Address and Contact Information
Address: 433 W State St, Newcomerstown, OH 43832
Phone: (740) 498-6234
Menu Photos
Related Web Results
Terry’s Pizza Shoppe | Newcomerstown OH – Facebook
Terry’s Pizza Shoppe, Newcomerstown. 1656 likes · 1720 were here. American Restaurant.
Terry’s Pizza Shoppe – Newcomerstown
Newcomerstown, OH 43832. Directions. Categories: Places to Eat. +. -. To navigate the map with touch gestures double-tap and hold your finger on the map, then …
Terry’s Pizza Shoppe – Discover Ohio’s Beloved Pizzeria
Terry’s Pizza Shoppe, located at 433 W State St in Newcomerstown, OH, is a beloved staple in the community, drawing in both locals and visitors alike with its …
Reviews
Jill Gordon
The pizza we got was not good. It tasted very bad. Never had it before and when I called to place my order the service was rude. Don’t recommend this at all.
… moreAudrey Didek
By far one of the worst pizzas I’ve ever had, was sick all night as well as my son. Customer service was terrible, Tiffany must be related to the owner in order to still have a job there. Definitely will never come back, was passing through town never had been and regret going. Im not sure who hasn’t had real pizza and enjoys this
… moreCody Allen
It was busy at the time and I’m in no rush. People were behind me and I’ve waited longer than them. Terry (the owner) starts calling out the people behind me and says their order is ready. Well mine is too I see mine right there on the counter, all ready to go too and I got cold hard cash because they don’t take credit cards only cash or check. Anyways I get completely ignored because I’m not a Newcomerstown native or a regular. It’s like I was nobody, I didn’t exist. Then finally I was next, the 2 mean older ladies told me to hold while they played around in there purse and eventually asked me what did I want? I said I have an order to pick up. I they said 12 piece chicken and I said no 16 piece. The mean old lady said NO! You said 12 piece on the phone. It wasn’t that big of a deal or a difference but I Took a moment and looked at every body and saw Terry looking at me and mumbling something. The two mean older ladies were giving me such dirty looks. After that whole long wait in line and being ignored, I told them just forget it walked out. As I was walking out the door, I flipped everybody off. That is way out of character for me but you know what? Screw them for treating me like that. I’m glad they’re going out of business next month in August.
… moresara tomlinson
Revisited today and met with great kindness.
And great food again.
Large portions for you dollar. The owner Terry himself came over and checked on us .
However deeply saddened to learn of the passing of his wife Bonnie.
Accommodating: Me and my husband had a special request of something that isn’t on the menu we wanted everything on a pizza in a bowl they gave us a very tasty meal . We will be back when we are in town next year camping for sure
… moreAnd great food again.
Large portions for you dollar. The owner Terry himself came over and checked on us .
However deeply saddened to learn of the passing of his wife Bonnie.
Accommodating: Me and my husband had a special request of something that isn’t on the menu we wanted everything on a pizza in a bowl they gave us a very tasty meal . We will be back when we are in town next year camping for sure
Capri Newman
When I was in highschool (35 years ago), every Friday night my friends and I would hang out there! The food was good back then, and it’s just as good today! Very comfy dining room area! Delivery is always timely! 5 stars across the board!
… moreRonda Hobbs
The food is absolutely delicious! Excellent,fish, chicken and subs. Pizza good too! Very caring staff who want to be sure you love your food and are enjoying yourself!!! Haven’t tried everything to give an opinion but everything I have tried has been great
… moreRebecca Wharton
Terry’s fish is amazing,,hot & cold,too bad he’s sold the shop,I just started going there:( but still great fish!
… moreJoseph
Used to have the best buffet! Great wings and pizza and for a decent price, Terry is always a pleasure to see and it’s great to see a local business survive so long with all the hardships over the years!
… moreRenee Reed
Got hungry driving home from Columbus and didn’t want typical hamburger fast food. Found this place online and ordered a medium pizza to go. Pizza was done quickly, tasted delicious, and priced less than one of those hamburger places. The service was also very friendly. We would definitely stop back again!
… morekipling liptok
Great place for a small town. Good food, the all you can eat buffet is priced right. People are really friendly and helpful. I would go again. However the place is a little out dated and really needs a good scrubbing, it’s clean but could be more so. It kinda feels like a antique store and pizza place smashed into one. But as I said before I would go again.
… more