Savor the fusion of classic comfort and Italian-American cuisine in Milwaukee! Enjoy crispy, tender textures with every bite. Experience warm, hearty flavors delivered to your door or ready for pickup. Place your online order now for a memorable dining experience!
Address and Contact Information
Address: 2577 S 68th St, Milwaukee, WI 53219
Phone: (414) 545-5373
Website: https://tarantinospizzadelivery.com/
Order and Reservations
Order: Order online
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Order Authentic Pizza Online | Tarantino’s Pizzeria – Pickup or …
Tarantino’s Italian-American Delights … Discover the heart of Italy at Tarantino’s Pizzeria in Milwaukee! Our menu offers delicious Italian and Pizza creations, …
Tarantino’s – Milwaukee, WI – 2577 S 68th St – Hours, Menu, Order
Get 5% off your pizza delivery order – View the menu, hours, address, and photos for Tarantino’s in Milwaukee, WI. Order online for delivery or pickup on …
Tarantino’s – 2577 S 68th St, Milwaukee, WI 53219 – Slice
Cheese Pizza. Classic cheese or create your own pizza. $6.65. $6.32 ; Cheese & Pepperoni Pizza. Classic cheese and pepperoni. $7.45. $7.08 ; BBQ Chicken Pizza.
Last Updates
Reviews
Sandy Stack
The only thing that saved Tarantino pizza from me calling and reaming them out, was the delivery driver. I didn’t catch her name but she was very sweet. Other than that, the food is trash. My calamari was so rubbery it was disappointing. My meatball sub was so soggy I couldn’t even eat it. The motz sticks tasted like they have been sitting out for days. I will never order from here again and am very sorry that I ordered from here.
… moreRachael Mueller
I have found it disturbing to observe on multiple occations the owner/chef walking into the front door with his large German Shepherd dog…which would explain the smell inside. I believe this restaurant (seems more like a home) should be inspected.
… moreSaraya
Be so fr…this place is ABSOLUTELY FILTHY. Order here on accident as I usually get Taninos and WOW, the smell when you walk in is like filty house smell, dusty, dirty, open containers in kitchen. One bite of the pizza and it was a hard no. How a pizza have NO SMELL OR TASTE? Just like WAT? Employees seemed to be doing the best with what they had, overall nice people. Pizza went in the trash where it belongs.
… morelaura davis
The bread and mushrooms I ordered were not even edible. They went straight to the trash. The pizza was disgusting and not cooked in the middle. I thought I was ordering from Tanino’s. My mistake I mix the two up. I will never order from this place ever again.
… moreAJ Johnson
Every time I’ve ordered tarantino’s it has been amazing but this time was disgustingly disappointing. I spent $50 on a pizza, breaded cauliflower, and 2 cannoli. The pizza was burnt around the entire crust edge but somehow cold, soggy, and borderline raw throughout the rest. It looked and tasted like the canadian bacon was added after it was “cooked”. I ate a couple bites of a small piece and put it back in the box. My boyfriend ate one piece and left the others he grabbed untouched on his plate. The breaded cauliflower was cold and not fried thoroughly so it was nearly raw cauliflower in a fried breading. The cannoli was the only thing that was edible. I talked this place up so much telling my boyfriend how good the food is… but this was a horrible way for him to experience it. Completely ruined my opinion of the restaurant and I doubt I’ll order from them again. Waste of $50.
… moreScyber
Locally owned mom & pop restaurant. Classic Milwaukee style thin crust and taste. Their sub sandwiches on seeded Italian bread are my favorite – make sure to get em with cheese.
EDIT (2022) – This place is even BETTER than the last time I reviewed them! Pizza & garlic bread plus pizza bread were delivered in less than half the time I was quoted!
If you’re looking for that classic Milwaukee style pizza, this is the best in the area! Tastes very similar to Papa Stu’s & Maria’s (RIP to both).
… moreEDIT (2022) – This place is even BETTER than the last time I reviewed them! Pizza & garlic bread plus pizza bread were delivered in less than half the time I was quoted!
If you’re looking for that classic Milwaukee style pizza, this is the best in the area! Tastes very similar to Papa Stu’s & Maria’s (RIP to both).
Deena Stange
Excellent tasting Thin Crust Pizza, Love the crust. 1st time customer and I will definitely be going back. Used to be a Maria’s, Papa Luigis, and Pepi’s Pizza Person, now Tarantino’s Pizzeria will get my business when I want to pick up or have my pizza delivered, since they do NOT have any seating. This Pizza Restaurant is Pick up or Delivery ONLY. If you like thin crust Pizza I’d definitely recommend you give this Longstanding Family Run Pizza Place a try!
… moreBigJsgarage w
I ordered 18″ pizza and got a 16″ I called and told them. The guy tells me that can not be the guy who made the pizza has been doing for 30 years. So I tell him well I am holding a tape measure on it and it reads 16″. Ok I will talk to him about it later.He acted like he really did not care and never offered to do anything about it. Here is the kicker they some how sent me a 18″ pizza in a 16″ box as seen in picture. First and last thing I ever buy from there.
… moreClifford Goldsmith
The worst pizza I’ve ever had so undercooked it went straight to the garbage
… moreJesus Reeves
Got to try the spaghetti w/ sauce last night because as I soon as I walked in the house from work, my daughter handed me her to-go container that her grandma got for her, saying it was nasty and the noodles were hard…
Well, she’s pretty picky and I was hungry, so I decided to try it…. Yeah, wow, she was right! It was basically noodles with canned tomato paste and some herbs tossed in…. It was extremely bland and tasteless. Zero flavor. And dry as hell. Not even dousing it with Parmesan could save it….
I got through about 3/4 of the container(I was hungry) and had to stop. Honestly, I’d be ashamed to serve that to customers if I owned this place. It was probably the worst spaghetti with sauce I’ve ever had from any restaurant. It was bad….
If you want a good quick spaghetti from a restaurant, I highly recommend Tanino’s on 76th. That’s where we usually go for takeout spaghetti. FAR better!
… moreWell, she’s pretty picky and I was hungry, so I decided to try it…. Yeah, wow, she was right! It was basically noodles with canned tomato paste and some herbs tossed in…. It was extremely bland and tasteless. Zero flavor. And dry as hell. Not even dousing it with Parmesan could save it….
I got through about 3/4 of the container(I was hungry) and had to stop. Honestly, I’d be ashamed to serve that to customers if I owned this place. It was probably the worst spaghetti with sauce I’ve ever had from any restaurant. It was bad….
If you want a good quick spaghetti from a restaurant, I highly recommend Tanino’s on 76th. That’s where we usually go for takeout spaghetti. FAR better!