expecting tangy you didn’t get it. I would bet $ it is Sweet Baby Rays, so if you like super sweet style its great.
Cheese amount was good, didnt taste much cheddar on the BBQ but it was fine.
A lot of sundried tomatoes! a huge plus. The star of the show was the chicken cutlets used on the BBQ chicken pizza. I think if would be just as good if not better to get a cutlet sandwich w/BBQ sauce and some peppers & onions.
… moreI came back here a few times after learning this place changed names (from Baby Tommy’s) and absorbed Legion Pizza in Kennesaw (where I frequented).
I will be coming here a lot less than Legion, mostly because it is farther away and much less convenient for me personally. There is plenty of parking, but it is right on US-41 with no light if you are coming from the North and having to turn left into it.
The menu is different than the former Baby Tommy’s (missing sundried tomatoes which was the hero of my last review) and different from Legion BUT does have the Roman crust.
Here is what I thought of the food I have tried
NY Style Pizza, Cheese and Ham: Its OK doesn’t taste like NY slices but is decent pizza
Roman Pizza: This is why you should go here, the only place in town that sells it. I would usually get pepperoni. It isn’t as good as Legion, which was a disappointment, the crust wasn’t as fluffy inside/crisp outside. The last one I had had almost no sauce and TONS of cheese which just slid right off (crust is pre-baked then recooked with toppings). Needs work but has promise.
Cheese sticks: These were good but the last time too much chees the dough didn’t cook (same day as to too cheesy pizza). This could have one a one time issue because previous versions were better.
Bruschetta: This was good, but the price for what it is is just too far off for me to re-order.
Slices:
BBQ Chicken Roman: I like the crust but the chicken here wasn’t as good as the Baby Tommys cutlets, i dont really know what changed
Sometime in 2022:
Probably a 3.5 but I rounded up since I don’t know of another slice spot in the area and that is a nice feature. Good, but not spectacular.
The service was good, I was greeted and got my order pretty quickly.
What I ordered:
BBQ Chicken Pizza (Medium $22.49)
Choose your own, Cheese + Sundried Tomatoes (Medium $19.99)
The crust was foldable while still having some strength. It had no flavor on it’s own but held up to the toppings. Neither of my pizza’s were cut all the way through, so a knife or your own cutter required (or tearing it which is not easy when doling out quickly). One of the slices had a hole in the crust, so it was just toppings on parchment.
The red sauce was good nothing overpowering. The BBQ sauce was listed on the website as “tangy”, it wasn’t just very sweet. This isn’t a bad thing but if you were expecting tangy you didn’t get it. I would bet $ it is Sweet Baby Rays, so if you like super sweet style its great.
Cheese amount was good, didnt taste much cheddar on the BBQ but it was fine.
A lot of sundried tomatoes! a huge plus. The star of the show was the chicken cutlets used on the BBQ chicken pizza. I think if would be just as good if not better to get a cutlet sandwich w/BBQ sauce and some peppers & onions.
David Kim
Don’t ever order a roll. The bottom of the bread was soaked in grease. Bread was stale. Sausage was cut so thin it barely registered any flavor on my tongue. I’m from Queens NYC and I was pissed spending $8 on my meal. I hate to hate but the roll was horrible.
… moreStephanie Albanese
Listen, it’s not bad. It’s not amazing, either. The crust/dough is a bit on the sweet side for my taste but the texture is pretty good. Nice and thin like a NY slice should be. Crust is crispy, but again, sweet. Sauce isnt sweet or overbearing, more
Tart, thank goodness. Cheese…could use a smidge more. Crust doesn’t hold up when held up, if you know what I mean gibbagoabbagool oh!
… moreTart, thank goodness. Cheese…could use a smidge more. Crust doesn’t hold up when held up, if you know what I mean gibbagoabbagool oh!
Nate Deem
I’ve been ordering from this pizza place for years since it was Baby Tommys they used to have a great pizza the works with double crust it was delicious the last experience I had was absolutely horrible they must’ve had a pizza that was pepperoni sitting in that window for at least an hour then I just decided to throw that in the oven to heat it up with some peppers uncooked sausage on the top absolutely horrible me and the family had to throw it away. Melissa was kind enough to give us our money back for the pizza however charged us for the garlic bread just disappointing across-the-board. People shouldn’t take jobs unless they want to do the job correct at least that’s the way it used to be will not be ordering again —-if you look at the photo you can see the cheese is done near burnt look at the peppers and onions they aren’t even cooked So disappointing
… moreMichael Braxton
Baby Tommy’s, now The Best Pizza Marietta, was always a great slice. Their new merger with Legion Pizzeria should prove fruitful with the new menu items. Can’t beat the Brute Meate or the Death By Pepperoni. Great flavors & decent portions.
… moreCaleb Smith
Great quality, large true NY style pizza, friendly staff and decent prices. It was also not overly greasy, which is great! I will absolutely return.
UPDATE: As of 9/26/2020 they no longer have employees wearing masks nor do they require customers who are coming in to do so. There is no socially distant requirements inside and I was personally very upset by all of this. While I get the state of Georgia isn’t doing a great job of trying to protect its citizens, I’d really hope that the restaurant would care more about their employees and their customers. As a result I wouldn’t currently recommend this place if you’re trying to stay safe as they aren’t doing the bare minimum to keep themselves or you healthy. I lowered their rating by 1 star because of this, but as/if the pandemic passes, this really shouldn’t be as large of an issue, but does certainly speak to their safety measures and precautions as a food place which doesn’t personally set well with me. As a result I’ll never return or do business with this establishment in the future.
… moreUPDATE: As of 9/26/2020 they no longer have employees wearing masks nor do they require customers who are coming in to do so. There is no socially distant requirements inside and I was personally very upset by all of this. While I get the state of Georgia isn’t doing a great job of trying to protect its citizens, I’d really hope that the restaurant would care more about their employees and their customers. As a result I wouldn’t currently recommend this place if you’re trying to stay safe as they aren’t doing the bare minimum to keep themselves or you healthy. I lowered their rating by 1 star because of this, but as/if the pandemic passes, this really shouldn’t be as large of an issue, but does certainly speak to their safety measures and precautions as a food place which doesn’t personally set well with me. As a result I’ll never return or do business with this establishment in the future.
Natt K.
Easily miss if you drive by for the first time. I came here for something easy for lunch. Got ziti with sausage; rich and flavorful in generous portion. Side salad was crisp and clean. Pricing is acceptable for year 2022. I will be here if I’m in the area.
… more