Social Profile: 
✔️Brunch ✔️Lunch ✔️Dinner ✔️Dine in ✔️Take out ✔️Delivery
… View more
Longtime, unfussy pizzeria with counter-service, offering Italian food, sandwiches & lots of beer.
Address and Contact Information
Address: 5101 Mayfield Rd, Lyndhurst, OH 44124
Phone: (440) 449-1252
Website: http://www.compolastastypizza.com/
Menu Photos
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Menu – Compolas Tasty Pizza
Skip to Main Content. Compolas Tasty Pizza | Lyndhurst, Ohio | Pizza, Pasta, Subs |. Home · About Us · Location · Menu · Online Order · Dine In · Specials …
Compolas Tasty Pizza | Lyndhurst, Ohio | 440-1252
Opened 60 years ago by family partriarch Joe Compola and his wife Mary, Tasty Pizza has been a part of life in Lyndhurst for countless customers.
Tasty Pizza | Lyndhurst OH – Facebook
Online ordering now available for pick up and $3 dollar off for your first order online! #pizza #orderonline #chownow
Reviews
Maria Tromposch
My first time here, my husband used to work nearby 30 years ago? And would come here for lunch. The fact that they’re still here is a testament to how good the food is. The dining room is decorated with a lot of sports memorabilia it is a bit dark I think the majority of their business is carry out. It’s a very relaxed atmosphere there are coolers when you walk in and you choose your drink and choose your table place your order at the front and your food is brought to you. You go to the back of the restaurant and pick up your own dishes silverware napkins etc. Everything is definitely homemade there was a giant mixer going with pizza dough in it. Definitely recommend
… moreZac Breitbach
Some of the worst pizza I’ve ever had. At least the salad was good. Inside is very cool/old school. Wish the pizza was even mediocre.
… moreJohn L
I would like to give this quaint family establishment a better review, everyone was very friendly and polite. Unfortunately the things I enjoyed about my experience end there. Ordered a large pizza and cheesy garlic bread to eat-in. Pizza was quite expensive considering the sparse toppings it had, definitely needed more cheese. The homemade crust and sauce were quite good though. The cheesy garlic bread wasn’t quite cooked enough, again barely any cheese and what was there wasn’t quite cooked. Seemed like a great place for large groups.
… moreFwant
Possibly the most unique pizza I have ever had. I’m a truck driver that delivers next door once a week and finally got around to trying this place. the smells that come from this place remind me of my all time favorite pizza spot. first off, the people were incredibly nice. felt like a family atmosphere and I was greeted with a smile. the pizza is incredibly unique. not sure I’ve ever had anything quite like it. it’s greasy but not too heavy. I don’t want to make a fool of myself guessing what their cheese blend is but man, it’s the star of the show. the sauce was fresh and I love love love the move of putting the pepperoni under the cheese. at the end of the day this pizza was an A+. thanks for the excellent pie!
… moreThomas Ryder
Best quick lunch at a great price. The dining area is filled with legends of Cleveland sports moments. Highly recommend this anytime you can’t decide where to eat nearby.
… moreGabriel Cohen
I have had pizza all over Ohio, and I can safely say that this place is by far the best in OH! You’re greeted by super friendly people, the menu has really great options, and the food is genuinely tasty!
We ordered a meat lovers pizza with a side of garlic bread, house salad, and pasta. The food is rich in flavor and not over salted. Unlike most places and entrees, here you receive a healthy portion that will leave you well satisfied.
… moreWe ordered a meat lovers pizza with a side of garlic bread, house salad, and pasta. The food is rich in flavor and not over salted. Unlike most places and entrees, here you receive a healthy portion that will leave you well satisfied.
Susan Wagaman
Excellent Pizza…such fresh homemade ingredients. Very pleasurable staff and very reasonable prices. Great menu to choose from. Our first visit and we will become regulars.
… moreMasaki Dan
The pizza is so good. Always in time for picking up.
Thank you!
… moreThank you!
Luke DeWaal
Absolutely delicious and old school pizza joint. Love this place, highly recommend
… morekaya maghan
Ordered a large pizza from here, received very poor service from them as a man of color. They don’t greet you or say hello. They just stare and look confused as to why you are here. Maybe it’s good for non-colored individuals to eat here. But I wouldn’t support this place as a person of color with the way they treat us, and their proud of it too.
… more