Social Profile: 
… View more
Charming counter-serve providing classic & original flavors of ice cream & toppings.
Address and Contact Information
Address: 11925 S Strang Line Rd, Olathe, KS 66062
Phone: (913) 393-3500
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Related Web Results
Sylas and Maddy’s Homemade Ice Cream
11925 S. Strang Line Rd. Olathe, KS 66062. 913.393.3500. 1101 Massachusetts St. Lawrence, KS 66044. 785.832.8323 …
Menu – Sylas and Maddy’s Homemade Ice Cream
… Back To Top. Sylas and Maddy’s Homemade Ice Cream, 11925 S Strang Line Rd, Olathe, KS, 66062, United States913.393.3500. Powered by Squarespace.
Our Story – Sylas and Maddy’s Homemade Ice Cream
Sylas and Maddy’s Homemade Ice Cream has been a Kansas City favorite since 1997. We first opened in Lawrence, followed by the second store in Olathe in 1999.
Reviews
Lori Adams
Well, I’m gonna have to come back and get the ice cream flight with six scoops… that way, I can try all the flavors that I want. I started with the peanut butter and it was !!There are so many delicious ones here and the ice cream is very creamy. It’s advertised as homemade. I don’t know the details on that but it sure tastes good. The staff was very nice. Plenty of clean places to sit and enjoy your ice cream. We will be back!!
… moreWesley Schick
Hands down the best ice cream you will ever have! I LOVE this place! They have tons of flavors, waffle cones, shakes and you can buy your favorite flavor in a pint or gallon to take home! My personal favorite is a cookie monster shake with whipped cream and a vanilla wafer. Try this place if you are an ice cream lover. You won’t regret it!
… moreKyle Lawson
I tried this place for the first time today. The store was clean, the employees were friendly, and the best part is the ice cream was decently normal. I hate places that try to create such weird flavor combos. The waffle cone was perfectly crispy and sweet without being too dry. The medium size cone was massive, but the price was still only about $5. I will definitely be returning.
… moreStan Georgakopoulos
This place has the best ice cream period. I have had ice cream coast to coast, and this is the absolute best. The next best place is the Plush Horse in the southwest suburbs of Chicago called Palos Park.
… moreCassidy Kuehl
Visited after going out to eat and it was exactly what I needed! The ice cream was delicious and I highly recommend! I wasn’t a fan of how expensive I felt the ice cream was for the amount I got, but I’ll likely be back! I will say I think it would have been helpful if an employee would have gone through the options they provided as there was a lot of overwhelming information provided while looking at the menu, as after I got my order, I noticed they did ice cream sandwiches and I definitely would have got an ice cream sandwich if I’d known it was an option. But overall it’s a great place to enjoy family and friends while enjoying a sweet treat and I will be back!
… moreBryan Terry
This is a cute little place with GREAT ice cream! My family really enjoyed trying a couple of their unique flavors. Everyone working was super friendly and helpful too. Delicious, I would recommend stopping by!
… morestephan mathis
The ice cream was delicious and they have many flavors to choose from. I’ll definitely be coming back here to try more flavors. I got the strawberry cheesecake & apple pie, they both were really good!
… moreN A
Pros:
(1) Very large menu selection
(2) Fun sounding flavor combinations
(3) Large portion sizes (medium ice cream scoop is all you need)
(4) The waffle cones smell amazing and are very thick
Cons:
(1) The flavors are just missing something – like sugar. The ice cream (Maddy’s Mud) didn’t taste all that much like coffee or chocolate or brownies, and the waffle cones were just fairly plain, as if sugar was forgotten to be added when creating the cone. Overall, the ice cream + cone was simply not sweet as you’d expect (one of us described it as “like a thick fortune cookie”)
… more(1) Very large menu selection
(2) Fun sounding flavor combinations
(3) Large portion sizes (medium ice cream scoop is all you need)
(4) The waffle cones smell amazing and are very thick
Cons:
(1) The flavors are just missing something – like sugar. The ice cream (Maddy’s Mud) didn’t taste all that much like coffee or chocolate or brownies, and the waffle cones were just fairly plain, as if sugar was forgotten to be added when creating the cone. Overall, the ice cream + cone was simply not sweet as you’d expect (one of us described it as “like a thick fortune cookie”)
Lei Francisco
We were told this is a great local ice cream shop. And YES, it is so good. The staff there were super patient with us as it took forever for all of us to pick the delicious flavors we wanted most! The ice cream textures were so creamy and rich! YUM!
… moreAthena Haley
Awesome ice cream shop with lots of flavors to choose from. We went on father’s day, there was a long line but they did a great job keeping it moving! The waffle cones were also very good!
… more