Paul Sheffield
The guy at the counter told me I would come back and I 100% will come back. The pizza was classic Columbus tavern style. The crust was perfectly crisp with a hint of a buttery note. The sauce was delicious and the pepperoni was a great quality. And yhe pizza was cooked to perfection. Classic old school pizza joint. Definitely recommend Terita’s!
… moreTasha Williams
It’s a lovely little pizzeria small but large in heart every pizza is handmade and personalized to your liking handmade sauce to fit your perfect taste and fresh pepperonis! Lots of fresh toppings And don’t forget the amazing handmade sausage absolutely delicious!
… moreDaniel Mayfield
Pizza is my thing. I try to scout out the best spots everywhere I travel. This was honestly some of the best pizza I’ve had anywhere. Everybody’s got their style preferences when it comes to crust and sauce and all the toppings, I get that. But in my book, I can’t recall ever having had a better pizza. The cracker thin crusty was chewy on the inside slices, and perfectly crisp on the rim. The sauce had a slight kick and the perfect amount of sweet. And whatever cheese blend they’re running was way good. I always order a pepperoni pizza, but some reviews suggested trying the plain cheese. So I went half and half and almost liked the cheese more. Sad news for me, I live in Texas and won’t be having Terita’s any time again soon.
… moreEshan Bhatt
I’m sure it was a one off, but I did receive food poisoning and I think it may have been old veggies on the pizza. I have been eating applesauce for two days now because my stomach got pretty sensitive. Tasted good, didn’t leave me good
… moreDerrick Head
Pizza hit every time very professional quick atmosphere rank is 3 stars only because its a hole in the wall foreal not somewhere u chill n eat but we here for food and great service they have both of those top 10 pizzas in columbus fasure
… moreCrystal Wootboots
I’m from Akron and popped in on a Friday night. It was a little busy and the smell was so good it was almost torture to wait for my order. It was some of the best pizza I’ve had in years!
I’ll stop in again when I’m in town!
… moreRebecca Leary
My family has been getting pizza from here for over 60 years. As a third generation customer, Terita’s will always be a go-to. I put an order in for 2 large pizzas, the Special and a Pepperoni. They are 100% worth going into a not so great neighborhood for. The service is great. They were friendly and speedy. Once you go inside the shop there wasn’t much space for multiple people watching for food but they don’t make you wait long. Can’t wait for our next order!
… moreN Williams
Small little place you wouldn’t think it’s but it’s pretty frickin awesome! , where I come from this pizza “style” isn’t and option so to come to a new area and find a great pizza like this you where to go when you want good food and friendly people to greet you when you get it I like this place and I’ll definitely be coming back 🙂
… moreAlex H
Rolling through town decided to Portnoy this place. Can’t argue with the price didn’t even know how to tip the guy it’s crispy it’s awesome I’m happy. I’m still in the parking lot scarfing it down watching traffic. So good
… moreNichole Armstrong
Pizza is always hot and fresh when picking up. The homemade sausage is delicious. It has a little kick, but nothing crazy as I usually can’t handle spicy. The staff is always friendly and works quickly to get orders filled fast. It’s definitely worth the 20 min drive for me.
… more