Sue Ream
So cool! True blue soul food right in the heart of small-town-Indiana New Castle. House made BBQ that can be ordered sweet or spicy to your liking, collard greens, and an amazing cheesesteak sandwich. The fries are delish- ripples and seasoned. But the real show stopper was that Bourbon Whiskey Nut Pie! Wow!
… moreAlyssa Bodenhamer
Food was AMAZING, I had some of the bbq wings and it was the best bbq sauce I have ever had. Staff was so nice, we accidentally stayed like 20 minutes past close and they were very nice about that. Abby was a great waitress. We will definitely be back soon!
… moreMark Nicholson
Service was fast, polite and attentive. The food was delicious and the owner even took time to meet me and prepare something special before I left.
I highly recommend visiting this soul food BBQ restaurant in New Castle!
… moreShane Hammond
First time here! Service and food was amazing to say the least. We got to meet the owner and he was very kind and passionate about bringing good food and service to new castle. The Philly sandwich was super good and had a great flavor. Everything here is made from scratch and you can tell! We will be back soon!
… moreWilliam Crabtree
We have eaten here a couple of times. Then picked up rib tips and chicken wings for New Year’s. They were a huge hit with our family. To us the food has been amazing and the staff is equally amazing. The owner treats you like an appreciated, long time friend. Very socialbe and enduring. I realize parking is a little inconvenient but the parking lot behind has plenty of spaces. I completely recommend That’s My Dog!
… moreDarius Burke
The owner is super nice. Love his attention to detail with the food. The food was great. The collard greens were amazing which is hard to impress me on collard greens. The service was nice prompt and kept on top of our drinks. Make sure to try this place out if you haven’t.
… moreJo
My catfish was fried perfectly, the greens were amazing Mac and cheese had a slightly Smokey flavor just absolutely delicious. The owner has the gentle and kind demeanor that just made it easy to be there and makes you appreciate his skills all the more.
… moreJenny Hutchinson
Best Mac & cheese I have ever had! Great price for the portion size! Our server was friendly and attentive. We will be back!
… moreEthan Roberts
Been here a few times and the quality of food has been incredible every visit. Fantastic BBQ and wings alongside some great sides. Really loved the Jerk Chicken wings and will be coming back for more!
… moreSara Morrell
That’s My Dogg is a new favorite for us in New Castle. The catfish and rib tips dinners were so delicious, and the prices for the food you get were great. The staff is so friendly, and it was overall a five-star experience. Will definitely be coming back!!
… more