Jess W
The pizza is made with fresh ingredients and bursting with flavours, not too salty when compared to most other pizza places. The dough is good, and crisp on the bottom! I have paid for much more expensive pizzas with soggy bottoms. The thickness of the crust was also perfect, just enough to enhance the flavours and thin enough to let the toppings shine.
They were very helpful on the phone and friendly when I went to pick up the order. However, I do not enjoy the garlic bread. It’s funny that they do everything else so well and their garlic bread tastes like store-bought then warmed up, thus the 4 stars in food. Otherwise, I recommend ordering from this place before the large chains/franchises. You get way better value for your money.
… moreAtaul Munim
One of the worst pizza I have tried. It was over cooked. After couple of slices my jaw was hurting as it was too hard. The toppings didn’t taste good and sauce was coming off slices like it was uncooked. I placed order via DoorDash and it was the last order from this place.
… moreRaheel
This is my favorite pizzeria in Vaughan. Tucked away in Rutherford Rd Plaza, this hidden gem is beyond special — fresh sauce and fresh dough. I have been going here since the original owner, Gerry ran the place. The new owners took over and the pies are still special, not exactly like before but getting there (especially the cheese pizza).
… moreJames Wu
The new owner is friendly and kind. The pizza was slightly over cooked but one needs to mistakes in order to improve. The dough is how remember it. Not over worked and dense like all these other chains establishments. The tomato sauce had enough tang and was not runny . The pie was not overly greasy. The cheese, and toppings was held up well with the good under carriage so it didn’t droop. Had the pizza been taken out of the oven 3-5 min earlier it would have been much better. Everything else is five stars. Just needs more practice. This establishment will always be my go to for Italian pies. Welcome to the neighborhood!
… moreMikey
Taste of Naples Pizzeria is hugely popular for locals here with many Italians in the area. The 16” pizza yielded 8 large tasty slices with a soft light pizza crust, fresh tomato sauce & good topping ingredients. Crisp thin crust bottom gave a nice finish.
This is a real Neopolitan pizza that’s a touch better than I’ve had elsewhere. Be sure to order takeout early as we encountered a queue but our pizza was ready in a timely manner. Just wait for your number to be displayed outside before heading in-store to pickup.
… moreThomas Mudronja
I’ve been coming to this hidden gem for a couple of years now. The old owner said he was shutting down the business a few months ago, then he told me the last time I came a new owner will be taking over but he told me the pizzas will be the same.
I’m happy to say the pizzas are just as good as before. This is by far my favourite pizza spot.
The hours are even better now with the new owner.
Best take out pizza in the GTA !!!
… moreNaz.Flâneur
This place is the true definition of a hidden gem!
I ordered the 16-slice classic Italian pizza with garlic dipping sauce, and it was an absolute pleasure. The flavors were savory and delicious. Count me in as a regular customer!
… moreMar
Best New York style pizza I’ve had.
First ate from here at Pizza Fest – hands down the best stall at the festival.
We’ve since visited this pizzeria a bunch of times. It’s a bit of a drive for us but it’s so worth it.
My favourite part is the rich quality herbed tomato sauce.
The crust is perfectly thin and crisp. Thin in the middle and then airy at the edges. Was surprised to taste and find caraway seeds in it – which adds such a nice flavour and texture!
Their cheese is nice and gooey too.
And their garlic dip takes it to another level for me, it really brings out the brightness in that tomato sauce.
The man who runs this place alone is a true pizza artisan, a must try!
… morePetra H
I’ve been coming here for years and was sad to hear that the old owner was leaving last year. The new owner is just as amazing. Very good customer service and the pizza is just as I remember it being! There is absolutely no difference. This is my favourite pizza spot in the GTA! I highly recommend you check this place out you will not be disappointed.
… moreSC
If you want simple, satisfying and delicious pizza, this is the place! I have ordered many times from this place, usually with cheese, mushrooms and pepperoni or cheese with olives. Their pizza is cooked to perfection, they use special flour for their crust and it’s a nice flavor, they bake it super fluffy and nicely toasted. Sauce, cheese and other ingredients are well balance. Always satisfy after having their pizza.
I will say, their pizzas beats many fancy gourmet pizza places. No need fancy toppings, just a simple pizza with quality ingredients and made with care. So good. 🙂
… more