Rowan Hawkins
Taffy’s is Cash Only. Prices are up like everywhere else. I’m attaching 2025 menu pics for updated pricing. I always get shakes when I visit stands like this. After Tax, a Regular shake was $9. They only had whole milk available and it tasted like vanilla softserve was in the shake. I kinda hoped that since they sell coffee icecream that a coffee shake would be made with that. Dissapointed that it is not. I didn’t try the food, but saw on another order that the fries are super skinny which isn’t how I prefer them. That didn’t affect my rating.
… moreEric Green
Cute spot for lunch and ice cream that has been in business since the 50s. Stopped by around 1pm on a Friday afternoon and there were plenty of people lounging on their cool swinging tables enjoying traditional American fare such as fries, hamburgers, and milkshakes. I couldn’t get over the swinging tables, such a unique way to enjoy food with the family. I had the buffalo chicken sandwich, fried cauliflower, and a root beer float. This is a cash only restaurant, so make sure to plan for that. Everything was nicely prepared and service was courteous and quick. I would definitely stop by again to try some of the other treats on the menu.
… moreMorgan Olsen
Milkshake are always great. Decided to try the chili cheese hot dogs today and highly disappointed. The hotdogs have a hard skin on them and mine came with a piece of plastic on it and an onion under it. I didn’t order mine with onion. And the cheese sauce tastes.. off.. well be back for milkshakes but definitely won’t get food there again.
… moreKyle Encarnacion
One of my favorite places to go for a shake! There’s an insane amount of unique flavors/mixes. I would highly recommend the grasshopper(GSC) the vibe is very relaxed with ample amount of seating on swinging/rocking chairs! Also had a tasty foot long hotdog. The workers were very nice even though we came pretty close to closing.
… moreAidan Bain
If you want to get a hot dog, a burger, or any of the endless combinations of milkshakes, Taffy’s is the place. This is a place that’s got a 50s vibe that can’t be beat.
… moreBill Hanifin
65 years? 71?
Nah, this is the 76th year for Taffy’s and it’s only getting better.
You and your kids will never have a happier meal than when you’re on the swings on a sunny day with a KellyTough Milkshake in your hand.
Shop. Dine. Enjoy. Local.
#UdderlyMoolicious
#OrchardPark #GoBills
… moreT. Burke
The hot dog had a good char, crisp bite and nice flavor. You can also bury it in toppings if you prefer. The milk shake (Malted Bailey’s Cream) was perfectly blended and easy to drink.
… moreLori McDermott
Used to be THE place to go for a hotdog. The quality of food has gone down. Steak hoagie was not steak and it was topped with orange creamy stuff when it should be provolone or asked if they normally use something different. The shoestring fries were dripping with grease. We did not enjoy our food.
… moreJessica Heart
Definitely lived up to its reputation! Got a regular funky monkey(chocolate+banana+peanut butter), Italian sausage hotdog and curly fries with an add-on of chilli. The milkshake was creamy and delicious, one of the best milkshakes I’ve had by far. The dog was juicy and flavorful. The fries were okay but it gets a 5 star regardless!
… moreNov C
Taffy’s is one of my favorite places for Milkshake. There are more than 60 flavors to choose from and you will be tempted to try them all!! I love the Mango Blast milkshake..yum!
… more